Ben's Forum Replies
Ben, I find that whenever I post on a thread that has multiple pages I'm taken back to the start of the first page of the thread rather than to the post I've just submitted. I often find that this happens when I visit a thread from a link on another page too.
It's taking you back to the page you were on when you wrote the reply. So since you're clicking Reply to Thread on the first page, that's where it takes you back to. This never happened to me, because I click through to the most recent page before entering my reply at the end of the thread. Once I post it, I'm taken straight to my reply.
I'll see if I can make it so that the user is always taken to the end of the thread when they post a reply.
The following bands have been added to Metal Academy on the 11th of September, 2019:
1. Dream Quest (GUARDIANS, INFINITE) - requested by DippoMagoo
2. Light Bringer (GUARDIANS, INFINITE) - requested by Deadnight Warrior
3. Dünedain (GUARDIANS) - requested by DippoMagoo
4. Lovebites (GUARDIANS) - requested by Deadnight Warrior
5. Spotlights (INFINITE, FALLEN)
6. Igorrr (INFINITE) - requested by Xephyr
7. Cormorant (INFINITE, HORDE, NORTH)
8. Beyond the Bridge (INFINITE) - requested by Xephyr
9. Kristendom (HORDE)
10. Enshine (HORDE, FALLEN)
11. Dementor (HORDE)
12. Hate Eternal (HORDE)
13. Defacement (HORDE, NORTH)
14. Psycroptic (HORDE) - requested by Daniel
15. Notre Dame (FALLEN, NORTH)
16. Remembrance (FALLEN) - requested by Daniel
17. Cultes des Ghoules (NORTH)
18. Cor Scorpii (NORTH) - requested by illusionist
19. Mo'ynoq (NORTH)
20. Caladan Brood (NORTH)
The following bands have been added to Metal Academy on the 9th/10th of September, 2019:
1. Rok (PIT, NORTH)
2. Demoniac (NORTH, GUARDIANS)
3. Violet Cold (NORTH)
4. Catamenia (NORTH, HORDE) - requested by illusionist
5. Kaevum (NORTH)
6. Cirith Gorgor (NORTH)
7. Dordeduh (NORTH)
8. Nordjevel (NORTH)
9. Hypno5e (INFINITE, HORDE)
10. Pressure Points (INFINITE) - requested by Daniel
11. Dragon Guardian (GUARDIANS) - requested by DeadnightWarrior
12. Dreamtale (GUARDIANS) - requested by DippoMagoo
13. Dragonfly (GUARDIANS) - requested by DippoMagoo
14. Imperial Circus Dead Decadence (HORDE, GUARDIANS) - requested by DeadnightWarrior
15. Noctambulist (HORDE)
Yeah, the font size would shrink if press backspace in a review that's already blank, so I have to refresh the page. Please fix it, Ben!
I believe this little problem has been fixed now. Let me know if you disagree.
Cheers.
I came here to suggest exactly this. Clicking through all the numbers of pages to get back to specific letters of bands was a little tedious as I was alphabetically filling out my ratings over the last week.
This feature has been added. Check it out and let me know what you think.
Cellar Darling
Chaos Divine
Eumeria
Intervals
Pomegranate Tiger
Votum
Witherfall
Xanthochroid
Thank you!
All have been added.
Wolves In The Throne Room - "Two Hunters" (2007)
Superb atmospheric black metal from Washington USA. Mixes the classic Scandinavian black metal sound of Burzum, Darkthrone & Emperor with the post-metal of Neurosis & Isis & the analogue ambience of Gas & Popol Vuh. Quite possibly the best US black metal release ever recorded.
4.5/5
Couldn't agree more. Definitely my favourite WitTR album.
The following bands have been added to Metal Academy on the 6th of September, 2019:
1. 40 Watt Sun (FALLEN)
2. Bridear (GUARDIANS) - requested by DeadnightWarrior
3. Vultures Vengeance (GUARDIANS)
4. Burning Witches (GUARDIANS)- requested by DeadnightWarrior
5. Imperial (PIT)
6. Gehennah (PIT, NORTH)
7. Ritual Carnage (PIT, HORDE)
8. Death Toll 80k (HORDE)
9. Inanimate Existence (HORDE, INFINITE)
10. Pensées nocturnes (INFINITE, NORTH) - requested by Daniel
11. Akphaezya (INFINITE) - requested by illusionist
12. Witherfall (INFINITE) - requested by Xephyr
13. Akasha (NORTH)
14. Abbath (NORTH) - requested by illusionist
15. Petrychor (NORTH) - requested by Daniel
16. Aquilus (NORTH)
Awesome Thanks!
Could i also request:
Dopethrone (The Fallen)
Pseudogod (The North)
Vortex of End (The North)
Throane (The North/The Fallen)
Tetragrammacide (The North/The Horde)
All done.
The following bands have been added to Metal Academy on the 5th of September, 2019:
1. Xanthochroid (INFINITE, NORTH, GUARDIANS) - requested by illusionist
2. Votum (INFINITE) - requested by Xephyr
3. Instanzia (GUARDIANS)
4. Orden Ogan (GUARDIANS, NORTH)
5. Tiluland (GUARDIANS)
6. Unshine (GUARDIANS, FALLEN) - requested by Xephyr
7. Tsatthoggua (NORTH)
8. Swordmaster (NORTH, PIT, HORDE)
9. Vortex of End (NORTH) - requested by Vlgrim
10. Infernö (PIT)
11. Zyklon (HORDE) - requested by illusionist
12. Witch Vomit (HORDE)
13. Infernal Conjuration (HORDE)
Ben, please add October Falls (Finland).
Done
I figure this is as good of a place as any to also mention that I'm seeing two duplicate artist entries for Timeghoul
Fixed! Thanks for letting me know.
Ben, please add Order of Ennead (USA & Orpheus Omega (Australia).
Done.
The following bands have been added to Metal Academy on the 3rd/4th of September, 2019:
1. Magrudergrind (HORDE)
2. Sadistik Exekution (HORDE, PIT, NORTH)
3. Musmahhu (HORDE)
4. Orpheus Omega (HORDE) - requested by Daniel
5. MyGrain (HORDE) - requested by illusionist
6. Belzebubs (HORDE, NORTH)
7. Luciferion (HORDE) - requested by illusionist
8. Funebrarum (HORDE)
9. Bewitched (PIT, GUARDIANS, NORTH)
10. While Heaven Wept (GUARDIANS, FALLEN, INFINITE)
11. Syu (GUARDIANS, INFINITE) - requested by Xephyr
12. Pomegranate Tiger (INFINITE) - requested by Xephyr
13. Throane (NORTH, FALLEN, INFINITE) - requested by Vlgrim
14. Devil Master (NORTH)
15. Tetragrammacide (NORTH) - requested by Vlgrim
16. Drautran (NORTH)
17. The Fall of Every Season (FALLEN)
18. Diabolos Rising (SPHERE)
This is all fantastic feedback Xephyr. I'll begin work on all of it and see what we can do.
The site has over 12,000 releases now, and I'm still adding popular bands. Just shows how massive the history of metal is!
Rise Above Records is complete. I've done a lot of research, but can only discover 98 metal releases on the label to date, so technically this list is complete for now.
There have been no further list requests, so I'm going to do...Osmose Productions. Shouldn't take long to hit 100 releases, as I've added the majority of bands already.
The following bands have been added to Metal Academy on the 1st/2nd of September, 2019:
1. Torche (FALLEN)
2. Witchskull (FALLEN)
3. Menace Ruine (FALLEN, NORTH)
4. Dopethrone (FALLEN) - requested by Vlgrim
5. Kylesa (FALLEN) - requested by illusionist
6. Saint Deamon (GUARDIANS)
7. Theocracy (GUARDIANS)
8. Keldian (GUARDIANS) - requested by illusionist
9. Blasphereion (HORDE)
10. Masacre (HORDE)
11. Pseudogod (HORDE, NORTH) - requested by Vlgrim
12. Order of Ennead (HORDE, NORTH) - requested by Daniel
13. Moon Tooth (INFINITE, GATEWAY)
14. Intervals (INFINITE) - requested by Xephyr
15. Eumeria (INFINITE) - requested by Xephyr
16. Gruzja (NORTH)
17. October Falls (NORTH) - requested by Daniel
18. Wormwitch (NORTH)
Have you forgotten to put up the last three bands I requested Ben? It's probably been a week since I posted them.
I somehow missed those. Two are done now.
The following bands have been added to Metal Academy on the 29th/30th of August, 2019:
1. Ides of Gemini (FALLEN)
2. Colosseum (FALLEN)
3. Beastmaker (FALLEN)
4. Saturn (GUARDIANS)
5. Judicator (GUARDIANS) - requested by illusionist
6. CMX (INFINITE)
7. Chaos Divine (INFINITE, HORDE) - requested by Xephyr
8. Cellar Darling (INFINITE) - requested by Xephyr
9. Odraza (NORTH) - requested by Vlgrim
10. Trist (NORTH)
11. Sielunvihollinen (NORTH)
12. Inferno (NORTH) - requested by Vlgrim
13. Hoth (NORTH, HORDE) - requested by illusionist
14. Shadow of Intent (REVOLUTION, HORDE)
15. Cerebral Rot (HORDE)
Yeah, the font size would shrink if press backspace in a review that's already blank, so I have to refresh the page. Please fix it, Ben!
I've noticed that. Will try to fix.
Keep the suggestions coming guys!
As for The Others, there is another clan for non-metal releases, but it's hidden from all the views. I'm more than happy to include non-metal releases by otherwise metal bands, but I think the focus of the site would suffer if we started adding purely rock bands or any other genres for that matter. If I start adding Nirvana, Van Halen and Guns N' Roses, I think we've probably gone in a direction we didn't intend to.
Haha, I've heard of RuneScape but not played it. In fact, I tend to stay away from MMORPGs due to my obsessive personality (I prefer to devote my obsessive tendencies to Metal Academy). I think the clan and clan symbols we've created could be applied to lots of games, including Warhammer. Undead would be The North. Demons The Horde. Robots The Sphere. etc. Although you could argue that the Elves and the Undead should both belong to The North.
Actually, I've not told anyone this yet, but I based a lot of my design for this site on the Magic the Gathering card game. I started by trying to attach metal genres to the five colors of magic (below), but soon realised that it was impossible to snugly fit them into five clumps. I even dabbled with the idea of having clans and sub-clans, but that quickly became too complicated. You have no idea how long it took Daniel and I to agree on the clans the way they are. I'm pretty happy with them, particularly as no-one has questioned our decisions. The only thing that bothers me is that The Gateway, The Sphere and The Revolution are extremely difficult to attract new members for. There are a few obvious reasons for that, but I don't think the site would have worked if we just started throwing the likes of Metalcore, Industrial Metal and Alternative Metal into other clans. Hopefully we find some passionate fans of those styles of music.
I do believe it has to do with data that's copied from elsewhere. When I copy reviews from RYM, I paste them into word first and then paste them here by right clicking and selecting Paste as Plan Text. That seems to work every time for me.
But I'll see if there's any way that I can stop it from happening.
Easily one of my favorite albums, and the album that got me into Black Metal!
Bethlehem - Sardonischer Untergang Im Zeichen Irreligiöser Darbietung
That's a pretty out there album to be your first black metal album, particularly with the extreme vocals. I guess if you come in through that doorway, then a lot of more typical black metal would sound conventional.
The following bands have been added to Metal Academy on the 27th/28th of August, 2019:
1. Lucifer (GUARDIANS, FALLEN)
2. Death Penalty (GUARDIANS)
3. Coven (GUARDIANS) - requested by illusionist
4. Pharaoh (GUARDIANS)
5. Lyra's Legacy (GUARDIANS, INFINITE) - requested by Xephyr
6. Niviane (GUARDIANS) - requested by Xephyr
7. Gnaw Their Tongues (NORTH, FALLEN) - requested by Vlgrim
8. Imperial Triumphant (NORTH, INFINITE, HORDE) - requested by Vlgrim
9. Hannes Grossmann (HORDE, INFINITE)
10. Dark Lunacy (HORDE)
11. Repugnant (HORDE)
12. Entombed A.D. (HORDE) - requested by illusionist
13. Nocturnus AD (HORDE)
14. Dead to a Dying World (HORDE, FALLEN)
15. Dream Death (PIT, FALLEN)
16. With the Dead (FALLEN)
I also added the endless non-metal releases for Boris. That task took a few hours (to research, find quality artwork, and then add). Glad it's done!
Thanks for adding Aether Realm! Love those guys!
Quick note, however. I appreciate your use of the proper conjoined "AE" character, however it makes the band difficult to search for. Most people can't easily type that on a keyboad. If you search "Aether Realm" (as I suspect most would), there are no results.
Seems like this should be easy to fix somehow.
That's a good point. I've changed it to Aether Realm, and changed Ævangelist to Aevangelist while I was at it.
Cheers!
The following bands have been added to Metal Academy on the 25th/26th of August, 2019:
1. Iron Man (FALLEN)
2. Witchsorrow (FALLEN)
3. Nasheim (NORTH)
4. Infernal War (NORTH, HORDE)
5. Atlas Pain (NORTH, GUARDIANS) - requested by illusionist
6. Dødsengel (NORTH) - requested by Vlgrim
7. Månegarm (NORTH)
8. Kryptos (HORDE, GUARDIANS) - requested by Xephyr
9. Emptiness (HORDE, INFINITE) - requested by Vlgrim
10. Aether Realm (HORDE) - requested by illusionist
11. Pulchra Morte (HORDE)
12. Ossuarium (HORDE)
13. Oath, The (GUARDIANS)
14. Lords of Black (GUARDIANS) - requested by Xephyr
15. Timeless Miracle (GUARDIANS)
Another member that came to metal through Guitar Hero! I didn't realise it was responsible for bringing so many into the fold.
I'm thrilled that you accepted my invite and encourage you to continue contributing. I'm going to make a big push in the next few weeks to bring some more members in. The more this place feels like a growing community, the more likely they are to join in on the fun.
Cheers!
I'll throw in my welcome as well Xephyr. Daniel and I are thrilled that you're getting some value out of Metal Academy. Makes all the effort worth it!
I love reading these "origin stories" for metal fans. If anyone reading this hasn't done one yet, we'd love to hear from you.
Even though it's noticeably thrashier than Voivod's debut, I still think that "Rrroooaaarrr" sounds much more like Venom, Motorhead & Exciter than Metallica, Slayer or Exodus so it should be retagged as speed metal. Much like "War & Pain", it also offers more than the odd hint at hardcore punk & progressive metal but those elements are not strong enough to warrant a additional tag.
This release has been submitted to the Hall for judgement.
Kayo Dot's debut album "Choirs Of The Eye" is pure post-metal. It's really not all that avant-garde in my opinion. Especially given that the post-metal tag allows for a reasonable amount of experimentation anyway. So I'm proposing that we remove the avant-garde metal tag for reasons of accuracy.
This release has been added to the Hall for judgement.
Messiah's "Hymn To Abramelin" album combines thrash metal with elements of speed metal, black metal, traditional heavy metal & even some doom metal. But there's very little death metal on offer. I don't see that it has any right to be in The Horde so I'd like to see it removed & remain only in The Pit.
This release has been submitted to the Hall for judgement.
Focus is canonically considered a landmark album in death metal. While its current home in Infinite is also appropriate due to the extremely progressive and experimental nature of the music, I feel that Cynic are still enough of a death metal band at their core on this album (harsh vocals everywhere, riffs that would go on to inspire legions of techdeath imitators) to warrant placement in both. Almost feels a shame to not have Focus in the death metal lists.
This release has been added to the Hall of Judgement.
The following bands have been added to Metal Academy on the 22nd/23rd of August, 2019:
1. Serpentcult (FALLEN)
2. Moss (FALLEN)
3. Gates of Slumber, The (FALLEN, GUARDIANS)
4. Turilli / Lione Rhapsody (GUARDIANS)
5. Green Lung (FALLEN)
6. Void of Silence (FALLEN)
7. Ævangelist (HORDE, NORTH, INFINITE) - requested by Vlgrim
8. Disbelief (HORDE)
9. Equipoise (HORDE)
10. Peccatum (INFINITE)
11. Dark Tribe (NORTH)
12. Adaestuo (NORTH) - requested by Vlgrim
13. Darkened Nocturn Slaughtercult (NORTH)
14. Agathodaimon (NORTH)
15. Akrotheism (NORTH) - requested by Vlgrim
The following bands have been added to Metal Academy on the 20th/21st of August, 2019:
1. Winters (FALLEN)
2. Atavist (FALLEN)
3. Taint (FALLEN)
4. The Hidden Hand (FALLEN, GUARDIANS)
5. Asphodelus (FALLEN)
6. Divinefire (GUARDIANS) - requested by DippoMagoo
7. Galloglass (GUARDIANS)
8. Martriden (HORDE, INFINITE) - requested by Daniel
9. Drawn and Quartered (HORDE)
10. Devourment (HORDE)
11. Wolverine (INFINITE)
12. Nyseius (NORTH) - requested by Daniel
13. Gaahls Wyrd (NORTH)
14. Morbid Carnage (PIT) - requested by Daniel
I generally add 2 bands per user per day, so I should get through all of yours within a couple of weeks.
I kind of forgot about this suggestion, so thanks for the bump. Will look into how easy it is to implement.
Any chance you could fill out the Chevelle discography, particularly just by adding the Sci-Fi Crimes and Hats Off To The Bull albums? I don't think they're different enough from the others to warrant being the only ones excluded. Chevelle pretty much always have the same general rock/metal sound.
When I added Chevelle, I didn't have the option to add non-clan releases. Now I do, so I'll sort that out for you this week.
Next wave:
Cain's Offering
Cellador
Dark Empire
Dawn of Destiny
Derdian
Desert
Divinefire
All done!
Ben, please add Nyseius (France).
Done
Ben, please add Morbid Carnage (Hungary).
Done
Ben, please add Martriden (USA).
Done
Thank you, here's another round:
Frozen Crown
Katana
Kobra and the Lotus
Leaves' Eyes
Lyriel
Skull Fist
Smoulder
Tanith
Unleash The Archers
Xandria
These have all been added.
Thanks Ben, however I've got one more for you.
They're my favourite stoner band, they're completely underrated and they've got a killer new album out, so can you please add Witches of God...
Done!
Ben, please add Kruger (Switzerland).
Done.
The following bands have been added to Metal Academy on the 19th of August, 2019:
1. Shaman (GUARDIANS, INFINITE)
2. Derdian (GUARDIANS) - requested by DippoMagoo
3. Desert (GUARDIANS) - requested by DippoMagoo
4. Xandria (GUARDIANS, FALLEN) - requested by Xephyr
5. Unleash The Archers (GUARDIANS, HORDE) - requested by Xephyr
6. Capricorns (FALLEN, INFINITE)
7. Pod People (FALLEN)
8. Debris Inc. (FALLEN)
9. Kruger (FALLEN) - requested by Daniel
10. Krux (FALLEN)
11. Internal Rot (HORDE)
12. Helium Horse Fly (INFINITE)
13. Star One (INFINITE)
14. Vanum (NORTH)
The following bands have been added to Metal Academy on the 17th/18th of August, 2019:
1. Kerasphorus (HORDE) - requested by Daniel
2. Illdisposed (HORDE)
3. Ceremony of Silence (HORDE)
4. Kronos (HORDE) - requested by Daniel
5. Downfall of Gaia (NORTH, INFINITE, FALLEN)
6. Laster (NORTH, INFINITE)
7. Bottom (FALLEN)
8. Rebaelliun (HORDE)
9. Teeth of Lions Rule the Divine (FALLEN)
10. Unearthly Trance (FALLEN)
11. Dawn of Destiny (INFINITE, GUARDIANS) - requested by DippoMagoo
12. Beyond Twilight (INFINITE)
13. Skull Fist (GUARDIANS, PIT) - requested by Xephyr
14. Dark Empire (GUARDIANS, PIT) - requested by DippoMagoo
15. Tanith (GUARDIANS) - requested by Xephyr
16.Domine (FALLEN)
17. Hallows Eve (PIT)
The following bands have been added to Metal Academy on the 15th/16th of August, 2019:
1. Cain's Offering (GUARDIANS) - requested by DippoMagoo
2. Cellador (GUARDIANS) - requested by DippoMagoo
3. Kobra and the Lotus (GUARDIANS) - requested by Xephyr
4. Leaves' Eyes (GUARDIANS, FALLEN, NORTH) - requested by Xephyr
5. Falls of Rauros (NORTH)
6. Hypnosia (PIT, HORDE)
7. King Gizzard and the Lizard Wizard (PIT, FALLEN)
8. Jucifer (FALLEN, GATEWAY) - requested by Daniel
9. sHEAVY (FALLEN)
10. Naevus (FALLEN)
11. Sally (FALLEN)
12. Witches of God (FALLEN) - requested by Sonny92
13. Asterisk* (HORDE)
14. Garden of Shadows (HORDE)
15. The Callous Daoboys (REVOLUTION)
The following bands have been added to Metal Academy on the 13th/14th of August, 2019:
1. Vinnie Moore (GUARDIANS, INFINITE)
2. Katana (GUARDIANS) - requested by Xephyr
3. Frozen Crown (GUARDIANS) - requested by Xephyr
4. Gordian Knot (INFINITE)
5. Disciples of Mockery (HORDE, FALLEN)
6. Introrectalgestation (HORDE) - requested by Daniel
7. Fleshcrawl (HORDE)
8. Revelation (FALLEN)
9. Penance (FALLEN)
10. Mourn (FALLEN)
11. Mammoth Weed Wizard Bastard (FALLEN)
12. Maestus (FALLEN, NORTH)
13. Istapp (NORTH) - requested by Daniel
14. Kampfar (NORTH)
15. Evildead (PIT)