Ben's Reviews

A classic album that epitomizes everything that is black metal. Damn essential!

Mayhem's De Mysteriis Dom Sathanas album was and is much more than just another black metal album. This release (and the band behind it) has a history attached to it that makes for fascinating reading (including murder, suicide and church burnings) and probably more than any other album, epitomizes what black metal was truly meant to be. Now I'm not one of those guys that says black metal should remain "true" and should never venture out into more experimental realms. Personally, I think that all genres become stale unless they broaden their influences and become a little adventurous at some point. Nor am I someone that encourages anti-authoritarian or anti-religious actions (despite my skeptical nature). But right from the outset, this wonderful little genre we call black metal was designed to be evil, inaccessible and morbidly atmospheric. De Mysteriis Dom Sathanas is all of those things and has an incredible aura attached to it that's difficult to describe.

First and foremost, I think Euronymous was simply a genius when it comes to writing malevolent, cold, black metal riffs. Every track on this album has multiple cracking riffs and I wish so very much that he had been able to continue his musical vision and not been cowardly slain by Varg. Hellhammer's drumming is incredible to say the least and while every performance he has ever produced is worth listening to, I think this one is the one he will be remembered for. It's strange to read that Varg's bass lines were lowered in the mix after he murdered Euronymous as I can't say it had all that much effect. They are usually quite audible throughout the album and are certainly of a high quality. Which brings me to without doubt the most controversial aspect of De Mysteriis Dom Sathanas. Attila Csihar! I'll be the first to admit that Attila's vocals are incredibly strange and at times just downright ugly. When I first heard the album way back in the mid 90s, I was put off so much by his performance that I couldn't listen to the album at all. But slowly over time I came to accept them and then somehow, to love them. Perhaps it has a lot to do with the fact that the man has since performed for many other bands and it's just a matter of getting used them. Or perhaps they're just so spasmodically strange, that it takes quite a few listens to come to grips with. Either way, these days I can't imagine this classic album with any other vocalist and I truly think his creepy, chaotic style suits the backdrop perfectly.

There are no bad tracks to be found and it's difficult to pick out highlights, but I think my personal favourites would be Funeral Fog, Freezing Moon, Pagan Fears, Life Eternal, Buried by Time and Dust and the title track. As silly as it would be to call De Mysteriis Dom Sathanas underrated (it's considered a classic by thousands all over the world), I do think it is occasionally harshly judged due to the vocals. I highly encourage any black metal fans out there that haven't yet experienced this wonderful piece of history, to make sure they don't dismiss it too easily. It's slight inaccessibility (from a vocal point of view) only adds to the package and in my opinion, De Mysteriis Dom Sathanas is one of the very best albums extreme metal has to offer and a near perfect example of a style that makes my life so much more enjoyable!

An album of intensity and complexity, but one that fails to match the emotion and grandeur of past releases.

Emperor’s first two breathtakingly grand albums had set such a high standard that the prospect of matching them, let alone surpassing them, must have been daunting for the band to say the least. Their debut In the Nightside Eclipse had pretty much singlehandedly launched symphonic black metal and while scores of bands tried and failed to emulate it, Emperor went and upped the ante with the immense Anthems to the Welkin at Dusk. In the years following its release, I along with thousands of other fans, were hanging out for another mesmerising wall of sound black metal masterpiece, as though it were just a given that Emperor would eventually produce it. It was just too hard to fathom that they could let us down, with Ihsahn, Samoth and Trym seemingly too gifted and ambitious to produce anything but pure atmospheric gold. The only change in line-up since Anthems had been recorded was bassist Alver leaving the band, but considering Ihsahn was more than capable of taking his place in the studio, and that Alver’s performance was all but inaudible on the previous album, the loss was unlikely to have much of a negative impact. When IX Equilibrium was finally released on November the 23rd 1999, I picked it up and raced home, heart literally pounding in anticipation while I ripped the plastic off.

Did IX Equilibrium live up to my expectations? The short answer is no, but then I wonder how many albums actually could. When you expect a band’s new album to be the best thing you’ve ever heard, you’re very likely going to be let down. To my initial disappointment, Emperor did not attempt to make Anthems to the Welkin at Dusk Part II, and the resulting album is a very different beast indeed. Seemingly taking inspiration from their death metal roots, yet with a completely modern sound, IX Equilibrium is a black metal album that’s more interested in flummoxing the listener with a swirling cacophony of riffs and incessantly mind-battering percussion than creating any sort of meticulously constructed mood . The outcome is an album that lacks the epic atmosphere and consistency of previous albums, yet once you get your head around the sheer madness of it all, there’s still a heck of a lot of genius on offer. If you focus on what these musicians are doing with their instruments, you can’t help but feel a certain level of respect. It’s clear that Emperor, and in particular main songwriter Ihsahn, are no longer able to restrict their creative sensibilities to standard black metal fare, with constant shifts in velocity and playing styles kicking in regularly, rarely allowing the listener to settle in for the ride for long.

The above description likely makes IX Equilibrium sound like a difficult album, and I guess it is to a degree. The main issue I have with it is not the complexity however, but with the lack of emotion that it induces. While there are some tracks that I really enjoy such as Curse Ye All Men, Of Blindness & Subsequent Seers and in particular Decrystallizing Reason, the rest of them are merely impressive without moving me substantially like Emperor’s material normally does. Probably the only track that doesn’t really work for me at all would be The Warriors of Modern Death, which seems to be a throwback to Bathory-like epic metal, complete with Hammerheart replicated dodgy leads. I can appreciate what they were trying to do, but the positive variety it offers is outweighed by the sheer contrast to the rest of the material. Is IX Equilibrium still worth the four stars I’ve given it despite my qualms? Well, it’s still Emperor, with all the class that the name suggests. The majority of the album is still miles ahead of what the bulk of the scene could muster, and the pure intensity and intricacy of it all holds considerable merit despite the difficulties. The negative tone of this review is perhaps given proper context then by knowing that I gave the first two albums five stars with no hesitation whatsoever and place them towards the very apex of black metal masterpieces. IX Equilibrium is just a bit disappointing in comparison.

A swirling labyrinth of intense black metal, Anthems is one of the elite metal albums.

After the Reverence teaser EP demonstrated that Emperor had overcome their line-up issues and formed a devastating new unit (Ihsahn, Samoth, Alver and Trym), I was very impatient to see what these Norwegians were about to let loose. I figured whatever the end result, it would undoubtedly be highly ambitious, yet I was not prepared for just how intense Anthems to the Welkin at Dusk would turn out to be. In the Nightside Eclipse was a brilliant album, but its symphonic black metal seems like easy listening compared to this beast. Emperor pulled out all stops for Anthems by cranking the production up to extraordinary levels, with the symphonic aspect fleshing out massive metal compositions. I have to admit that the first couple of times I experienced this album, the sheer chaos and complexity of it all was just too much to take in. I knew it was something incredible immediately, and that the apparent chaos was somehow masterfully controlled, but with all the aspects of the band intertwining at such high velocity and with such abrasiveness, my poor brain was just struggling to keep up. Anthems to the Welkin at Dusk is an extremely loud album that wants to make your ears bleed, but if you don’t mind the loss of blood, there’s immense masochistic pleasure to be experienced here.

A major point of discussion for the album has always been the production. In theory, it may not sound that unusual to give each instrument exactly the same volume in the mix, but in reality that can result in an impenetrable wall of noise. Emperor was very lucky to get away with it here and at times I’m not sure they really should have. The guitars, drums, keyboards and vocals are all extremely loud and clear, but given that drums in general are far more dominating as an instrument in general, they threaten to suffocate the whole recording throughout. There are two main reasons why this doesn’t stop Anthems to the Welkin at Dusk from being critically lauded as one of the most important black metal releases ever recorded. Firstly, Trym’s drumming performance is outstanding! His blasting is ferocious and he keeps things varied and intense for the entire running time. Secondly, black metal never demanded that all instruments be audible at all times. There’s always something new and impressive jumping out of the production, giving the listener multitudes of things to grab hold of. Majestic keyboards, kick ass riffs and Ihsahn’s vicious vocals all fight for attention resulting in a blissful labyrinth of glorious darkness. This may sound frustrating on paper but each time you listen to the album it will make more and more sense until the collective genius becomes apparent.

Ihsahn’s vocals are vastly different to the high pitched shrieks found on In the Nightside Eclipse. His technique is now much lower and more venomous, but he also adds clean vocals regularly to good effect. His clean style can sound a bit awkward and pretentious at times, but they fit nicely enough within the tone of the music. His performance on With Strength I Burn in particular makes for an album highlight. The guitar techniques are also startlingly different to the debut with very few riffs going for the hypnotic black metal effect. Ihsahn and Samoth instead produce a constant flow of time changes and a general level of complexity not normally associated with black metal. There are quite a few early signs of the progressive take that Emperor would utilise on later albums, but Anthems remains firmly grounded in black metal. The keyboards still consist mostly of choir-like gothic backdrops, but there’s an extra level of classical sophistication which was expected after the Opus a Satana instrumental on Reverence. Ensorcelled by Khaos is a good example of this increase, with the symphonic aspect combining beautifully with the bass for a seriously grand outcome. You may have noticed that this is the first time I’ve mentioned the word bass. That’s because poor Alver got left behind in the cacophony of sound. Undoubtedly a shame, but he does raise his hand temporarily during the album’s less intense sections.

Anthems to the Welkin at Dusk starts off calmly enough with the Alsvartr (The Oath) intro building up magnificently. The transition into the complete savagery of Ye Entrancemperium has to be one of the most exciting moments in metal, and just when you’re thinking how brutal it all is, they step it up further with Trym launching into violent blast beats and Samoth and Ihsahn unleashing an awesomely killer riff. The infamous Euronymous gets credit for the opening riff which he wrote for an unnamed Mayhem song, but I’m fairly sure it would have sounded nothing like it does in the hands of Emperor. Other highlights include the still amazing Loss of Curse and Reverence and the absolutely monstrous With Strength I Burn, the latter which showcases all the elements that make this period Emperor so impressive in one 8 minute epic. Special mention should also go to closing instrumental The Wanderer. While the majority of versions of the album now come with the Reverence EP tacked on the end, I can’t help feeling that this negates the power of The Wanderer as a closing track. After the complex maelstrom that comes before it, it’s soothing yet haunting melodies are the perfect come down. Of course you’ll want to get another fix before too long, because Anthems to the Welkin at Dusk is an incredible experience by one of black metal’s elite bands.

As a teaser for the approaching masterpiece, Reverence eased our concern that Emperor's best might be behind them. Excellent stuff!

It hadn’t been all fun and games for Emperor since 1994’s brilliant In the Nightside Eclipse album. The band seemingly had the black metal world at their feet and fans were fervent to see what these Norwegians would produce next. But as is the case with many black metal bands of this era, the apparent commitment of the band members went far beyond the music itself, which inevitably resulted in some time behind bars. The band’s guitarist Samoth was sentenced to 16 months in prison for arson after being found guilty, along with Varg Vikernes (who would also be charged with the murder of Mayhem’s Euronymous and several other arson counts), for his part in the burning down of Skjold Church in Vindafjord. To make matters worse, drummer Bard G. Eithun (aka Faust) was convicted of the murder of a homosexual man two years after the crime and was sentenced to fourteen years in prison (of which he would serve just over nine). With half the band out of action, bassist Tchort (who was also arrested a couple of years earlier for burglary, knife assault and grave desecration) also departed the band leaving Ihsahn to ponder what might have been.

It didn’t seem all that likely that Emperor would be able to remain a force, let alone produce anything close to the quality of their debut. Yet hindsight shows that this is the perfect example of “what doesn’t kill us makes us stronger”. Once Samoth was released from prison, he and Ihsahn set about trying to find replacements for Tchort and Faust, with more desire than ever to take Emperor to the pinnacle of black metal music. They handpicked Alver from Dødheimsgard to perform bass duties and, in what turned out to be a brilliant decision, drummer Trym from Enslaved. If there was ever any doubt that Emperor’s new line-up could deliver the goods, the Reverence EP would wipe them away in no uncertain terms. The Loss of Curse and Reverence displayed Emperor at their most epic, inimitable and close to impenetrable best. In Longing Spirit showcased a newer, more refined Emperor, full of the same grand atmosphere in a less chaotic form. Finally, Opus a Satana proved that not only could Ihsahn maintain the band’s majestic tone without the need for typical metal instruments, he had musicianship skills far surpassing the average black metal performer.

The new Emperor was compositionally more sophisticated and we all knew that it wouldn’t be too long before we held something truly special in our hands. Trym had added a terrifyingly brutal element to the band and the whole production was given far more punch while losing none of the wall of sound effect that their work was renowned for. This release was always intended to be a teaser rather than an essential piece in Emperor’s history, with both The Loss and Curse of Reverence and In Longing Spirit both set to hold a place on the planned full length Anthems to the Welkin at Dusk release later in the year. That would have left only the instrumental version of Inno a Satana (entitled Opus a Satana) as the only real reason for fans to track the Reverence EP down. The band’s decision to leave In Longing Spirit off the album soon changed that, but the fact that pretty much every version of Anthems to the Welkin at Dusk contains both In Longing Spirit and Opus a Satana as bonus tracks these days means it should not be difficult for anyone to own these tracks in some form or another. You should too because it’s…well, it’s Emperor!

Complex and majestic symphonic black metal from the mighty Emperor. A definitive moment in metal music.

In the Nightside Eclipse was recorded in July 1993. Emperor had already made a name for themselves by this time, and miraculously done so purely through their musical output alone. They would soon become far more famous for all the wrong reasons, but it was their Wrath of the Tyrant demo and split album with Enslaved that were causing waves of excitement amongst a growing legion of black metal fans. The line-up had only one change between the self titled EP and In the Nightside Eclipse, with bassist Mortiis leaving due to an apparent loss of interest in metal to be replaced by Terje Vik Schei (aka Tchort). Tchort had previously played guitar for Green Carnation back when they were a death metal band in the early 90s before spending two years in prison for burglary, knife assault, and grave desecration. One can only assume that Samoth and Faust found a kindred spirit in Tchort, as the two of them were currently unidentified fugitives for crimes they committed in 1992 (Samoth burnt down churches along with Varg Vikernes from Burzum and Faust murdered a man for making homosexual advances towards him). Both of these men would eventually be convicted of these crimes, but not until they’d played their roles in one of extreme metal’s finest moments.

In the Nightside Eclipse is an astounding, landmark black metal album. Not content to simply replicate the likes of Dark Throne and Mayhem, Emperor took black metal in a whole new direction. They almost single-handedly created the symphonic black metal subgenre and did so with a level of complexity all the imitators can only dream of. From a purely metal perspective, the album is chock full of fantastic full throttle drumming, mesmerising majestic riffs and violently magnificent vocals. With these aspects alone, I'm pretty sure Emperor would have been onto a winner, but it's the symphonic element that takes their music far and above your average black metal band. In the Nightside Eclipse is like a macabre opera of dark genius, with swirling backdrops and rousing gothic compositions. The sheer wall of noise effect can initially be quite confronting, but once it sinks its claws into you, there's no escaping the grandiose brilliance that is Emperor. It’s the type of album where you stop focussing on individual instruments within seconds and let yourself get swept away by the all-encompassing whole. The riffs often don't even get front line attention and play second fiddle to the keyboards, but Emperor knew exactly when to give them centre stage with the symphonic elements intermittently withdrawing to allow the guitars to shine through.

If you listen to In the Nightside Eclipse and concentrate on the symphonic aspect alone it’s not particularly impressive from a musical point of view. Fairly simple B grade gothic horror movie ooooohs and aaaaahs kick in intermittently that could so easily have come off as cheesy and weak in someone else’s hands. It’s due to Ihsahn and Samoth’s song crafting skills that these effects don’t just work, but bestow already fantastic black metal with a huge dose of epic. Ihsahn deserves credit for his vocal performance also as his effective spoken word and full throated, high pitched black metal shrieks give the impression of complete conviction and malice. I am the Black Wizards and Cosmic Keys to My Creation and Times were the highlights of the self titled EP and both are included here in re-recorded fashion. They still stand out as high points on the full length, yet Into the Infinity of Thoughts and Beyond the Great Vast Forests are just as superb. Emperor would go on to create three more massive albums before calling it a day, but I think only 1997's Anthems to the Welkin at Dusk can come close to matching this amazing debut. There's no doubt in my mind that this deserves the full five stars and I imagine I'll still be cranking this up when I'm 60 and being swept off my feet in a rush of black metal magic.

The first official Emperor release showcases majestic symphonic black metal of the highest order.

There was a lot of label interest in Emperor after the Wrath of the Tyrant demo spread through the underground. The band was at one stage signed to Euronymous’ infamous Deathlike Silence Productions, but for one reason or another never actually released anything for it. In the end it was newly formed label Candlelight that would be fortunate enough to get Emperor onto their roster and the band set about getting something recorded officially. Samoth realised that his percussion skills were not his main strength, so Bård G. Eithun (aka Faust) was recruited as a full time drummer, allowing Samoth to move back to guitar. Ihsahn, Samoth, Mortiis and Faust entered the studio “under the December full moon anno 1992” where they would record seven tracks in total. Five were re-recordings of tracks found on the Wrath of the Tyrant demo (Ancient Queen, Night of the Graveless Souls, Witches Sabbath, Lord of the Storms and Wrath of the Tyrant) while I am the Black Wizards and Cosmic Keys to My Creations and Times were brand new Emperor compositions. There was almost enough material to release a full length Emperor album but the decision was made to choose the four best tracks and release a self titled EP instead. They made the right choice too as the tracks they chose are of the highest quality.

Most fans would know the Emperor EP as part of the split Emperor / Hordanes Land release with Enslaved that was released in June 1993, but it was also released as a separate vinyl 12” EP a month prior. The split is considered a classic black metal release, being the first official recordings of two of the most prominent and remarkable bands to come out of the Norwegian black metal scene. The striking album cover that adorns both versions of the Emperor EP is a wood engraving by French artist Gustave Doré (1832-1883) called Death on the Pale Horse, which is actually one of many bible illustrations that Gustave completed over his career. It might seem strange for Emperor to attach anything related to the bible, but the verse the illustration represents is from a rather morbid Revelation verse that certainly doesn’t seem at odds with black metal. “And I looked, and behold a pale horse: and his name that sat on him was Death, and Hell followed with him. And power was given unto them over the fourth part of the earth, to kill with sword, and with hunger, and with death, and with the beasts of the earth.” It wouldn’t be the last time Emperor would utilise Doré’s work, nor would they be the only black metal band that would use his material, but more on that another time.

The versions of Ancient Queen, Lord of the Storms and Witches Sabbath recorded in this session would eventually be released in a separate vinyl 12” EP in 1994 and while they are still enjoyable and far improved from the demo, none of them come close to anything here. The obvious highlights are the new tracks I am the Black Wizards and Cosmic Keys to My Creations and Times which shows just how quickly Emperor were improving their song writing. There was simply nothing as majestically wonderful in the world of black metal released prior to this. The level of atmospheric mystery and wonder that Emperor could create with their wall of sound is unrivalled and they’d go on to record a couple of the greatest extreme metal albums ever using the blueprint that’s present right here. Night of the Graveless Souls and Wrath of the Tyrant are of a slightly lesser quality, but the better production, far superior drumming, higher prominence of keyboards and the fact that Emperor had finally realised that performing black metal with down-tuned guitars does not get the ideal result mean they are far superior to the demo versions. They alone make this EP well worth tracking down in whatever format you can get your hands on, even if you own the In the Nightside Eclipse album (which includes both of the new tracks re-recorded).

Further info: The members of Emperor were incredibly prolific in their early years. I’m not just talking about recording music here as there’s nothing particularly impressive about the amount of albums they were releasing. It’s just that somehow these guys managed to find the time in between writing and recording black metal to run around the neighbourhood doing all sorts of nasty things to buildings and people. Between recording the Wrath of the Tyrant demo in July 1992 and the Emperor EP in December 1992, Samoth and Faust would both be heavily involved in burning down the ancient churches of Norway. It is known for certain that Samoth, along with Varg Vikernes (of Burzum fame), burnt down Skjold Church in Vindafjord on September 13. More seriously, on August 21, a day before he assisted Varg and Euronymous (of Mayhem fame) burn down Holmenkollen Chapel in Oslo, Faust stabbed a man named Magne Andreassen to death for making sexual advances towards him. Neither Samoth nor Faust would be convicted of these crimes until 1994 when the shit hit the fan in Norway, allowing them to record some of Emperor’s most important material as unidentified criminals. You could say these guys took their beliefs seriously. A little too seriously perhaps?!

With 17 full length albums, Polish band Acid Drinkers are an outfit I've considered checking out many times. The main thing that's turned me off over the years is the way their album covers suggest the band are just having a laugh. I had noticed that their 2008 album Verses of Steel is relatively well received though, so when it appeared as an option in this month's Review Draft for The Pit, I figured it was time to take the plunge? Do I regret that decision? Well, at least now I know that my natural aversion was correct all along. Before I go any further, I'm surprised this only has a thrash metal primary on RYM (and therefore here). There's a fair bit of groove metal on this album, as well as a hint of crossover thrash from time to time. Regardless of where it fits on the metal tree, Verses of Steel has a surprising lack of emphasis on riffs. There are plenty to experience if you choose to focus on them, but they're rarely powerful or effective, and I find the vocals draw my attention away from them more often than not. That could have something to do with the vocalists spasmodic approach, and I have to say that I don't enjoy them for the most part. Like the band's artwork so often does, the band seems to be going for an entertaining and somewhat comedic approach, which just rubs me up the wrong way. I'll take vicious and brutal over humurous and playful anyday (unless it's Mike Patton).

In the end I've given Verses of Steel plenty of time to connect with me. It's not terrible, and I found myself enjoying parts of it quite a bit when I wasn't being so critical. I'm not surprised that they have a reasonable sized fanbase, but this isn't what I want from my thrash metal. If you want to check it out, second track In a Black Sail Wrapped is easily the highlight. Don't expect the rest of the album to be at that standard though.

This is a wonderful album that more black metal fans should experience. I first heard back when it was released and it's one of those albums that I find myself going back to over and over for another fix. I know it seems redundant to use the word atmospheric when describing a release in a subgenre that contains the word itself, but these Germans completely filled all 54 minutes of Andacht with it. The black metal itself has a heap of emotion enducing riffs and (surprisingly audible) basslines, but the addition of moving synths, gregorian chants and snippets from various sources (I recognise Bram Stoker's Dracula for one) take it to a whole other level. These aspects also help to give each of the six tracks their own identity and, unlike many atmospheric black metal albums, I'm never in doubt as to which track I'm listening to. I've always assumed that this is an album deserving of five stars, but now that I've given it a few concentrated listens in the past week, I've come to realise that it does lose steam towards the end. The final two tracks are not quite as great as the first four, and it's this drop that has resulted in me settling on a high 4.5. Andacht is still an album I highly recommend to anyone that enjoys black metal.

As a final note, I discovered today that the band utilised a drum machine for this recording. I'm sure Daniel will tell me it's obvious, but I must admit it's never even crossed my mind throughout all the listens over the years. I'm not one of those elitists that think drums have to be real for the music to be authentic, so it makes no difference to me. Either way, they're clearly done extremely well here.

When I saw that Impious are from Sweden and that Death Domination, their sixth and seemingly final album, is listed as melodic death metal, I immediately assumed I was about to experience just another band from the In Flames / Soilwork school. This expectation was very quickly obliterated though, as this album gets off to a much more brutal start than those bands ever attempted, with the first couple of tracks ripping along with more typical death metal ferocity. Vocalist Martin Åkesson barks his vocals out with a heap of aggression, and drummer Mikke Norén puts the pedal to the metal, with regular blast beats and a generally high level of energy. There are definitely moments on the album that sit more comfortably beside the aforementioned bands, and the melodic death metal tag isn't unwarranted, but don't be put off if Swedish melodic death metal isn't normally your thing.

All this said, I have to admit that I enjoy the mid section of the album the most, particularly And the Empire Shall Fall and Hate Killing Project, where the band change things up and slow things down. The majority of the album relies heavily on intense vocal rhythms and intense battery, with the riffs often taking the runners up position in the race. When the band take the time to concentrate on writing more varied song structures, things become much more interesting and memorable for me. As things are, this album just isn't all that compelling, and my feelings for it are generally as lukewarm as the middling reception this band tends to get online.

I guess I should start by saying that I'm a fan of gothic metal. Just making that statement can be somewhat daunting amongst many metal fans, as it feels very much like a minority subgenre to enjoy. I've spent a lot of time over the years listening to the likes of Tiamat, The Gathering, Theatre of Tragedy, Katatonia, Moonspell and Paradise Lost, not to mention gothic death doom bands like My Dying Bride and Draconian. As with any style of music though, this doesn't mean that I enjoy ALL gothic metal releases. Case in point - Heavenwood's Abyss Masterpiece album. Here we have a band that seems to be attempting to follow the Paradise Lost recipe, yet inadvertently forgets to include some vital ingredients. Given the relative simplicity of the musicianship found in your typical gothic metal release, it's super important that the outcome manages to connect with the listener on an emotional level. The bands I mentioned above are not attempting to wow you with technicality and often make little attempt to be particularly creative, but what they do well is move the listener with melancholic and despondent atmosphere (occasionally even romantic). Heavenwood seem perfectly capable and have a solid production, but rarely make me feel much at all. It's only really on The Arcadia Order and Leonor that I find myself getting all that involved, and given Abyss Masterpiece has a runtime of over an hour, that's just not enough meat on the bone. As a final note, I'm not sure how this release has been given a death doom metal subgenre at RYM. There's very little that resembles doom here.

Having ignored most thrash bands that have formed in the past couple of decades, I've lately discovered that there's more quality there than I'd previously assumed. Brazilian band Violator are yet another example of some dudes trying to replicate what their heroes were doing a generation prior, but they do so with admirable energy and an abundance of exciting thrash riffs. If you enjoy Exodus in their prime, then this will almost certainly provide a level of entertainment and comfort. I enjoy the first four tracks enough to rate this a bit higher, but there are some flaws with this EP that cause me drop my score down. First and foremost, the final two tracks were clearly recorded in a different session. I did some digging and discovered that they were actually recorded for a compilation a year prior. The production isn't as good and the songwriting is lacking in comparison to the other tracks on the EP to the point where I think it would have just been better without them. My second flaw is a bit more nitpicky, but Violator's tendency to include silliness at the end of tracks, such as the belch at the end of Thrash Maniacs and the apparent acoustic busker closing off the otherwise excellent The Plague Never Dies. As much as these flaws tarnish the experience for me, I still think Violent Mosh is deserving of 3 stars. I'll definitely check out their first full length at some point.

My options weren't great in the April Review Draft for The North, but I must admit that I felt like an explorer intent on uncovering a hidden treasure when I selected Sturmgeist's Meister Mephisto album from 2005. It had ok ratings, and I generally find enjoyment whenever industrial and black metal are melded together (Aborym, Thorns etc.). My confidence was quickly challenged though, with the first few tracks having very little to do with black metal at all. Instead I was experiencing a strange version of German industrial metal with a gothic coat of paint. I did however quickly recognise the vocalist as none other than Cornelius Jakhelln from the very avant-garde Solefald, and this fact alone reinvigorated me to push on and give the album time to work whatever magic the crazy guy was conjuring into my ear. Fast forward three full listens and I have to say that I've not discovered anything that I particularly enjoy. Simplistic riffs can be fine in industrial metal when the album is given a huge production, but that's not the case here. Cornelius' vocals are generally always over-theatrical, but I find them to be extra difficult to tolerate in this framework. The album does veer further into black metal as it goes on though, particularly closing track Walpurgisnacht - 2. Satz: Meister Mephisto, and it's here that I feel the band's potential is uncovered. Sadly, it's too little too late, with the remaining bad taste convincing me that this is one bottle I won't be partaking from in future.

Daniel has recommended this album to me a couple of times in the past, but I ignored him, just like I tried to do when we were kids and he refused to get out of my room. I'm starting to wonder whether he did actually have something interesting to say all those times. It still seems unlikely, but on this occassion I have to begrudgingly admit that he's right. The Howling Void's second full length, Shadows Over the Cosmos, is 100% up my alley, and I'm hitting myself (which also happens to be something he used to make me do) that I didn't check it out earlier. This is Skepticism worship of the highest order, with slow pounding drums, a backdrop of atmospheric yet non-invasive keyboards, deep chasm-filling death vocals, and a combination of simplistic yet impactful heavy riffs and gorgeous melodies. If you like Funeral Doom Metal, and it's definitely not for everyone, then there's absolutely no reason that you won't find this to be a crushing and emotionally moving album. That said, it is an album that needs a couple of spins before you can really appreciate it, but that's really a given for music as sparse and lengthy as this (there are only four real tracks, but it still has a running time of just under an hour).

How this rates 3.47 on RYM while albums it clearly matches in quality and style are up over 3.70 is just beyond me. Sonny, don't be like me and ignore this release any longer (if indeed you haven't already checked it out). I think you'll dig this! The title track and closing monster Lord of the Black Gulf are my highlights.

This is my first time listening to Trepalium and I have to say it's been interesting to say the least. I'd noticed the avant-garde metal tag applied to it, so expected something out of the ordinary, but I wasn't at all prepared for what I got. I don't know if this is representative of what this French band normally produce, but what we have here is a mix of funk, groove and... I don't know... swing? That description's not really doing it justice, so let me try again. Can you imagine The Muppets doing a metal cabaret based on the film Metropolis? No? Well, Voodoo Moonshine may just scratch an itch you never knew you had!

Once I came to grips with the style, I've spent quite a bit of time letting it sink in before making any sort of judgement. The result is that I do quite enjoy this EP. At only 23 minutes in length, it doesn't overstay it's welcome, and the six tracks on offer are reasonably consistent in quality. That said, there are certainly aspects that grate on me, and despite the release having a very unique sound, it doesn't compete with the genius songwriting and hilarity of Mr. Bungle's debut (which I consider a distant ancestor). Points for something different though, and I'm certainly glad I've danced with these wangas!

This is my first experience with U.S. band Xibalba. They appear to have been a metalcore outfit at one point, but this latest album is very much a death metal release with a couple of doom metal tracks tacked onto the end. As that description suggests, the album has a strange flow to it, having a heavy pummelling death metal approach for the most part, before changing gears entirely for the rest. I actually the enjoy the production, and when I focus on individual moving parts, Años en infierno seems to have all the ingredients to be a rewarding experience. The issue is really in the songwriting though, with all the chopping and changing resulting in several tracks that lack any sort of identity. It's a bit sad when the most memorable tracks are an instrumental, that admittedly has very cool tribal drumming throughout, and a lengthy doom metal track that's somewhat tarnished by sub-par clean vocal sections. I have a feeling these guys could do something that really hits home, but they haven't got their crafting sensibilities in order at this point.

I can't say I was too excited about picking this release in the March Review Draft for The Fallen, but I think that had more to do with the band's silly name than it being an atmospheric sludge metal album. I shouldn't have judged a book by it's cover, as I've ended up finding quite a lot to enjoy on the band's third full length. It's certainly on the lighter side of the subgenre, with many sections sitting just as comfortably in alternative metal territory than anything close to sludge, but it does contain enough heavy riffs to satisfy my personal preferences. I can't say I ever really get bored while listening to it, despite the 71 minute running time, and many of the tracks have strong identifying features and hooks that slide under your skin with ease. All this said, the album is certainly not without flaws. There's a simplicity in the vocals that often seems at odds with the neatly structured music, and while vocalist Brent Vanneste has a pleasant (mostly clean) style, he rarely moves beyond safe, unimaginative pastures. Still, I like The Hutch enough to be interested in checking out more form the band, who thankfully go by the more palatable name Stake these days. I'll give it a mildly generous 3.5 stars for keeping my interest for several listens. If you're interested in checking out what this is all about, the three track run of Photonic, Push/Pull and Pilgrimage of a Black Heart is, in my opinion, the strongest part of the album.

My only previous experience with Greek band Varathron, prior to selecting Patriarchs of Evil for the latest North Review Draft, was their debut album His Majesty at the Swamp from 1993. I recall enjoying that release, but found it difficult to get past just how similar it was to the work of their countrymates Rotting Christ. It utilised the same palm muted riffing technique and had very similar melodic tones. It also had a similarly weak production, so it's not surprising that I gave the debuts from both bands the same score (3.5 stars).

When listening to the band's most recent effort (their sixth full length album), it quickly became apparent that the production is vastly improved. However, apart from this clean, modern sound, very little has changed in the 25 years since the aforementioned debut. If anything, I think this album sounds ever more like Rotting Christ than the band did previously, which is some effort. There are a few blastbeat sections, which I don't recall being present on the debut, but otherwise it utlises the same techniques and song structures that you'd expect from a Hellenic black metal band. I can't deny that the songwriting is decent, and the eight tracks have enough variety to them to keep me interested throughout. At the end of the day, this album brings nothing fresh or particularly creative, but it's solid and entertaining enough to get the same 3.5 star score.

If you want to check a couple of tracks out, I'd recommend Into the Absurd or the closing epic Ouroboros Dweller (The Dweller of Barathrum).

Funeral doom metal is not for everyone. I can fully appreciate that some metal fans would find it boring and monotonous. It's actually difficult to describe why I love it so much, but ever since I first heard Esoteric, Skepticism and Shape of Despair back in 2001, I've found it to be the metal subgenre that I connect with the most consistently. That said, even I have to give many funeral doom albums a few listens before they wrap their tendrils around me and drag me into their heavenly depths. Colosseum's third and final release, Chapter 3: Parasomnia, is a prime example of an album that needs to sit for a while before it can be fully appreciated. What first seems to be an overly long and simplistic album has many subtleties that only work their magic with time, at which point you find yourself wondering why you didn't appreciate them the first time. In particular, the band utilises synths and strings in a very unobtrusive way and it's possibly more effective for it, as the doomy metal aspects remain front and centre throughout. Anyone that enjoys the beautifully crushing sound of fellow Finnish doomsters Shape of Despair will no doubt find euphoric pockets here, but Colosseum don't quite reach the emotional heights of their countrymen. As much as I hate to say it, given he committed suicide prior to the album's release, I do feel that frontman Juhani Palomäki's deep vocals are not quite as strong as I'd like them to be. Even still, this is pretty close to a 4.5 star album for me. It may even get there with a few more spins.

Temple Nightside were completely unknown to me prior to picking The Hecatomb for this month's Horde Review Draft (apart from noting the great artwork on this album's cover while adding it to the site). I'm so very grateful for the introduction, as this is way up my alley. I'm most attracted to death metal when it's dark as fuck and sounds like it was created by demons in the bowels of hell. Well that's exactly what we have here! With a really organic sounding production (particularly the drums, which I love) and growled echoing vocals that feel like they're coming out of the music rather than being placed on top of it, I find myself reminded of the legendary disEMBOWELMENT, despite Temple Nightside leaning far more into the blasting death metal spectrum. If that comparison seems odd, given this is listed as a death / black metal album, I personally think it contains much more doom than black, and disEMBOWELMENT were one of the few death doom bands that actually contained legitimate death metal. The riffs on The Hecatomb are also incredibly dark and heavy, not to mention memorable and genuinely effective, making this album one of the finds of the year for me. The fact that Temple Nightside, like disEMBOWELMENT, hail from my home country, make it just a bit sadder that I haven't discovered them until now. It's exciting to see that they have three other albums and an EP to sink my teeth into.

The Metal Academy Review Drafts are certainly making me check out releases that I probably never would have otherwise. As much as I enjoyed Whiplash's debut album Power and Pain from 1986, I'd never considered delving any further into their discography. Having now spent some time with their third release, Insult to Injury, I don't think I've missed out on all that much, but that's not to say that there's no enjoyment to be had. By this point the band had taken a significant step away from the Exodus-like aggression of the debut and moved into more Judas Priest style heavy metal. In fact, there's so much heavy metal on this album that I don't think it would sound out of place in The Guardians. I think this transition is a bit problematic for the band though. When you can no longer hide behind thrashing intensity, songwriting ability becomes far more important, and unfortunately Insult to Injury is a bit hit and miss on that front. For every good track, such as the title track and highlight Essence of Evil, there's a less memorable effort, such as Hiroshima and the appropriately titled Rape of the Mind. In the end this is a decent listen for anyone that enjoys bands that straddle the heavy / thrash line (such as Metal Church), but it's an album I likely won't go back to very often.

I've always considered myself a fan of this album, having picked it up on release. At that point in my metal journey, I'd become increasingly interested in bands that took the black metal blueprint and mixed in other influences. Bands like Ved Buens Ende....., Fleurety, Arcturus, Aborym and Dødheimsgard excited me greatly, so I had no issue at all with ...And Oceans giving their black metal a healthy dose of cyber symphonics. I've since listened to it many times while doing other things, enjoying its strange atmosphere and numerous special moments, thinking that one day I'll finally sit down and write a review to inform others of this hidden gem. Well, it hasn't quite worked out that way! Now that I sit down and totally focus on A.M.G.O.D. as an album, it's actually a hit and miss affair that I just can't rate as highly as I expected to. It starts strongly, with the first three tracks showcasing the band's interesting approach of injecting invasive symphonic aspects into otherwise decent melodic black metal (this sounds nothing like Emperor in case you're wondering), but sadly goes a bit downhill from there. By the time I get to the admittedly atmospheric but highly repetitive instrumental TBA in a Silver Box and the divisive techno beast that is New World Model, I have to admit that I was previously overrating A.M.G.O.D. as an album, if not as an enjoyable sideshow that has numerous great moments.

I'll say straight off that if you enjoy Candlemass and Solitude Aeturnus, I thoroughly recommend checking out this debut EP from Swedish band Memory Garden. It contains the sort of doomy riffs and soaring vocals that you'd expect from both of those classic bands. So why am I only giving it 3 stars? Well, for starters, it's only 18 minutes in length which is, particularly for a doom release, reasonably insubstantial. But the main reason I can't give Forever the sort of score that it probably deserves is due to vocalist Stefan Berglund. He's a fantastic singer, clearly having a level of training to match the legendary vocalists from the aforementioned bands. But, well, he has such a strong lisp that I find myself laughing at how hilarious it all sounds. If you've ever watched Monty Python and the Holy Grail, well imagine if Biggus Dickus joined a doom metal band and sang lyrics such as "With my thord and thpear, I'll make the hereticth thuffer." It's such a shame really, as this is otherwise great.

While I've always been aware of Assassin (their debut album The Upcoming Terror is held in reasonably high regard), I'm not certain I'd ever checked them out. Selecting their 5th album, 2016's Combat Cathedral, as my November draft pick for The Pit has given me the opportunity to do just that. Right from the get go I've been impressed with what I've heard. The production is strong, and the band certainly know how to write punchy thrash riffs. Vocalist Ingo Bajonczak is a definite highlight too, being a cross between Testament's Chuck Billy and Pantera's Phil Anselmo, albeit with a German accent. When I listen to the album while doing other things, I'm consistently drawn in by the album's highlight moments, but I have to admit that it's formulaic approach and 53 minute running time have made it a bit of a slog to really focus on in one sitting. In the end I think I get enough enjoyment out of Combat Cathedral to go with 3.5 stars. If you enjoy traditional thrash metal, you could do a lot worse than this.

It's my understanding that Necrodeath released a couple of decent thrash metal albums in the late 80s, but the awful ratings that are generally attributed to Ton(e)s of Hate made me feel pretty uncomfortable about having to pick it for the latest Horde Review Draft. It didn't take long for me to understand why its been so consistently criticised over the years. While the death and thrash genre tags are accurate, it's fairly clear that the band were attempting to make an accessible and occasionally pop-inspired release. What they completely forgot to do in the process was include great riffs, or any riffs really. While it's not unusual for bass players to simply accompany the guitar riffs in this style of music, I think it's pretty rare that the base completely overpowers the guitars in the mix. I find myself knowing what the riffs probably are at any given moment, but all I can really hear is the bass. It causes the whole experience to lack power and impact, particularly during the thrashier sections where the riffs should be front and centre. Even ignoring any production issues, the songwriting just isn't that great, with some of the more memorable sections only being so because they're repetitive and annoying. Queen of Desire is probably the only track that I really enjoy the whole way through, with no silly repetitious vocal line or grating cymbal / cowbell combo. These Italians have 13 full length releases, but I can't say that Ton(e) of Hate has made me want to go and check any of the others out.

I very much enjoyed Spanish band Negativa's unimaginatively titled 2022 album 04, so was excited to be able to first pick it's predecessor (yep, you guessed it...03) in the November Review Draft for The North. My excitement appeared to be well founded after the first couple of tracks, with both XVII and XVIII having the same hypnotic Shining-meets-modern-Leviathan quality that made 04 so effective.  The band really understand how to get the most out of their riffs, with the other instruments staying relatively clear of the spotlight while they work their magic. This restraint makes the uptempo sections all that more effective, and allow tracks that might otherwise have blended together to become more memorable. Sadly, after this great start, 03 gradually falls away throughout the remaining four tracks, becoming less and less gripping, right up to the noisy and fairly pointless final track, XXII. There's enough good stuff here to hang on for a 3.5 star rating, but I'm fairly certain 03 will always sit behind 04 (see what I did there?) to the point I'm not sure I'll revisit this with any regularity.

It took me a while to find my way to the gothic metal genre, having first formed an obsession with death doom in the early nineties. If you ignore the gothic aspect of My Dying Bride, it was probably Moonspell and Tiamat that gave me my first real taste, along with Type O Negative's October Rust. It wasn't until late in 1998, when I returned home from a trip to Utopia Records in Sydney with The Gathering's How to Measure a Planet and Theatre of Tragedy's Aegis, that the ingredient that really draws me to the genre was revealed to me... female vocals. Musicianship is rarely the main focus in gothic metal, with atmosphere and song-writing being brought right to the fore. The angelic beauty of Anneke van Giersbergen and Liv Kristine's performances on these two albums completely destroyed me, and formed an infatuation that has continued up to the present, when Heike Langhans (Draconian) and Aleah (Trees of Eternity) blissfully torture my soul. That first The Gathering experience led me to the band's most prized releases, and while many fans appear to prefer 1995's Mandylion, it's Nighttime Birds that became (and remains) my personal favourite.

It often feels like this album was designed to showcase just how talented Anneke is. The softer moments allow her emotion and tenderness to shine, while the heavier sections are really just vehicles for her to soar to places most vocalists could only ever dream of. The lyrics are simplistic and at times almost child-like, but they're given huge gravitas and power through her delivery. The music does everything it needs to do, while occasionally introducing creative techniques and instrumentation that aren't often heard in metal. A few of these more experimental moments aren't all the successful for me, particularly the toe-tapping chorus section of Third Chance, which ruins any chance that Nighttime Birds had of receiving 5 stars from me. In the end though, I'm really glad that the October Review Draft allowed me to use my first pick and finally give this a review and rating.

4.5 stars

The Review Draft here at Metal Academy has again forced me to really delve into a release from a band I'd previously only dabbled with, only to find that I've been missing out on something great. This EP from English band Solstice is a pretty clear mix of heavy metal and doom metal and while that combination doesn't always bring me joy, the great production and epic atmosphere of these 4 tracks have put this right in my wheelhouse. I may not personally feel that the Epic Doom Metal subgenre is required, but surely the music on display here is exactly what the pushers have in mind. If the excellent riffs, melodies and leads aren't enough to make you think of times long past and glories well earned, then Paul Kearns' soaring vocals surely will. The band that most comes to mind when listening to this EP is Manowar, with slightly less cheese and a fair bit more doom. I'm actually fine with that, and now find myself eager to delve into the rest of Solstice's discography. As far as recommendations go, there's really only two tracks (along with lengthy intro and outro instrumentals), with the near 10 minute monster title track being the easy highlight for me. In fact, I think I'll request this track be included in the October Fallen playlist to share the glory.

Aspid's one and only release is an album I've had on my radar for many years, but just never got around to checking out until now. Perhaps it's the technical thrash metal tag that caused me to put it off, having a somewhat rocky relationship with the subgenre. Or maybe I'd unfairly written it off, figuring it would likely be an overrated and underproduced record from a part of the world not known for its thrash metal. While I can't be sure why it has taken me this long, I can say that I'm very happy that I've finally made the effort. Not only does the album sound a lot better than I expected to, these guys have serious chops to go with it! Similar to what Sadus were producing back in the 90s, Кровоизлияние (which apparently translates to Extravasation, whatever that means) is filled with great riffs, a heap of time changes, really nice leads, impressive and very audible bass, and enough variety for it remain exciting for it's entire 48 minute runtime. Vitaly Kholopov's vocals are quite aggressive for thrash, particularly in his native Russian, and the music itself occasionally approaches death metal (the awesome blastbeats on track 6 make me wish they'd pushed things a little further).

As good as I've found this album to be, I don't think I can justify anything higher than 4 stars. For starters, I don't consider any of the 8 individual tracks to deserve a full 5 stars. I also can't ignore that fifth track Эй ты fails to make much of an impression, and the lengthy intro is both tacky and unsuited to what follows. Overall though, consider me a fan, and given how dead thrash metal was in 1993 (Anacrusis' Screams and Whispers excluded, but that was really a progressive metal album), this certainly deserves its high standing in the metal community.

I was stoked when this Lunar Aurora album was still available for me to select in this month's Review Draft for The North. I'm a big fan of the band's later work, particularly 2007's Andacht, but had never managed to check out any of their discography prior to 2004. I'll say straight up that this doesn't sound like the band's later albums, which sit comfortably in the atmospheric black metal subgenre. This release is much more primal and raw, taking influence from numerous classic 90s black metal albums while forging a strong identity of its own. There's also a big symphonic aspect, to the point where I'm shocked no-one appears to consider Ars Moriendi to be a symphonic black metal release. Emperor is an obvious influence,  and while the symphonics may not contribute to the whole album, they play a big role for much of it. There are lots of other sound effects that appear throughout too, such as wind, the howling of wolves and chimes, creating a wintry atmosphere that the majestic black metal riffs back up perfectly. I can also hear early Satyricon and particularly Abigor, putting this album into my absolute soft spot.

If you're at all like me, you like your black metal vocals to be really fucking evil sounding, and thankfully bassist Whyrhd really delivers on this front. Along with his fantastic, albeit traditional black metal shrieks, he at times sounds completely possessed, as though the demon from The Evil Dead escaped from the basement and joined a German black metal band. Add this manic performance to the top-notch riffs and intense drumming and you've got all the ingredients of a classic, but sadly it doesn't quite live up to that. There are just a couple of tracks that don't quite match up to the better parts of the album, and third track Kältetod inexplicably contains a pretty dodgy snare sound that I find really distracting. I can't fathom how this happened, but I have noticed that there are at least a couple of different mixes of the album available. Perhaps this track has a different mix, or maybe it was just recorded separately? I don't know, but it sadly stops me from giving Ars Moriendi the 4.5 stars that it otherwise deserves. Seriously, if you enjoy 90s black metal, and can handle some symphonics with your blastbeats, you should check this hidden gem out.

I reckon I've listened to most of Insomnium's discography over the years, but never really dedicated the time to explore it well enough for a review. The Horde Review Draft gave me the opportunity to change that, so I took it with open arms. There is very little new in what this band do (it's easy to hear the influence of numerous other Scandinavian bands), but they work their craft in a very professional and palatable way. It's fairly accessible stuff, even with the brutal path that the vocals take on occasion, and the melodies consistently take priority over the more traditional death metal riffing. I have to admit that this particular album occasionally oversteps with this accessibility, particularly Through the Shadows, which I'm surprised to find is considered a highlight by many fans. Thankfully the teeth-grit-inducing clean vocal chorus, that comfortably make that track the worst on the album for me, isn't a sign of things to come. In fact, it's follow-up, Song of the Blackest Bird, makes up for it in no uncertain terms, containing fantastic death vocals and a heady mix of Dark Tranquillity and Amorphis. The rest of the album contains enough variety to keep things exciting, while rarely overstepping that personal accessibility tipping point.

I'm not at all surprised to find that Daniel gave this album 2.5 stars, as he's never been a big fan of Swedish (or Finnish) melodic death metal, and I can't see this album converting anyone that feels that way. As someone that's more than a little partial for this type of thing, One for Sorrow is a very solid and entertaining example, and one that I'll definitely return to from time to time. If you want a taster, check out the aforementioned Song of the Blackest Bird, Unsung or the epic Septic Flesh reminding closing title track. It's 4 stars for me.

This Devil Master album has strongly reinforced why I should never judge an album on first listen. I was far from impressed with the punky Venom-like debauchery on offer, feeling fairly certain that I'd be dumping 2 out of 5 on this in a week's time. Little was I to know that each subsequent listen was going to reveal a surprising amount of memorable and enjoyable aspects that were initially overcome by my gag reflex. I must admit that the drumming is a big part of the problem, having that simplistic punk style that always rubs me up the wrong way, but boy there are some good riffs behind them. Nearly every track has really memorable and entertaining guitar work, turning what I thought was a one-dimensional album into one I found myself looking forward to returning to. I have no idea what deathrock is (this album is listed as Black Metal and Deathrock), but if closing track Never Ending Night is a good representation of it, it might be something I should check out. I totally dig this track! I can't quite push this into 4 star territory, but given my original impression, the fact that it's close tells me it might just get there given time. If you don't mind some punk in your black metal, then I recommend given Ecstasies of Never Ending Night a listen (or 5).

2022 RANKING (69 releases so far)

43. The Chasm - The Scars of a Lost Reflective Shadow - 3.5 stars

44. Devil Master - Ecstasies of Never Ending Night - 3.5 stars

45. The Halo Effect - Days of the Lost - 3.5 stars

2022 BLACK RANKING (31 releases so far)

19. Moonlight Sorcery - Piercing Through the Frozen Eternity - 3.5 stars

20. Devil Master - Ecstasies of Never Ending Night - 3.5 stars

21. Véhémence - Ordalies

It took me a long time to appreciate the early to mid 80s era of doom metal. In fact, if it wasn't for the Metal Academy podcast, I may never have properly listened to the likes of Trouble, Saint Vitus, Witchfinder General and Pentagram. Even with this only recently developed appreciation, I have to admit that I tend to like my doom metal to be much darker and heavier than this classic heavy metal influenced era contained, and it's for this reason that Obsidian Sea have been a bit of a struggle for me. Sure, there's doom metal here, but there's also a very light atmosphere, and a heavy metal /progressive rock approach that takes it out of my comfort zone. It actually reminds me quite a bit of Warlord on occasion, particularly the track Mythos. Heck, a cowbell pops up from time to time, which really tells you all you need to know. In the end I guess I just don't get a tremendous amount out of it, despite not finding anything much to complain about, so I'll simply call this album mildly enjoyable but not particularly for me.

2022 RANKING (68 releases so far)

59. Saidan - Onryō II: Her Spirit Eternal - 3 stars

60. Obsidian Sea - Pathos - 3 stars

61. Stangarigel - Na Severe Srdca - 2.5 stars

2022 DOOM RANKING (19 releases so far)

16. Temple of Void - Summoning the Slayer - 3 stars

17. Obsidian Sea - Pathos - 3 stars

18. Mizmor - Wit's End - 2.5 stars

I'll start by saying that I've always been a fan of melodic death metal. There appear to be a lot of more conventional death metal fans that simply can't get into the accessible and melodic version of the genre, but that's simply not the case for me. So when I saw that four ex-members of In Flames (guitarists Jesper Strömblad & Niclas Engelin, bass player Peter Iwers and drummer Daniel Svensson) had put together a new band with Dark Tranquillity vocalist Mikael Stanne, I was more than a little intrigued. The instant I pressed play on The Halo Effect's debut Days of of the Lost, I was taken way back to the late 90s, when In Flames produced a number a really good releases that played a major role in the creation of the Swedish melodic death metal movement. This album is almost a carbon copy of what the band were doing during their heyday, with the added benefit of Stanne's vocals, which I've always preferred to the more violent approach of Anders Fridén.

As comfortable and nostalgic as it is to listen to the 10 tracks on offer, I do have to admit that the overall experience falls a little short of the classics the performer's previous bands produced. For starters, it's quite top heavy, with the early quality of tracks like Shadowminds and Days of the Lost falling away to more lacklustre efforts in the second half, particularly A Truth Worth Lying For. In fact, as much as quite enjoy the tone of Stannes' clean vocals, the tracks where this becomes the focus fail to hit the mark. I would also have liked for the band to break out of the verse chorus verse chorus blueprint at least a couple of times on the album, but with no track that pushes the five minute mark, there is very little room for any real creativity or progression. I guess I'm mentioning these apparent flaws to explain my 3 and a half stars, despite Days of the Lost being a very well performed and produced album in a style that these bands originated. I'll definitely listen to this again, but it doesn't do enough to trouble any end of year lists.

2022 RANKING (67 releases so far)

43. The Chasm - The Scars of a Lost Reflective Shadow - 3.5 stars

44. The Halo Effect - Days of the Lost - 3.5 stars

45. Véhémence - Ordalies

2022 DEATH RANKING (17 releases so far)

13. The Chasm - The Scars of a Lost Reflective Shadow - 3.5 stars

14. The Halo Effect - Days of the Lost - 3.5 stars

15. Undeath - It's Time... to Rise From the Grave - 3.5 stars

Wow! Why have I not checked out this Chilean band before?! This album, which is the band's third, has jumped into my top slot for 2022 by quite some margin. I can't say that it does anything particularly new, but it's exactly what I want from my death metal. Inanna sound a lot like Immolation, but I can also hear Morbid Angel mixed with the progressive side of Death. Given those three bands are amongst my favourite bands in metal, there was a fair chance I was going to be into this. The production is fantastic, with a great drum sound and the perfect emphasis on both lead and rhythm guitars. I absolutely love the vocals too, which have that deep yet decipherable power that the likes of Dave Vincent perform so well. In the end though it's the wonderful song-crafting and atmosphere that make Void of Unending Depths so enjoyable. This is a dark death metal album that manages to combine brutality and intensity with melody and progressive flair. There's rarely a moment that isn't captivating, and given the length of the tracks, that takes immense dedication and talent. I'm sure every metal fan knows those moments when listening to an album that make them close their eyes and smile, and then pump their fist and want to roar. This album is full of those moments for me.

Members of The Horde simply must check this album out. Those members of The Infinite that don't mind the more extreme side of metal should also add it to their playlist. I wouldn't at all be surprised if this is my album of the year, and we're only two-thirds of the way through. A full 5 stars!

2022 RANKING (66 releases so far)

1. Inanna - Void of Unending Depths - 5 stars

2. Shape of Despair - Return to the Void - 5 stars

3. Scarcity - Aveilut - 4.5 stars

2022 DEATH RANKING (16 releases so far)

1. Inanna - Void of Unending Depths - 5 stars

2. Immolation - Acts of God - 4.5 stars

3. Artificial Brain - Artificial Brain - 4.5 stars

I should have known this wasn't going to be for me. The anime cover alone should have been a warning sign, but the Blackgaze / Post-Hardcore primaries combined with Screamo / J-Rock secondaries really should have rammed it home. The fact is that I'm not particularly experienced with any of these genres, so checking this album out in the hope of finding something to my tastes was more than a little naïve. No-one can say that I didn't give it a try though! To me this sounds like the sort of metal that a certain teenage crowd would really get into (note that I don't mean any offense to older fans, it's just my perception of it). Not only is it accessible, it also has a party atmosphere to some of the tracks thanks to the chosen beats. There are even leads on this thing that sound like they could accompany the theme song from an 80s/90s sitcom, which is a far stretch from the atmosphere I'm attracted to. Still, this is an album that fell into my clan, so I guess it's fair game. 2.5 stars it is. I would have gone even lower if it wasn't for a couple of mildly enjoyable tracks towards the end, particularly The Forgotten Ones.

2022 RANKING (65 releases so far)

60. Kostnatění - Oheň hoří tam, kde padl 2.5 stars

61. Asunojokei - Island - 2.5 stars

62. Mizmor - Wit's End - 2.5 stars

2022 BLACK RANKING (30 releases so far)

27. Kostnatění - Oheň hoří tam, kde padl 2.5 stars

28. Asunojokei - Island - 2.5 stars

29. Mnima - Disciples of Excremental Liturgies - 2 stars

The album cover for Temple of Void's latest release is pretty fucking awesome, so I had high hopes that this death doom album would deliver the goods. Unfortunately that hasn't turned out to be the case. This failure isn't due to there being anything particularly bad on Summoning the Slayer (well, if I ignore the closing acoustic ballad which is strongly at odds with the rest of the album), but neither is there anything overly impressive. This is just six tracks of by the numbers death doom that neither stirs me emotionally or crushes me into submission. The deep growls of vocalist Mike Erdody are more than adequate, but the riffs and drums create very little emotional impact and occasionally venture into boredom-town. This album is a warm, somewhat comforting, glass of milk when I require a strong cup of coffee or nice bottle of shiraz to really get me going these days. I think a lukewarm 3 stars is appropriate.

2022 RANKING (63 releases so far)

53. Deathhammer - Electric Warfare - 3 stars

54. Temple of Void - Summoning the Slayer - 3 stars

55. Sadness - Tortuga - 3 stars

2022 DOOM RANKING (17 releases so far)

14. Hangman's Chair - A Loner - 3.5 stars

15. Temple of Void - Summoning the Slayer - 3 stars

16. Mizmor - Wit's End - 2.5 stars

Apparently this Canadian band performed grindcore before switching to black metal in recent years. There's certainly an intensity to Thought Form Descent that's suggestive of their background, with roaring vocals and heavy blast beats being major features. Unlike the short burst songwriting of grindcore though, Wake have crafted lengthy, shifting black metal works for this release. It's taken me a while to really appreciate what they're doing, mostly because the guitars are lower in the mix than would be ideal, but I can't deny that this is a solid, impactful album. Bleeding Eyes of the Watcher, the track I included on the recent North playlist, is particularly great, pushing this from a 3.5 to a 4 for me. I'd like to hear more riffs on future releases though, as they're good when they're not hidden behind the onslaught.

2022 RANKING (62 releases so far)

24. Mammoth Weed Wizard Bastard - The Harvest - 4 stars

25. Wake - Through Form Descent - 4 stars

26. Bríi - Corpos transparentes - 4 stars

2022 BLACK RANKING (28 releases so far)

9. Wiegedood - There's Always Blood at the End of the Road - 4 stars

10. Wake - Through Form Descent - 4 stars

11. Bríi - Corpos transparentes - 4 stars

I try to remain open minded when it comes to my metal. If my recent experience with White Ward proved anything to me, it was that I shouldn't accept my initial response to an album as gospel. I thought I was going to hate that album after a single attempt, but after numerous listens, I now consider it be a great release. To say that my first Imperial Triumphant attempt was disconcerting is understating things. Spirit of Ecstasy is an abrasive and chaotic experience, and an album that truly earns the Avant-Garde Metal genre tag. It's like someone threw dissonant death metal, avant-garde jazz and a whole bunch of effects and noise into a blender and turned it up to the max, or so it seemed on first listen. Given the huge praise the release is getting, I committed myself to coming to grips with it as much as I could before deciding how I really feel about it. What's the result? Well, I definitely now have a large amount of appreciation for what these guys have achieved. Many sections of the album are downright brilliant, and the musicianship to pull something like this off is obviously of the highest order. Tracks like Chump Change and Merkurius Gilded have opened up to me quite a lot, to the point where I like a lot more of their running time than I don't. But therein lies the problem for me. There is so much going here, that every track has parts that are, if not entirely unlistenable, just not very entertaining for me beyond novelty. I don't like jazz at all, and it's not going to make it sound better to me if it's performed in an abrasive fashion, or combined with screams and intense percussion. For every moment on this album that I dig, there's another that is just too much. Perhaps others just have a much greater tolerance for chaos than I do.

2022 RANKING (61 releases so far)

47. Negative Plane - The Pact... - 3 stars

48. Imperial Triumphant - Spirit of Ecstasy - 3 stars

49. Kreator - Hate über Alles - 3 stars

2022 DEATH RANKING (15 releases so far)

13. Undeath - It's Time... to Rise From the Grave - 3.5 stars

14. Imperial Triumphant - Spirit of Ecstasy - 3 stars

15. Needless - The Cosmic Cauldron - 3 stars

I think I've just been bitch-slapped by the gods of metal! There I was just a couple of weeks ago wondering whether I'd lost my love for thrash metal. Album after album has been disappointing in recent times to the point where I was left considering whether I was the problem. Thank fuck Critical Defiance came along to set me straight. This is how I like my thrash metal! This Chilean band have followed in the footsteps of some of the more intense 80s and early 90s thrash band, such as Sadus and Morbid Saint. There are riffs flying all over the place, and I can't tell you how happy I am that the production puts them right up front and in your face. Thrash metal has always been about the riffs, and Critical Defiance have given them the love and attention they deserve. The vocalist spits vocals out quite rabidly at times, yet balances that aggression with more controlled rhythms as well, creating an exciting yet palatable level of energy throughout. That said, the awesome mid-album instrumental (the somewhat paradoxically named Elephant) is probably the highlight for me, because it really lets the listener focus in on the band's strength (again, riffs).

The only real flaw here is that the band don't always make the most of all the goodies. While I do appreciate the 29 minute running time, some of the 10 tracks could have been given a bit more time to shine. Many of the best riffs come and go all too quickly, never returning until the listener inevitably presses play again. But I guess I can't have my cake and eat it too. No Life Forms is an exciting thrash metal release, crafted to get your blood pumping and certainly taking no prisoners. Song-writing takes a backseat to keeping the adrenaline going, and who am I to complain. This was the kick up the ass I needed!

2022 RANKING (59 releases so far)

20. Deathspell Omega - The Long Defeat - 4 stars

21. Critical Defiance - No Life Forms - 4 stars

22. Wiegedood - There's Always Blood at the End of the Road - 4 stars

2022 THRASH RANKING (11 releases so far)

1. Critical Defiance - No Life Forms - 4 stars

2. Schizophrenia - Recollections of the Insane - 4 stars

3. Nocturnal Graves - An Outlaw's Stand - 3.5 stars

I'll say straight off that this is an extremely classy and impressive debut album. The level of sophistication and musical sorcery on offer is pushing the top of the scale, and I have very little doubt that Tómarúm could become very big indeed! Very much a black metal album, and a fairly intense one at that, Ash in Realms of Stone Icons enters progressive territory through the use of complex structures, gorgeous leads and a snaking fretless bass that makes its presence known throughout. I have no doubt that fans of bands like Ne Obliviscaris will drool over the result, even if it is more on the extreme side. Despite everything I've said so far being apparent from my first listen, I've spent the last week and a bit trying to figure out just how much I personally enjoy it. Being an obsessive black metal fan, I've actually found some of the progressive aspects to be a bit of a distraction, particularly the bass, which constantly jumps out of the mix in ways that feel a bit unnecessary. Some of the tracks are also a bit longer than they need to be, making listening to the hour long runtime a bit of a daunting prospect. As the album has grown on me, these concerns have lessened, and I'm now very comfortable giving this exciting and at times quite breath-taking debut release 4 stars. I can't wait to hear where Tómarúm go from here!

2022 RANKING (58 releases so far)

15. Tzompantli - Tlazcaltiliztli - 4 stars

16. Tómarúm - Ash in Realms of Stone Icons - 4 stars

17. Druid Lord - Relics of the Dead - 4 stars

2022 BLACK RANKING (27 releases so far)

6. Celeste - Assassine(s) - 4 stars

7. Tómarúm - Ash in Realms of Stone Icons - 4 stars

8. Deathspell Omega - The Long Defeat - 4 stars