Saxy S's Reviews

Hopefully this review doesn't get started off on the wrong foot and pisses off too many metal purists, but here it goes... I've never really cared for Sepultura.

Now granted, I never listened to Sepultura until much, MUCH later into my lifetime; probably around the time I started college which would have been ten years ago. I always thought their music was decent, certainly better than super early Slayer, but their music has just never been that recognizable in the same way as a band like... Testament or Kreator.

Now I will give Quadra some credit: this is the most interesting Sepultura album since Roots, regardless of what that might mean for some. This album has some genuine heart put into it and you can tell through the songwriting and album structure. Tracks like "Capital Enslavement" and "Guardians of Earth" lead you on some pretty great musical experiences, rather than just a straight up mosh-fest.

Some of these ideas sound like they are borrowing from technical thrash metal, but not necessarily in the way that I would typically soak in. This is technical/progressive music in the vein of Meshuggah, in which some technically proficient and very impressive percussion work masks the fact that the guitars are just chugging some open strings endlessly. Make no mistake, this is still very much thrash/groove Sepultura that anybody who knows anything about this group will be accepting of.

So what the hell then is "Agony of Defeat"? It's slow, groovy as f*ck, melodically enthralling from both the vocalist and lead guitar, and the main heavy groove is so damn thick; I fully expect to hear it in a "Try Not To Headbang" challenge on YouTube in the near future. It almost sounds like the band wanted a redo of their crossover appeal tat happened with Roots, but with a more natural Sepultura sound. The album ends with "Fear, Pain, Chaos, Suffering", which basically just sounds like a love letter to Pantera. And come on, who wouldn't fall to their knees for something like that?

In summary, Quadra is Sepultura's best album since Chaos A.D. and it sees the band taking a different road than the one they helped pave back in the day. I remember hearing snippets of progressive tendencies beginning to sneak their way into this bands sound in 2017 with Machine Messiah, but I had no idea that it might very well become their new niche. 

The sophomore album from Belgian thrashers Bütcher is a nonstop assault of thrash metal tendencies in the vein of early style Slayer. For some, that will be an easy sell. But for others (myself included), not so much. This album, to put it lightly, is incredibly one dimensional. Yes, the group can play blazing fast grooves and keep up the intensity for a long period of time. But I found myself becoming drained and less interested the longer the album went on. I was surprised when the title track came on, since it borrows a lot from black metal and turned out to be the best track on the album. Not just because it was the longest song on the album, but because its composition was rewarding and left me looking to play it again.

Now this album is produced a lot better than a 1980s Slayer album; The bass lines are fluent and powerful, the guitar work is crisp and precise, the percussion is absolutely ridiculous, while the vocals are probably more inline with the more black metal leaning thrash bands. Think Bathory or perhaps even Vektor.

Honestly, I don't really have much to say about 666 Goats Carry My Chariot. For what it is, this album is a very serviceable thrash metal album that will wow based on its technical proficiency alone. But again, it's a one dimensional listen. If you are looking for any nuance or development, you won't find it here. The title track is a wonderful song and I look to keep it in my rotation for a while, but the rest of the album is hit or miss for me. Maybe in smaller doses, not as apart of a full album, would these tracks resonate better.

When you think of rap rock, I'm sure most of us probably think of nu-metal and the horrible stench left by bands such as Limp Bizkit, Slipknot, Linkin Park among others. But those roots are actually entrenched in metal long before nu-metal became big in the late 90s/early 2000s. Faith No More started, and then there was Rage Against the Machine (RATM). They were clearly influenced by punk rock, but that didn't stop them from getting pretty damn heavy.

Starting off with "Killing In The Name", these riffs are filthy. Tom Morello takes the instrument and does things with it that you might have expected to hear on a Joe Satriani or Steve Vai album. And because of this, the bass lines are plentiful and give this album some incredible rhythm. If I may use a term that we use a lot in funk, these grooves are fat. Zach de la Rocha genuinely sounds pissed on this track as he howls the lyrics (and that's before the final chorus). 

And this carries on throughout the album. "Take The Power Back", "Bullet In The Head", "Know Your Enemy" and "Wake Up" are awesome standouts. They are anthemic and ballsy as well. So why does it work? Well, compared to many other rap-rock bands that came later, the lyricism is not littered with men in their twenties/thirties who still act like children. The drama is petty and very immature. RATM meanwhile, are political revolutionaries, perhaps even more so than the heaviest hardcore punk bands: Dead Kennedys, Descendants, hell even Discharge and Husker Du. And rap is the only way in which they can make their message. And they have to; there is no subtlety on display here. This might be one of the most blunt and in your face politically charged albums ever made.

For the reasons mentioned above, this album can be a tough sell to a lot of people. It also does make for a very challenging listening experience, even if you are prepared for it. It isn't a brutal record, but it is poignant, anthemic, and it can start one hell of a pit. It's too bad what rap-metal would become later on, but this album still slaps and a stark reminder of what this genre could sound like.

Well power metal doesn’t seem to be off to a blazing start in 2020, so we are going to talk about Temperance, an Italian based power metal band that might make the B listers in the power metal pyramid. They have always been about two steps behind their influences (Within Temptation, Nightwish, etc.), but did make prominent steps forward in 2018 on Of Jupiter and Moons after almost half the band was substituted for. So did they make any more improvements on Viridian? Are they in the A tier of power metal?

Well… no. Viridian is a serviceable power metal record that will certainly make their audience happy and tide them over until Nightwish release their new album later this year, but I wouldn’t be surprised if it’s forgotten about in record time after.

The production is pretty lackluster on this album; the synth choices are very blocky and don’t mesh well with most songs. The guitars are loud and near the front of the mix, but never give way for any nuance or subtlety. The bass parts are practically non-existent, and the parts of the vocals that I can hear over the guitars sound promising enough, but once again, they are very quiet in the overall mixing.

The other big issue is the songwriting. All of these songs follow the same formula of verse/chorus/bridge, followed by a key change final chorus and outro. Don’t get me wrong, I love a good key change, but most of these songs don’t deserve their key change since they never evolve from the very start. This album is quite formulaic overall.

I mean it isn’t bad, but I won’t return to this very much. Temperance are just one producer away from really clicking with me and becoming one of the elite tier names in modern power metal.

This is the debut album from a black metal band hailing from Guangdong, China and it's pretty damn effective. Six tracks (basically five since "Hermit" serves as an interlude) of pure, aggressive black metal with a distinctly Chinese twist. The songwriting on this album is pretty damn excellent; the guitar play on these tracks is memorable and engaging. The bass does have a little bit of a problem projecting throughout, but that seems mostly because of its lack of unique and separate lines from the rhythm guitar. The drum work on this album is pretty over the top and very impressive. The vocals are probably my least favourite part of the album since they do sound like they are being filtered through studio effects, as well the overall timbre of the shrieking style has never truly been my thing to begin with. They remind me more in the vein of a band like The Black Dahlia Murder.

But I can look over these vocals because, once again, where this album separates itself from so many other black metal albums are in the song constructions. This unique brand of East Asian oriental instrumentation, including flutes and guzheng is one of a kind in heavy metal in 2020 as far as I can tell. And they are wonderfully incorporated into the heavier sections; there is a section on "Rainy Night Carnage" in which the guzheng is given an extended solo and whoever is playing it does their best shredding impression. I do have to dock some points however because almost all of these songs do follow a very similar formula with their ambient, nature introductions before exploding into the metal ideas. 

But hell yeah I can jive to this! Maybe with time the band can do something about the vocal mixing, as well as come up with some more original ideas, but this is a very solid debut record and I'm looking forward to seeing what these guys can do next.

Another year, another Thy Catafalque album, and another great one at that. This Hungarian band has been the pillar of consistency over the last ten years and have always done a wonderful job of blending. This album blends together progressive rock/metal alongside Hungarian classical/folk music, as well as electronic elements. The hooks are as wonderful as ever, the instrumentals themselves are some of the best in recent Thy Catafalque's discography, and the counterpoint between the vocal timbres makes for a truly wonderful storytelling experience. This album never feels self indulgent even through the multitude of different places this album visits. This band is one of the most unique bands in metal right now and this was a pleasure to listen to. What a great way to start off the new year and with luck, hopefully the rest of this year can follow this up.

This is the debut album from Grimah, a black metal band hailing from Spain. And I do want to be a little more favorable towards this initial project because I can hear plenty of potential on display, even if it doesn't live up to the expectations.

For one, this album sounds really damn great! The guitar work is luscious and downright breathtaking at times. These songs have a tendency to fall into the melodic black metal side of things and can even border on the fringes of atmospheric black metal near the end. The bass lines are not flawless and they do tend to bow out more frequently than one would expect.

The vocalist needs work. Kellicos sounds like he's performing through a cold and is unable to hold many of his notes for extended periods of time without cracking. I think that this is the part that needs refinement. Think about what the faux spoken word delivery of a Rotting Christ album could sound like. It doesn't even have to be changing the vocal style all that much. It would only improve the performances that much more!

The songwriting is commendable, even if it does get a tad bit boring during the middle of the album. I really enjoyed the opener, "Blaze Against Grime", but then "Thus Spake The Stone" and "Veiled By Blossom's Essence" both sound like they not only treading water, but are also extended in their length. It wasn't until the next track "Façade of Futile Reflections" delivered a quasi doom metal extended intro that carried into the more expected black metal stuff. While the closer "Pénudo de Agonía y Desdén" is pure ABM bliss. It sounds unique for the record and warrants its ten minute runtime.

This album has plenty of flaws, but I can look over them for now in hopes that they can be reconciled on further releases. I hope that Grimah is a name that we hear about in metal for years to come.

Yep, this is a power metal record with all of the over the top mythological lyricism that one might expect. This album has a nice variety of styles and ideas, highlighted by its duality of male and female vocalists. The male performs in in a half sung, half scream delivery that is interesting, if a little grading at times, reminiscent of a band like Overkill or Kreator. The female vocals are clean and expansive and make up the best portions of this album on their own. When the two voices sing together, it sounds very decent, such as on "Kaunaz Dagaz", the title track and "Ride of the Valkyries".

The music on this album is very strong power metal, if a little redundant. But I am a sucker for this kind of stuff. It's produced very well and I'm a big fan of the melodic songwriting throughout. Such standouts include the tunes mentioned earlier, as well as "Hel", "Powersnake" and "Njord". The guitar work is fluent as well as the bass having a greater presence than has come to be expected from this style of music in the modern day. The percussion sounds great, even if it doesn't feel very memorable.

This is solid enough power metal to start off the year 2020. I'm not sure how long it will stick around, but it's a very solid album to tide you over until we get our first great metal album of the year. 

Kawir's blend of melodic black metal, combined with some of the traditional pagan elements of Greek folk music is certainly an interesting experience for someone who has never heard it before. The album sounds quite excellent most of the time. The percussion element is this album's strongest element; some of the drum work on this record is pretty ridiculous. As for the bass, you can't really hear much of it. This is very much a black metal album in the traditional sense of the phrase, in which rhythm guitars are used as replacements for organic, warm bass lines. Which is a shame because when the guitars are given a lead passage, they do sound quite good. The lead guitar on "Atalanti" and "Medea" are very strong. The vocals are also quite prominent and are produced / performed very well.

The songwriting on this record isn't quite great. This album does tread a little long at times, and this is mostly in part due to some very repetitive motifs that are never developed, with "Colchis" being the most egregious example. "Danaides" is not too far behind. But most of all, these songs don't fully embrace the pagan and folk influences that they should. They are used sparingly and in isolated fragments, rather than as an integral part of the sound. It reminds me a lot of Obsequaie's The Palms of Sorrowed Kings from late last year. Other pagan black metal bands like Drudkh and Saor have nothing to worry about.

As it stands, Adrasteia is a pretty decent record in terms of its black metal core, but fails to really deliver outside of that. 

Deftones were one of the first metal bands that I ever listened to, although in hindsight that probably wasn't a very good choice. For a "nu-metal" record, this is one of the least sounding nu-metal records that came out of that time period. Sure it does have its clear influences in the genre, but this has more in common with late 90s to early 2000s post-hardcore.

And how does it hold up? Well, surprisingly well, even if the Deftones themselves have moved further and further away from the nu-metal influences of their early years in the time since. And there is a reason why; it's because nu-metal hasn't aged very well.

The moments on this album that portray the most anger and frustration are typically its worst elements. "Rickets" and "Headup" highlight this albums least entertaining moments, as the bass is swamped out and replaced exclusively by chugging, rhythmic guitars, to the point where one wonders whether or not this album actually needed a drummer. I also have a problem with Chino as a performer. Whenever he dips into his softer almost whisper like delivery, it almost always seems to be paired with a clipping vocal effect that emphasizes some of his harsher syllables. 

But the first half of this record does make up for some of the second half's faults. "My Own Summer (Shove It)" has a great exchange of ideas and play styles, "Around The Fur" has a pretty sticky guitar melody, and "Be Quiet And Drive (Far Away)" is the most melodic track on the album and one of the standout moments. Chino's cleans are very enjoyable and his screams are usually paired with genuine frustration.

I think that for a nu-metal album, Around the Fur has the potential to be one of the best albums of that descriptor... if the Deftones actually decided to make a nu-metal album. But I still don't think that they did. And going back and listening to it again, I still feel that this record is more of a post-hardcore album with nu-metal tendencies. It's still a good album, but not a great one. Deftones would wait a couple more years to release their magnum opus, but this album helped to get them there.

An early taste of atmospheric black metal / blackgaze in 2020 with a solo Hungarian artist who doesn’t mind adding in some folk elements along the way. I think that this album has some very interesting ideas associated with it, but the execution of those ideas hold this album back from greatness.

For starters, the poetry on this album is wonderful. I am a really big fan of the word painting and general ambiguity of the lyrics, which leave the door open for plenty of interpretation. The song “Havasok / Snowy Mountains” goes so far as to borrow from Hungarian folklore and becomes very regional. It’s pretty cool to hear. “Danu’s Tears”, “Mist Pillars ‘19” and “Dark Waters” all follow suit with some great storytelling.

The production on this album is pretty hit or miss. For one, the incorporation of traditional Hungarian instruments is used very well on the second half of this album, especially with the bagpipes on the atmospheric, instrumental closer “Wilderness”. Beyond that, the vocalist, which is very far in the back of the mix, could have been given a lot more presence given what I mentioned earlier about this albums poetry.

The general sound of this album however is… not good. The guitars are way too compressed for this style of music and the bass gets the short end of the stick because of it. The softer sections on tracks like “Mist Pillars ‘19” and “Havasok / Snowy Mountains” sound great, but the clean / acoustic guitars are louder than the distorted, heavier stuff.

This album does deserve a better fate. This kind of folk metal that is literally based off of Hungarian folklore should be right up my alley, but is held back considerably by its lackluster production. If this sounded better, it could have been great. As it is, Dark Waters is decent, but it could have been made better by some chlorine.

Well, it looks like 2020 is starting off the same way that 2019 ended, so welcome to controversial hot takes with me, saxystephens.

Granted I don’t know how long this will last since this album is a very weak #1. Poppy’s newest album, I Disagree, is a test in sanity. Perhaps being able to stay steady as this album ferociously flails you across the room with its whiplash. Perhaps it’s patience in Poppy to find a hook to make these songs memorable. Perhaps it’s patience in me trying to find a critically acclaimed album that I actually like!

This album is hard to get through and most of it has to do with all of the influences Poppy tries to fit into this ten track, thirty-five minute album, as she tries to infuse pop music with metalcore, industrial, and nu-metal. She already tried this on Am I A Girl? A couple of years ago, and it got her a record deal with Sumerian!

This wouldn’t be a problem on its own if it was backed by the same artistic prowess (i.e. hooks) that made Poppy Computer such a great album. Instead, it sounds formulaic to modern metal. The hooks are sparse, Poppy’s vocals are not remotely engaging in the same way as many of her clear influences from Japanese metal are, and the songwriting has taken a massive step down. The mixing between pop and metal transitions is poorly executed. And it's redundant at times; “Anything Like Me” sounds like it stole the instrumental straight from Billie Eilish’s “bury a friend”.

Songs like “Nothing I Need” and “Sick of the Sun” are acceptable pop songs, while “Concrete” is an okay hybrid of styles, and “Fill the Crowd” has the best blend of styles as well as hooks on the album. The rest just sounds unfinished. We already had a great rock/pop hybrid album come out last year with A Boat on the Sea by Moron Police. Why couldn't we have gotten that huge instead?

As a complete pleb when it comes to the band Emperor, I had to go into Ihsahn's solo project with a pair of fresh ears. I had no expectations as to what to expect from Ihsahn at the start of the decade. And what I found is that Ihsahn has a metric f*ck tonne of achieved potential that I feel like was never tapped into under the Emperor name. 

Oh they came close with Prometheus, but unfortunately for the band, it would be their final official studio album before the calling it quits. And it's clear to me that Ihsahn was the primary songwriter behind Prometheus because this album is beautiful. The way in which this album effortlessly transitions back and forth between harsh and clean vocals, atmosphere and technicality, soft and aggressive; this album has it all and set the benchmark for Ihsahn as well as black metal in general at the turn of the decade. The way in which saxophone is incorporated into these compositions is brilliant. Even when it is used over a heavier passage, it is still prominent in the mix. This is about as close as I've heard to a saxophone shredding like its guitar counterpart.

Without all of the additional madness taking place in the instrumental, Ihsahn's vocals take center stage and they are prominent. You can literally hear every word on this album. You don't need to have the lyric sheet in front of you to understand every word and what these lyrics are saying, which is itself a glorious achievement.

All in all, Ihsahn's 2010 epic is a magnum opus to behold in the black metal community. Almost everything is tuned with the finest brush. It takes a lot of work for me to call both 10 minute tracks my two favourites on the album. Ihsahn proceeded to have a very solid decade, but never lived up to the sky high potential that was put on display with After. This is something truly special. If you enjoy progressive black metal, you are doing yourself a disservice by omitting this from your collection.

I truthfully don't have a lot to say about this album. What I will say however is that High on Fire had themselves a very impressive 2010s. They were one of the decades most consistent bands who just kept making killer music. And their music was impressive; stoner/sludge metal with a hint of thrash thrown in on top of it all to make it super dense and encapsulating. I'm not much of a stoner myself, but this album is so easy to get lost in even if you are sober, which makes for a truly transcendent experience.

This album is heavy, relentless and unforgiving, which does lead me to one of its biggest strengths: its precision. This record doesn't sound like it was recorded in the drummers basement late on a Tuesday night. It's very clean and very easy to digest. I know that Matt Pike is a legend in the sludge metal scene, and this album is proof of that for me. Very solid stuff.

I vividly remember seeing The Faceless perform live along with The HAARP Machine in St. Catherines, Ontario in 2013. And while I was mostly there to hear the opening act, I was familiar with The Faceless from their album Planetary Duality. I remember them playing "Accelerated Evolution" and liking what I heard that I had to go back home after and find their album that song was on. So, I actually saw this band play live before ever listening to one of their albums in full.

Anyways, here's Autotheism, one of the better albums to split the difference between the melodic side of progressive metal, and the more punishing insanity of technical death metal. This album is all over the place production wise. And most of it comes in the percussion. And it's a shame because it's also in the one place that I have consistently criticized tech death for: the bass drum. When this album gets locked into a double bass groove, or a technical section where guitar and drums are in unison, it gets very loud and messes with the mixing of the remainder of the performers.

Still, songs like "Accelerated Evolution", "Autotheist Movement III: Deconsecrate" and "Ten Billion Years" all sound quite good, even excellent. And of course, to fit my namesake, when the saxophone comes in during "Deconsecrate", I really enjoyed it. I wish that it could have been projected more; sometimes the sax gets buried underneath the guitar backgrounds.

Technical Death Metal is still not my thing, but I can appreciate when it is done well. And The Faceless do create very solid tech death that doesn't rely on blazing fast song structures to cover up for unfinished songwriting. Good stuff.

I was looking forward to hearing this: an atmospheric black metal band that borrows from bands like Summoning with symphonic and Celtic flare in it as well. Too bad the album sounds terrible!

The guitars sound like they are being recorded in 8-bit; almost like what you would expect heavy metal to sound like if it was coming out of your NES. Actually, when the opening track, "City of Azure Fire" started and I heard those woodwinds for the first time, I had to do a double take because those woodwinds to me, were unmistakable. That is the same melody that plays during a game of Age of Empires II. It wasn't exactly the same, but it was really damn close.

This album is corny as hell and not in the good way. This is meant to be listened to with masks off and something real and authentic, but all I hear is a bunch of trolling. Not a good way to start your career.

Album of the Decade? Not Quite

If you were to ask me what the most important albums of the decade were; the ones that we can look back on in another ten years from now and say "that's what the 2010s were all about!" I would assume most people would say Behemoth's The Satanist somewhere in their top ten. And I would have to agree. This album is pretty filthy blackened death metal that someone like me would come to appreciate. It doesn't sound sloppy or unfinished. The production is solid and Nergal's vocal delivery is some of the best it has been in Behemoth's entire discography.

However, Behemoth are a band that have been doing this shtick for a long time and it should come as no surprise to anyone. Ghost get a lot of flack for being a satantic worship cult even though their music is way too safe and mainstream. If normies are worried about cults, this is the group that they should be worried about! But where Behemoth falls short of Ghost is those grooves and hooks that are desperately lacking.Most people who listen to this won't need them and I can understand. But outside of some great riffage and technical proficiency, this album just lacks the core to keep me coming back.

This isn't a bad record. In fact, it's pretty damn excellent. I just wish that Behemoth could do something more with the genre, the subject matter and the songwriting than this. Behemoth created this album almost as a jumping on point into death metal and it serves its purpose surprisingly well. But I like my melodic metal, which does make me feel isolated from the rest of the crowd at times, but I'll stick with Omnium Gatherum, Insomnium, and Scar Symmetry.

When a band loses an integral member due to untimely death, it seems like an impossible task to replace them. Avenged Sevenfold dealt with this is 2009 with the passing of their drummer Jimmy "The Rev" Sullivan. After Mike Portnoy filled in for the remainder of that tour, Brooks Wackerman took over in 2015 and the band would release one of their most diverse albums of their careers. One of the reasons I will never fully respect Slipknot ever again is because of how poorly they treated touring bassist, Donnie Steele after the passing of Paul Gray.

The same can be said for Alice in Chains after the passing of Layne Stayley. William Duvall was tasked with attempting to win back all of those people who enjoyed this band during the 1990s who would, inevitably, call it half-assed Alice in Chains and that it would never be as good as Dirt or the self titled album. 2009 was proof of that with Black Gives Way to Blue, a serviceable record that lacked the sort of growth that one would hope from an artist with almost fifteen years layover.

So what did Alice in Chains do in 2013 with The Devil Put Dinosaurs Here? How about creating the most unique AiC album that changed the direction of the band completely, but also established this as not being Layne Stayley's group anymore. And while I will admit, this album did not click with me right away, but going back and listening to it again years later, I think it helps appreciate Rainier Fog even more when you see where many of the bones were planted (pun intended).

To begin, this album is immediately better than BGWTB because of its production. The guitars are seismic in their delivery, but they don't clip the mixing. As a result, the bass lines are also distinguishable and give even the albums slowest moments a sense of direction and forward momentum. And I would be remissed if I didn't mention the fantastic sounding vocal harmonies between Duvall and Cantrell here. I mentioned it during the last AiC review, but it almost sounds like Stayley never left us.

The songwriting feels heavier than ever before. The riffs are chunkier, the harmonies in the background vocals and melodic guitar passages are superb. The hooks from "Hollow", "Stone", "The Devil Put Dinosaurs Here", "Scalpel", and "Phantom Limb" are among some of the best Alice in Chains have had in this new era of the band. I love how this band moved away from the traditional grunge sound that made them so popular, but without losing much in the way of their unique identity.

Alice in Chains were always a dark and depressive group when it came to lyrical content. Many of the bands most influential songs: "Down in a Hole", "Nutshell", and "Angry Chair" were all deeply personal to Layne Stayley and his personal struggles that inevitably did him in. Where BGWTB was about coping with the loss of someone close to you, TDPDH addresses more general social issues; specifically the hypocrisy of religion. I love how songs like "Hollow" and "Phantom Limb" really flip off people who think that they can morally grandstand the plebs, but the mob is too large and the dissenting voices ring their words meaningless. Or how on "The Devil Put Dinosaurs Here", how these same people in power would denounce scientific evidence that the earth is a sphere or, as the title suggests, that dinosaurs never truly existed as a living species. They were instead placed by the devil to please the ever learning human mind. Who are you more likely to believe?

I'm not sure that Alice in Chains will ever be able to live up to the cosmic levels (pun intended?) of expectations that myself and a lot of other fans have unjustly placed upon this group. This isn't Dirt by any stretch, but it isn't supposed to be. This is the new Alice in Chains. Whether we like it or not, Layne Stayley is not coming back. This is William Duvall's Alice in Chains now. And it is magnificent. Many people were unjustly harsh on this album when it came out, myself included. I suggest you give this another listen. You never know what bones you might uncover.

Much like the bands namesake, The Boats of the Glen Carrig is a seafaring horror novel that Ahab has created as incidental music to the 1907 novel. And wow does it really live up to its predecessor because this album can get pretty haunting at times.

This is death doom metal with elements of progressive rock and/or post-rock/metal interludes that really help encapsulate the feeling of being all alone on the water and the abandonment that one would feel upon shipwreck with no one around to guide or help them. The progressive sections are beautifully encapsulating of the moments of calm that one might feel when they are attempting to return to a stable state of mind, only to become engulfed once again in the fear and anxiety of a nightmare that feels like it is strangling you.

Unsurprisingly, the first thing that I thought of before I gave this album a listen was Mastodon's 2004 album, Leviathan, considering that they are built around similar concepts. And to be fair to Ahab, there are several similarities in the songwriting techniques used on this album as Mastodon's epic. Such as the invaluable importance of the guitar as melodic instrument, the fruitful bass and powerful vocal delivery. Unlike Leviathan, this album is long and it feels like it, and it's supposed to. The fear of isolation is so pulsating on this album that you start to question when salvation will finally come and rescue you and return to your life as it was before.

My criticisms of this album are few and far between, but they are significant critiques. For one, the vocalists low end is powerful, but it does sound a little too much like the Cookie Monster. And he alternates between the deep low gutturals to a more aggressive screams and there is just no comparison between the two. Also, the album is long. I said that it is a large part of this albums appeal, but some of these songs could have been cut down and given the same emotional impact, otherwise, the tracks could have been split up, making for a more streamlined experience.

Ahab's epic is a pretty damn great album in the death doom library. The atmosphere fits the source material extremely well, as well as the lyrical content. This album may hit you like the weight of the sea as it did the Glen Carrig. But the trip is worth the emotional roller-coaster that is displayed within.

Picture this if you will. One of your favourite bands of all time have been disbanded for well over a decade and you know fully well that their will NEVER be a reunion. But then, suddenly, it happens. The band reunites for a new tour as well as a brand spanking new album just to get the juices flowing. Who wouldn't be excited?

That's how I felt in the year 2009 when Alice in Chains release their first studio album in fourteen years; the first to feature William Duvall as the primary vocalist since the passing of legendary former frontman, Layne Stayley (R.I.P.). I wanted this album to be phenomenal. I have made it no secret that Alice in Chains were my first love in heavy metal and Dirt is my favourite of the big four "grunge" albums.

And what we ended up with was... this. I mean it's a respectable album for Alice in Chains and I would have never expected this group to top one of the most influential albums of a generation. But this album suffers hard.

Now part of that has to do with the higher expectations. I have learned over countless disappointments to never place an album in an elite tier before I have even heard a note on it. And while hindsight is always 20/20, I was only eighteen and easily excitable. And for what it is, Black Gives Way to Blue is a more than solid Alice in Chains record. But, like I mentioned with Tool's most recent album, when you have a layoff of this long, just making more of the same stuff as you did before feels underwhelming.

First off, the production on this album is abysmal! Alice in Chains were not the group that needed to get involved in the "loudness wars" of the late 2000s. Their sludge-y brand of alternative metal/grunge was always slow and brooding. If you took songs like "Rooster" and modernized them with this production, the dynamic swells of the verse/chorus combos would have failed to deliver any emotional impact. "A Looking In View" has this problem right from the get go, and their is very little room for reprieve; you better not be listening to this song with headphones because you won't be able to hear yourself think for nearly seven minutes!

And if you go to the ballads, dear god the ballads! This dynamic swell ruins ballads such as "Your Decision", which could have been fantastic, is ruined by a guitar that is louder than Duvall! And any time the drums come in, you can forget it!

Some of my personal favourite moments happen on "Check My Brain", which is a pretty catchy tune, and the first promotional single that I heard. And oh boy I was immediately sold on William Duvall. He has a vocal timbre that is impeccable and very reminiscent of Stayley. While songs like "Last of My Kind" and "Lesson Learned" are dank, brooding pieces where the low end really shines through, even with the blown out mixing.

Now with time, albums like this as well as Metallica's Death Magnetic have been remastered and most people who didn't hear the album back in the day have no idea what I'm talking about! And that's fair. With that said, I have listened to the album again, this time the digital remastering, not my day one CD from HMV. So why do I still feel underwhelmed by this?

Part of that has to do with the songwriting. As mentioned previously, this is the band's first album in over a decade. Part of this may have been the group just trying to get their name out there and remind people that "hey! We're still here!" But from the death of Stayley in 2002, to the first days of recording this album, Cantrell has been away from AiC for six years. Surely over that time, you would think that they would have picked up some new tricks. But they didn't. Instead they released a serviceable record that got people's attention, but were unable to hold that attention into the next decade.

Which is a damn shame because Alice in Chains would redefine their style on their next album, The Devil Put Dinosaurs Here, where Cantrell asserted to us, the fans, that this was no longer Lanye Stayley's Alice in Chains, but William Duvall's. But we will have to save that discussion for another time...

What a strange album.

This is one of the weirdest black metal albums I've heard all year. This time, we're going to Switzerland to talk about some progressive black metal. I believe that the genre of "avant-garde" would be more understandable for an album like this. It doesn't seem to be intent on laying down pleasant melodic passages or brutal breakdown passages. This album is very atonal and takes all of the time it has to get going. This is further exemplified by the ritualistic nature of some of these song passages. It's faster than your typical drone metal dirge, but if slowed down, it could probably fit right in!

Overall, this album has some incredible highs, but also some very deep lows. When the album is at its best, it is transcendent, such as on "I Burn Within You" or "Ego Sum Omega". Otherwise you end up with "A Paradigm of Beauty", a song that does not feel like it fits in with the rest of the album at all. But I guess that is to be expected from an album like this. This feels like post-metal, but without any of the melodic importance. And yet I still can't turn away from it.

The vocals are clean and easily distinguishable, the guitar work is not extremely prominent, but it does create the atmosphere as one would expect from a post-metal project. The bass is strong and lays a steady foundation for most of the album, and the drum work is insane. The precision is commendable.

I have the sneaking suspicion that this album is going to grow on me more and more with repeated listens. But for now, I'm going to air on the side of caution and give it a recommendation, but not a full, unrestricted one. Perhaps a further endeavor into Schammasch's back catalog  is required...

A very solid dose of traditionalist doom metal, with a couple of new twists. For one, the guitar work on this album is pretty damn great! I like how the lead doesn't feel obliged to stay in the slower, melodic vein of the rest of the album and there are some pretty awesome shredding moments. The vocalist is pretty good at alternating between his cleaner lows and raspy high belting. I'm not a huge fan of when he growls though; it doesn't happen a lot, but it feels out of place and doesn't contribute much.

From a compositional standpoint, the album is pretty streamlined and most song ideas flow seamlessly from one into the next. The album does have quite a bit of meandering moments, highlighted by three interludes, two of them placed beside each other in the albums playthrough. Some songs also take their time reaching their conclusion, such as "The Snake Handler", even if the sum of its parts make it a pretty good song.

If I'm comparing this album to Spirit Adrift's album Divided By Darkness, this album is much heavier and more technically proficient. But from a melodic standpoint, it does feel like a lesser project. Still, the hybrid nature of this album is commendable. I hope these guys can iron out some of the kinks in the future because they have the potential to make something great. Keep an eye out for Crypt Sermon.

Since I don't listen to very much tech death, be sure to take my opinion with a massive grain of salt, but of the albums that I have heard in this vein over the last couple weeks, this is the one that sticks the most. It's pretty well produced (which is leaps and bounds ahead of any of its competition in 2019), and the ideas are still flowing from one track to the next. The album is still held back by many of my personal quips with the genre in general. It's scattered and it's played at such a blazing fast pace to attempt to hide the fact that many of these ideas are unfinished. I would still take this over Cattle Decapitation's Death Atlas, but it still doesn't sell me on the genre.

Sooner or later, these eighties thrash bands who were not arbitrarily chosen as "the big four" will have to realize that the reason albums like Master of Puppets, Rust in Peace, and Among the Living are all time classic records is because of their bass presence, not just their riffage. Death Angel have been around long enough to know this, yet they continue to push out the same album with the same mistakes every three or four years. I'll stick to modern Testament until they decide to stop make ...And Justice For All clones.

These guys have a really good Pantera impression on "Yesterday's Bones", and some of their slower groovy tunes are pretty solid (with the exception of "Hallowed Sound"). But on the tunes when they pick up tempo, like "My Time", "Beware The Wolf" and "Ripping Flesh", it's fairly obvious that these guys have one thrash idea and are going to beat it into the dirt. Fairly solid melodic groove metal, but nothing special.

An album that is only slightly better than Full of Hell's Weeping Choir because the mixing isn't horrendous, some adequate melodic flashes and the vocalists low end which is quite solid. Otherwise, the songwriting is terribly blended, the clean singing is okay, but our singer sounds too much like Bobby Ellsworth (Overkill) in the worst way, the high screeches sound like a mix between Donald Duck and a dying Chihuahua, and the bass drum is overblown in the mix! I'm starting to think that triggered bass drums are the primary focus of this style of music and I'm not a fan.

I don't understand the appeal of this

Because I don't partake in the smoking the devil's lettuce on a regular basis, I find it incredibly difficult to decipher who this album is intended for.

If you are intoxicated while listening, you naturally become tired, and I can see this as great music to fall asleep to, or as just noise in a quiet room. But if you're sober, you're just wondering why the hell no development of ideas has happened for nearly fifteen minutes! 

The difficult challenge that many metal fans face is finding a respectable bridge to help cross the chasm into darker subgenres, and in this case, black metal. Alcest are the forefathers of the blackgaze subgenre that has become quite popular through the 2010s. Their first two albums: Souvenirs d'un autre monde and Écailles de lune are considered classics in this subgenre, and after a brief hiatus with Shelter which incorporated more post-rock than black metal, Alcest return with Kodama, a pleasant album for sure, but lacking in the many of the categories that most extreme metal fans would most likely scour at.

The guitars are produced beautifully; the balancing act of the rhythm guitar and the tremolo picking leads are superb and the fundamental bass and percussion are wonderfully balanced. Many of the main melodies however in the vocals and lead guitar feel lackluster in their performance as they feel left behind the heavy handed rhythm section.

I will say that one of Kodama's biggest faults is how slow it is. Given the fact that this is blackgaze, I cannot say that I find this surprising at all, but the overall simplicity of the tempo charting throughout this album does make it challenging to make any distinguished notes about the tracks on this album. It does have key variations so it is not as monotonous as you might think. "Eclosion" has a pretty melodic leads during the post-rock bridges, and "Oiseaux de proie" delivers an excellent display of pacing as Neige begins with melodic vocals, then opting for harsh screams, then ending with a atmo-black infused outro that serves as the best song on the album. And while "Untouched" attempts to copy this formula, it feels incredibly neutered by the lack of a release point.

If I can give Alcest anything, it that this is some of the prettiest sounding black metal you may ever hear. The wall of sound is not overbearing, and the songwriting leaves a lot of space making for some very comfortable soundscapes. This is the kind of black metal I would listen to on a beach, not locked up in my apartment surrounded by 10+ centimeters of snow. And for that, I give Alcest credit for standing out. While Deafheaven have proven that blackgaze can be just as much intense as the black metal tag would suggest. I do like this record, but would argue that it is one of the bands lesser works. Kodama should be seen as complimentary material to the first two albums.

Medieval, folkened-black metal galore! And this album is quite solid as well. The guitar work does a large amount of heavy lifting on this album and makes for a very enticing experience.

I really enjoyed how this album was able to split the difference between its folk inspired sections and the heavier black metal sections. The band does an even better job of uniting them together in sections to give them their own unique appeal. It really creates the hybrid atmosphere that make you feel like the knights about to go to battle atop their horses. Obsequaie tried a similar idea this year as well, but failed to convert where it mattered.

Again, very solid album that you should not be deterred by just because of a potential language barrier.

I have never been the biggest fan of either technical death metal, or grindcore for that matter. So to see the two of them plopped together sure didn't do this album any favors right out of the gate. But hey, the album is only 25 minutes, what harm could it cause? A lot actually.

My goodness, the production on this album is downright abysmal! How many times are you going to allow the guitars to clip in the mixing? How many times are the drums going to overpower the vocalist? How many times could I hear a bass on this album? I could probably count that one on one hand. Of all of the extreme albums I've listened to so far during my binge of 2019 albums I missed, this is easily the worst and doesn't deserve much of the praise that it is getting.

To say that I have been anticipating this album would be an understatement!

To those uninitiated, Fen are a black metal band from London whose 2017 album, Winter is one of only a handful of albums that I could describe as “flawless”. Why? Well because it reminds me so much of Agalloch’s stunning album The Mantle from 2002. But where that album felt like the soundtrack to a beautiful cottage country that has just been dusted with a large amount of perfect, untouched snow, Fen’s album was more like a freezing rain that has covered everything in a coat of ice. Sure, it looks gorgeous and makes for some incredible photo opportunities, but then comes the realization that all of it will collapse under the additional weight brought by the ice, leaving behind an almost apocalyptic trail behind it. Both Winter and The Mantle are albums that should be held in equal regard, but for very different reasons.

So when I heard that Fen were working on a new album, you could see that I wanted to be one of the first to hear it. But I hindered my expectations a little bit; because nothing, no matter how hard the band tried, could ever live up to the astronomical heights that Winter delivered. So how is The Dead Light?

Well, it’s pretty damn great! But I was a little bit surprised to hear the branching directions that this group decided to take with this project. This one seems to borrow extensively from progressive metal as well as post-metal. There are even some sections that sound like they could have been borrowed from classic death and thrash metal. I don’t even know if “black metal” would be the proper genre definition for this album.

But the real question is how does it all fit? Surprisingly well actually. First and foremost, “The Dead Light Pt. 1” essentially kicks off the album after the extended intro “Witness”, by introducing us to odd time signatures and tempo changes. At first, you may feel a little surprised by how unprepared these transitions are, but before you know it, the band returns to the original idea with a seamless delivery. I really enjoyed how the group managed to take multiple themes and put them together and make them work. It also includes alternating passages of palm muted guitar chugging patterns, and the open tremolo picking and melodic phrases that have always been one of Fen’s strongest assets. Once again, how the group is able to compliment these sections and have them sound so good together is a nod to their songwriting prowess.

In addition to the actual construction of these songs, the production and instrumentalists need some due diligence. The bass (Grungyn) sounds phenomenal, as it usually does on Fen records. And the percussion work (Havenless) is pummeling when it needs to be, such as on the relentless song “Breath of Void”, but also relaxed and restrained when it needs to be as well such as the slower grinds of “Labyrinthine Echoes” and “Rendered in Onyx”. Lyrically, this album seems to be giving more attention to The Watcher’s clean singing. It isn’t impressive, but it doesn’t have to be. Maybe these sections could have been pushed forward in the mix a little bit more, or could have been moved to the slower, shoegaze sections.

Which leads us into the concept of dynamic control and where bands such as Fen and Saor are running circles around everyone else in extreme metal at the moment. Their attention to detail is superb and not enough can be said about how the transitions between sections and how they are intended to force the listener into restraint and control as they wait uncomfortably for the quieter sections to conclude and for the loud sections to return. The transitions aren’t as good as Winter, but they still sound quite excellent. Which is probably why the song “Breath of Void” is probably my least favourite on the project; it’s the least diverse on an album that has quite diverse styles, themes and emotions.

So in conclusion, The Dead Light is pretty great, but I didn’t expect anything else. The album is a breeze to get through despite what the total runtime might suggest. Each track has its moments that are uniquely Fen, but with enough new ideas and themes to keep longtime fans on their toes. It certainly isn’t Winter, but it is a light that you should definitely be following.

Consider me a heretic, but I think that Persefone only got better after the release of Spiritual Migration. Don't get me wrong, this is a fantastic album, but something about it just doesn't resonate the same way that Aathma does. Some of that might have to do with the heavier focus on technical wanking than melodic songwriting; chugging guitar riffs, never ending time signature changes, technically demanding guitar and percussion elements. But what amazes me above all of it is how well it all fits together! Given my history and my general distaste for technical death metal, there is no reason why I should like an album like this. But each tracks flows effortlessly from one into the next and before I realize it, I have listened through the entire album again! I really enjoy the thematic songwriting on tracks like "Mind as Universe" and "Spiritual Migration". I really like how the band takes a breather half way through the project to play a melo-death instrumental in "Consciousness". "Inner Fullness" and "The Majestic of Gaia" should appeal to any tech-death fans out there.

Persefone would only go on to get better with more melodic songwriting and greater concepts in 2017 with Aathma, but let's not forget the album that put Persefone on the map. Going back on this album near the end of the 2010s and hearing it again, I can attest that Spiritual Migration is one of the decades most influential heavy metal albums. Progressive and technical death metal owe a lot to this album.

This a gorgeous sounding atmospheric black metal album that really doubles down on the atmospheric part of its genre definer. The album is called Hallucinogen and it feels like a trip!

For one, the guitar work on this album is a standout. I really like how it is able to effortlessly transition from acting as a melodic instrument to a harmonic one with its tremolo picking patterns. The vocals, while not incredibly great or prominent, do serve their purpose. They feel like an afterthought, but the clean singing sections are sung with a very slow, brooding feel, almost like a religious hymn. The harsh vocals are sparse but effective. The foundation provided by the percussion and bass does its job and emphasizes the low end extremely well. The mixing of the percussion is top notch, not allowing the almost mechanical double bass work to clip in the mixing, while still being prominent enough that you will notice it.

This is a great little project that can be appreciated by many. Definitely one of 2019's sleeper albums IMO.

I have found myself very distant from the metal community for quite some time. It seems like every time a new there is a new progressive-djent/avant-garde/extreme brutal death metal band doesn’t garner any mainstream attention, those fans complain that not enough people are listening to their new favourite artist. However, when a metal band manages to garner a little bit of mainstream attention, everyone loses their minds that their precious genre is being commercialized. Everyone needs a starting point to get into the different music genres. For me, it was the 90s output of Metallica, with the Load and Reload albums (I’m too young to remember the self titled album).

The new craze of the 2010s has been BABYMETAL, a J-Pop duo whose backing band uses distorted, and drop tuned electric guitars and double bass drums. None of these are bad things on their own. And hell, even the bands last album, METAL RESISTANCE, was a branch away from the very coy, happy-go-lucky nature of the self titled album. So I could only hope that METAL GALAXY would continue this trend.

Alright, props to everyone involved for experimenting with some new sounds. However, with an album called METAL GALAXY, it is pretty obvious from the start that this is going to be a more electronic metal experience. The opening track “FUTURE METAL” is proof of this; lots of synth and electronic percussion. And while this isn’t always a bad thing, BABYMETAL are a group that could have desperately used some better mixing of the electronic elements.

For one, the opening track “FUTURE METAL” uses these really generic sounding guitar tones, matched with a poorly mixed percussion whose bass thumps clip the mic and don’t sound pleasing at all. The vocals are almost always pushed to the front of the mix, but when the singer is in her higher register, it peaks on tracks like “PA PA YA!!” and “Starlight”. Otherwise, you end with the pitch corrected “IN THE NAME OF”, where the vocals are pitch shifted to Hell itself, over a Slipknot B-side.

Other tracks are mixed better; “Shanti Shanti Shanti” is alright and I really liked the atmospheric elements added to “Kagerou”. The group is at its best when the guitars are given heavy prominence, like on the power metal outro “Arkadia”, the counterpoint between voice and guitar on “DA DA DANCE” and the quasi-ballad “Shine”.

The experimental elements come in the form of hybrids with other styles of metal. “Shanti Shanti Shanti” has melodic passages that sound borrowed for oriental metal, which I respect, but artists like Orphaned Land have pulled sound off with organic tones much better in the past. “Oh! MAJINAI” borrows from folk and pagan metal as it uses bagpipes as a secondary melodic instrument and every time I hear it I can’t wipe that stupid grin off of my face. It’s so goofy, yet still very satisfying. “Distortion” is the groups attempt to crossover as it calls upon Alissa White-Gluz of Arch Enemy. And I already mentioned the power metal “Arkadia”, and the atmospherics of “Kagerou”.

As for the vocals themselves, they sound okay. I find that more often than not, when the vocalists are higher register, they peak in the mix and don’t really allow for any subtlety in the instrumentation. Of course, BABYMETAL is also dealing with the fact that they have lost one of their members since the release of METAL GALAXY. The vocal layering sounds fine, but it is quite obvious that a lot of the vocals have been fixed in post-production, which is a little disappointing.

As a whole, METAL GALAXY is a serviceable metal/pop record. I think that the group has had better days and that many of the experimental elements on this record don’t work as well as previous albums had. Still, there is nothing overtly offensive about it; this is pop music with crunchy guitars and djent-y breakdowns. If that sounds like something you would like, you probably will.

Lots of Potential, but so many Missed Opportunities

This is quite the ambitious project for a group only on their second album. For those of you who are unaware (and given this band has zero ratings on the website, a lot of you are unaware), White Ward are a Ukrainian post-black metal band whose debut album, Futility Report made its way on to my radar when it appeared on several year end lists for 2017. I liked some of the ideas, but they were handicapped by some really bad production. And so I saw this album rank pretty high on RYM, so I decided to give White Ward another chance to impress me. 

The production and songwriting issues I had with the previous album still hold up, but I can give credit where it is due as the true black metal sections have improved dramatically since 2017. The guitars actually have some natural growl to them and aren't near the front of the mix, drowning out the bass. The vocals are fine enough, drawing a lot of inspiration from George Clarke of Deafheaven. But if you're expecting the rest of this album to sound like Deafheaven, you would be sadly mistaken.

White Ward are not looking to cheer anyone up with these tunes; the typical major key harmonies of albums like Sunbather are nowhere to be found. And the walls of sound are broken up in sizable chunks with slower, atmospheric sections that borrow more from shoegaze and jazz. Yes, jazz. The saxophone as a primary melodic instrument has been improved from the last album at the very least in its tone. That is to say it actually sounds like a saxophone instead of sounding like my crappy MIDI soundboards saxophone tone! However, this is a black metal album, and the horn does sound like it is being drowned out considerably when it is being used during a heavier section. Bands such as Rivers of Nihil, and Moron Police have incorporated saxophone in metal much more efficiently in recent years.

The songwriting is a little worrisome. I like how the group tries to get a little bit progressive with their songwriting as tracks can modulate through a number of different ideas throughout their runtime, but they never feel like they reach their end goal. I have always been a stickler when it comes to progressive songwriting and bringing these long musical journeys back to where they start, or at the very least, return to a major theme or idea. These tunes feel more like a collection of ideas that were just thrown together to make longer songs without putting in the work to make those transitions work.

It is a little bit better than Futility Report on aggregate so I would recommend it, but I would be very cautious. White Ward's sound won't be for everybody; it's a specific brand of black metal that asks the listener to chill out instead of forming a circle pit. And if that's what you're into, more power to you. I just have heard this sound done much better in recent years. By Deafheaven or otherwise.

In Mourning are a Swedish metal band who specialize in progressive metal, but are also willing to get crunchy with some death metal tones as well. I have been looking for a while to find a group who were willing to make this hybrid leap and succeed, as most of the "progressive death metal" in 2019 has felt very underwhelming. And I did like what I found within Garden of Storms.

For starters, the album kicks off with a bang with "Black Storm". I really enjoyed how the heavy percussion complimenting some really sweet guitar melodies. The bass and drums are produced quite well and Tobias' vocals sound very good. The transitions between harsh growls to the equally strong, yet relaxed clean singing is excellent.

This album unfortunately doesn't do a lot for me after the opening track until about the midway point. Sure, "Yields of Sand" and "Hierophant" sound very good and there is nothing offensive about them, I just don't have very much to say about them. Imagine some of the strongest, and loudest moments from Opeth's Ghost Reveries from 2005 and you'll have a pretty good understanding at what you're getting into.

I think that marks my biggest problem with this album as a whole. It's clear to me that this group want to be like Opeth circa the mid 2000s, but lack the originality that makes them standout. Tobias' harsh singing has an uncanny resemblance to that of Mikael Akerfeldt, which push the comparisons even further. I know this is a butchering of the sound, but imagine if Opeth didn't have the lush strings, flutes or synthesizers throughout the 2000s and you'd get something that sounded like In Mourning.

It isn't all bad though; "Magenta Ritual" is actually a very solid slower moment on the album where the dynamics contribute so much. The next track "Huntress Moon" is also excellent. This is the closest the album gets to really digging into true death metal tones; blast beat drumming, chugging guitar riffs and pummeling vocals, but it's all anchored by a subtle, yet powerful tremolo lead guitar that soars over the rest of the ensemble and makes for the original song as well as the albums highlight.

The album ends on a bit of a sour note with "The Last Outpost". The vocal effects around Tobias' during the bridge and some less than stellar songwriting, make the longest track on the album feel longer than it really should. Again, it feels more like a Ghost Reveries B-side than an original idea. And after I just finished listening to the new Wilderun album, it's hard to not compare the two on how to take influence from one of the most influential prog bands of all time. One is respecting the past, while paving their own, unique direction, while this is paying their respects, but not innovating further.

And that leaves me in a bit of an odd position because I do like this. Ghost Reveries is one of my favourite Opeth albums and more of that is always great. But the fact that it cuts back many of that albums unique charm in the instrumentation, but never compliments it with original ideas of their own, leaves me feeling more lukewarm on this than I wish. It is still good, but not great.

Oh How the Giants Have Fallen

Look I don’t have very much to say about this new album from Within Temptation. It’s been five years since Hydra came out and with an extended hiatus period like that, you would think that the group would be able to release something a little bit more interesting than… this.

And I hate saying that because I love Within Temptation, they are established veterans in the power metal genre that I imagine many similar bands look up to. But with this? Within Temptation, pardon the pun, gave in to the ever growing number of rock bands implementing more synth heavy music with piss poor production.

And oh my god, the production on this album is downright abysmal; compressed synths that pierce over the rest of the mix, a kick drum that is forced to close to the microphone, a snare drum that has so much reverb it couldn’t possibly have been recorded from an acoustic set, buzzy guitar tones that reminisce to the heavier, and worst, tracks on the last Bring Me The Horizon album, or in the case of “Holy Ground”, replaces the guitars altogether with blasted out synthesizers. The only thing saving the production from making this album worse is the dynamic contrast, something that Within Temptation have always be masters of. But they can't even pull that off correctly! The loud/soft dynamic is entirely based on whether or not the guitars are playing! And all of this leaves Sharon den Adel in a very unfortunate situation. Because let me be honest, Sharon’s vocal presence is what makes Within Temptation. When all of this is more prominent in the mix than Sharon’s vocal delivery, you have a massive problem.

So yeah, definitely not recommended even for Within Temptation fans. This is the wrong direction for the band and it does not make them look good. If you really want a power metal fix in 2019, wait a couple weeks for that new Avantasia record.

Well… this happened. It wasn’t quite 10,000 Days, but it sure felt like it to longtime fans of this group, which I include myself into that list. 13 years since the last album. TOOL have always taken their time releasing new music, but this was unprecedented. But, the legal disputes that this band found themselves in kept them out of the 2010s almost entirely. And as a result, their music was only just released on streaming platforms within the last month, which must have made the wait feel even longer!

I’ve gone back and reviewed every single studio release in anticipation of this, so if you want to know where I stand on one of my favourite metal groups and their discography, knock yourself out. But going into Fear Inoculum, I had no idea what to expect. I tried my to hinder my anticipation as more information was revealed because... there was no way this could live up to the sky high expectations that the TOOL cult have given it. So here we are. How does it stack up as a metal album in 2019? How does it compare to the rest of the groups music? Was it worth the over decade long wait?

Well… yes and no. For one, I am finally glad to see TOOL back making new music that is as polished and unique for a time where progressive rock and metal seem to be in full nostalgia effect. The bad side is that, despite my best efforts to not do this, TOOL haven’t really evolved that much since 10,000 Days. And as a result, the new album feels… underdeveloped. Not bad by any stretch; TOOL are a competent enough group to never release anything “bad”, just not where it should be.

And before we begin, I have to mention a couple of things. First, that this review will discuss only the tracks on the physical release. Not that the electronic interludes on the digital release are bad, but because they act more as moments of reprieve rather than contributing to the experience.

The other that needs to be abundantly clear to the cult fans that this album must be compared to modern metal albums, not just other TOOL albums. Because (1) the last TOOL album came out in 2006, and (2) the landscape of progressive rock/metal isn’t the same as it was back then either.

So to begin, if Lateralus was the band experimenting with their progressive side, and 10,000 Days was the band attempt at commercializing that sound, then Fear Inoculum is TOOL experimenting with “progressive sludge metal” or “atmospheric sludge metal”. These songs are long; not a single “song” is less than ten minutes. And many of them are built around a handful of different melodic themes and ideas that are woven together to make these songs worth their runtime. “Pneuma” starts with a disjointed guitar riff during the verses, and the chorus consists of long tones, while Danny Carey fills around the drum kit. The later portions of this song combine these two ideas together quite wonderfully.

And now I commit the first act of heresy by comparing TOOL to another band. And the album that I kept comparing this to was Winter, the 2017 masterpiece by English black metal band Fen; an album that at the time I gave a perfect score to and upon revisiting it, I stand by my score. That album was long as well and used brooding quiet sections to compliment the thunderous blast beats and howling vocals. Also as an item to make you, the listener, anticipate the release even more. With this, while many of these songs do manage to pull off dynamic contrast and release exceptionally well, it gets a little tiresome when they all follow the same formula.

Don’t get me wrong, “Invincible” and “Culling Voices” are two fantastic tracks, but especially for the later, when you know what’s coming before you’ve even heard it, that’s a problem. It’s why tracks like “Pneuma” and “7empest” are a little bit more unique, with “7empest” being a heavy metal assault from beginning to end. It does still have some strong dynamics, but nothing like the reprieve of the tempo change during the bridge of “Invincible”.

The title track is a song that could have been cut down to size a little bit, especially during the outro. The song starts off pretty post-metal, before transforming into an odd time signature riff that at least feels like it belongs with the beginning, but the outro just sounds like TOOL and didn’t fit in. The same can be said for “Descending”, a track highlighted by its last seven minutes as a jam session with prominence on Adam Jones guitar solo. I like the melodic stuff, but the chugging riffs just go on way too long. A damn shame because the first half of that track is phenomenal.

Which takes us into the performers themselves. As I said, Adam Jones seems to have much more prominence on this album as a melodic instrument than even before. Just look at “Descending” and “7empest” for that. Danny Carey is killing it on “Pneuma” and “Chocolate Chip Trip”. Justin Chancellor’s bass work is as prominent as ever and everyone complaining about how Maynard’s vocals sound need to stop. He’s 55. His voice has been dipping since Ænima, give him a break.

From a production standpoint, it’s not surprising that on an album that is diving even more into the atmospherics of sludge metal, TOOL is using more electronics and synthesizers on this album. It also wouldn’t surprise me if they’ve been listening to a lot of ambient, spacey, electronic music. Specifically, the Mass Effect: Original Soundtrack. The spacey intros of “Fear Inoculum” and “Culling Voices”, the dank low synth tones that are prominent on the outro of “Descending” and the electronic ostinato on “Chocolate Chip Trip”.

Okay, so what are the band trying to say on this record? Well this album seems to be showing the band at their most fearful/anxious. The critical point is when Maynard becomes personal on “Invincible”. Perhaps a very relevant song for the group, as they were forced into hiatus while they were still at the peak of their popularity, the band worries whether or not their fans will return to them.

“Fear Inoculum” discusses “The Deceiver”, an antagonist character who has brought our protagonist misery and anger, and the protagonist now begins to reject them. “Descending” is the band showing their fearfulness for the future of our planet and how our irreversible damage may cause the downfall of humanity as we know it. “Culling Voices” discusses the echo chambers that we form as individuals (in our own head) or as part of a group, and how constant replies of assurance are inevitably bad for us. And “7empest” is the rejection of the authority figures who tell the people lies to further their own narrative. And when those figures are called out for it, they blame somebody else. How relevant in 2019. With the themes of fear and anxiousness near the front, it makes sense as to why some of these songs feel long: these opinions are not fully formed or realized yet. They need to be refined and cut down to the proverbial meat and potatoes. I think for what the band is trying to say, the lyrics match the songs, even if I don’t like it.

So where are we? TOOL’s Fear Inoculum is a puzzling project. One that requires the attention of the listener to really grasp everything that is going on. That is to say, make sure you’re sober when you listen to this. It’s far too long for its own sake and should have been refined. As a metal album in 2019, it does stack up favourably to whatever the heck that last Slipknot album was, but compared to Saorand Spirit Adrift? Not so much. What about compared to other TOOL albums? It’s certainly a better than Ænima and it will have longer staying power, but compared to Undertow and 10,000 Days it feels like a step down. It’s a good comeback album, but it should have been a lot better.