Here are my thoughts on all the selected tracks:
Accept - "Metal Heart" from Metal Heart (1985)
4.5/5. 40 years ago, this is what metalheads call a banger, and I agree with them. I love how they added in some classical themes from Tchaikovsky and Beethoven.
Capilla Ardiente - "The Hands of Fate Around My Neck" from Where Gods Live and Men Die (2024)
4/5. A doomy heavy metal epic. Enough said!
Throne of Iron - "Past the Doors of Death" from Adventure One (2020)
3.5/5. Same with this one, though here it has a more galloping pace.
Savatage - "Strange Reality" from Streets - A Rock Opera (1991)
4/5. Another melodic heavy metal highlight to sing along to.
Sabaton - "Unbreakable" from The Art of War (2008)
4.5/5. This progressive highlight is one of the best songs I've heard by Sabaton, and I still think that today. It's the band's own Black Sabbath "Heaven and Hell"!
Heavenly - "Sign of the Winner" from Sign of the Winner (2001)
5/5. Absolute power metal greatness with superb guitarwork by Frédéric Leclercq who would later become the bassist for DragonForce.
Blind Guardian - "Nightfall" from Nightfall in Middle-Earth (1998)
4.5/5. I still know this track as a power metal classic, better than that d*mn "Bard's Song". This is how I knew the character Morgoth before the German death metal band.
Saxon - "Crusader" from Crusader (1984)
4/5. Anyone into NWOBHM, join the Saxon crusade!
Medieval Steel - "Medieval Steel" from Medieval Steel (1984, reissued on The Dungeon Tapes (2005))
4.5/5. I hope this doesn't sound sinful, but this track sounds like Twisted Sister gone Riot/Omen. That said, it really rocks out as a metal hymn. It's practically the band's own theme song! Not all heroes wear capes; some wield swords or play metal. Classic heavy metal can be quite interesting.
Lethal - "Arrival" from Programmed (1990)
4/5. Classic tracks like this still exist. Keep it real!
Taramis - "Doesn't Seem" from Queen of Thieves (1988)
4.5/5. Cool 80s progressive power metal right there!
Conception - "Silent Crying" from Parallel Minds (1993)
5/5. A fantastic out-of-this world ballad, and I don't usually say that about ballads. I haven't heard Conception until, but I'm glad there's the beauty of Roy Khan's singing before he joined Kamelot. Such a wonderful piece! From what I heard, Conception is kinda like a more progressive take on Khan's early years with Kamelot. They've recently returned with a new EP and album. The ballad reminds me of the ones by early Nevermore and Crimson Glory. There's nothing cheesy in this plate!
Rampage - "Benevolent Approach" from Acid Storm demo (1986, reissued on Veil of Mourn (1988))
4.5/5. After that slow ballad, we go fast again with this pretty amazing heavy/speed metal demo track.
Brocas Helm - "Fly High" from Black Death (1988)
4/5. Another great hymn with slight hints of Iron Maiden.
Attacker - "Battle at Helm Deep" from Downfall (1985)
3.5/5. 80s US power metal, closer to classic heavy metal, before Stratovarius and Hammerfall stormed in from Europe.
Destiny's End - "Breathe Deep the Dark" from Breathe Deep the Dark (1998)
4/5. In the 90s, Iced Earth and Destiny's End were still cranking up their classic heavy/US power metal sound. You might also know James Rivera as the vocalist of Helstar.
Concerto Moon - "The Gold Digger" from Back Beyond Time (2023)
3.5/5. Pretty good, but a little goofy for a band keeping up the Japanese power/neoclassical metal scene started by Galneryus.
Vitalij Kuprij - "Piano Overture" from Forward & Beyond (2004)
4/5. RIP Vitalij Kuprij. Enjoy this cool cover of Moonlight Sonata with Symphony X guitarist Michael Romeo.
Within Temptation - "Caged" from Mother Earth (2000)
4.5/5. Then we have the slow folk-ish highlight "Caged". Both the vocals by Sharon den Adel and the instrumentation are quite diverse. The peaceful calmness are at the right dose here, before it all ends up crashing down later in the original album.
Nightwish - "Ghost Love Score" from Once (2004)
4.5/5. The true epic of this playlist and its original album, and very much everything the album has already offered is blended together greatly. First we have a couple verses with more of the Eastern sitar, then it slows down to a ballad-like section, and after that, we have a lovely orchestral break that is well-executed. Immediately when the metal comes back on, you're hit by one of the most epic moments in symphonic metal, right before Tarja continues singing. And the rest is memorable too.
Mechina - "When Honor Meets Steel" from Venator (2022)
5/5. An aggressive way to head out than can pulverize those earlier melodic tracks, complete with blasts and more growls, most of them coming from guest vocalist Anna Hel. So brutally awesome!
Pretty good playlist I've made, huh? I recommend this to any heavy/power/symphonic/neoclassical metal fan and anyone who isn't into those genres but is up to getting into a great start for the genre. Thanks to anyone who have contributed with their own submissions, and I hope the rest of you enjoy it like I've had!