Rexorcist's Forum Replies

I didn't tag it metal when I put it on my chart.  Skip it.

As for this song, just plain heavy psych to me.

There seems to be an early "taditional heavy metal" backdrop in the production in some places, but it can be easily compared to the metallic backdrop of 80's metal into hair metal, so I'm not gonna call this metal.  But it sure kicks some fuckin' ass.

Maybe.  But there are very few "post" subgenres of metal that I really take seriously.  But as I've said before, if they're missing the sludge then I just won't call it atmo-sludge.  Biggest example is Rosetta.  Too atmo, not sludgy enough.  There needs to be more "truth" to the "post" tag for post-metal as well, which is where bands like Solstafir come in.

Feel like it's pertinent to put this here rather than anywhere else, just found out that my old college radio station has moved away from music for the most part and is just another NPR station that spouts pre-recorded talking shows and such. Dunno how I feel really, other than sad. As someone who enjoys music and sharing it, I'm just glad that I was able to take advantage of that opportunity when I could. It really shaped how I look at music, and especially Metal music, when I was able to share it with so many people that would legitimately call in and cared about what they were listening to on some random college station in their hometown. As things move forward I can only see it getting worse for these kinds of stations, so I can only be thankful what what I was able to do in my 3 years there. 

The pain of cancellation of something you love.  It's kinda like a part of your soul was disrespected. 

There's definitely early doom influence here, but as a full on song, it's mostly typical 70's hard rock.

I'm not Fallen, but I really do see a clear distinction between atmo-sludge and post-metal, and refuse to call one the subgenre of the other.  There's a little overlap, and that's it as far as I'm concerned.  Post-metal shouldn't just be long atmospheric metal.  Take bands like GYBE, Sans and Tortoise in post-rock.  There's more to it on a structural spectrum, and most atmo-sludge doesn't meet that standard.  They're just slow and atmospheric, big woop, like atmo-black.

So my final point is: I wouldn't mind if atmo-sludge returned as a separate entity, but I have little to do with the Fallen save voting on alls that the Fallen happen to be on, so whatevs.

Bluesy and proggy, but not heavy enough for a metal tag.

Forgot about the album this week.  It'll continue next Tuesday.

I think the horn is distracting people on this one. Hard rock.

I listen to power metal.  Horn doesn't bother me.

Ride the Sky was also a single, and since singles are usually released before the album, but Zeppelin also performed the song for the first time t the 1970 Bath Festival of Blues and Progressive Music in June.

Major Rainbow vibes here.  Heavy metal.

I found about a third of it to be "traditional heavy metal" and that's about it.

Fixed.

Hard rock in every sense of the term.

Kinda psych but mostly blues rock.

Turns out the edition I heard when I made my first comment had sides A and B reversed, so my comment on the first track was from muscle memory on the wrong tracklist.  So I switch my commentary on the first track to this rym standard:

Hard Rock, Blues Rock

Heavy Metal

I feel like it's more inspiration than anything.  The Planets is too popular of a classical piece to credit as your own.

Yeah, I'm going stoner metal and traditional heavy metal on this one.

It’s the added complexity in the arrangements & song-structures as well as the cold, angry atmosphere. It also helps that it’s a thrash riff masterclass with all four band members at the absolute peak of their powers from a performance & musicianship perspective.

Gonna have to give it a replay today.

After I'm done with Draconian, I guess I'll put together private doom and goth lists and see where they're going.  Unfortunately, I'm still in a position to where I'm safe with the way I want my log if I listen to one metal album a day, assuming I listen to enough albums in that day to make up for it.  Today I finished the Poppy catalog and heard the new Duran Duran as well as their debut.  But I'm definitely not into them as much as I'd like to be considering their status in the new wave scene.

My day's likely going to be spent with DJ Shadow.  He's got a new one out and I've only heard his debut and a singles compilation.

I think I'm gonna go hard rock heavy metal on this one because it's got a lot of energy that makes me want to bang my head despite its obvious blues rock elements.

Lotsa thrash there.  Hard to avoid it in that decade.  Out of curiosity, what sets And Justice for All above Master of Poppets and Ride the Lightning IYO?

I don't care what folk we put it under as long as it's not metal.

I seem to remember that as well, but I think that was a good move for them because the two sides compliment each other well.

Another good example is how The Moody Blues were another pop rock band in 1965 before Days of Future Passed.

I was more impressed with than album than most people.  Even though they're better at hard rock, Deep Purple proved that they can really bring out the fantasy vibes through rock long before symphonic prog or any fantasy genres of rock and metal ever existed.  It was a very "vibes" album from what I remember.  And yeah, the prog wasn't always the MOST creative as it had been done more well before, but I kinda believe that the first two real prog bands were Moody Blues and Deep Purple, and this was one of those albums that helped cement it before King Crimson came into the picture (and coined the term).

If they did plagiarize it, they did that song a favor.  The production doesn't do anything good about that Ritual song any justice...

I don't remember Woman from Tokyo very well, but I'm more or less going with Daniel's description on this one.

Today's HORDE album:

Behemoth - Demigod (2004)

Genre: Death

Votes: 1

Reason: Behemoth is an understated essential in modern death.

Review:

I'm nowhere near into solo Ozzy as I am into Black Sabbath, and I know I'm not alone in this.  Because of this, I've spent very little time in Ozzy's solo career.  Up until today, I had only heard his first two albums.  I really think it's about time I stopped putting both solo Ozzy and solo Dio off and gotten to a couple of their albums.  But I'll keep this brief.

I was glad that each song felt a little different at times.  Some were pretty speedy like the title track and (ironically) "Slow Down," some were more about the beat and biker attitude like "Waiting for Darkness," and songs like "So Tired" added a more symphonic and melodic side, steering itself away from typical power ballads by keeping the gothic vibes of the album intact.  There's also some time for raw creepiness a la Alice Cooper, like on the song "Spiders."  But I think what really made the album so enjoyable is that all the melodies are very strong.  It seems to be a major focus on the album where everything else, including the variety factor, seems to work around the melodies.  And this leads up to the album's only flaw: stylistically and structurally, it's a pretty typical 80's heavy metal album.  None of the songs are bad, but thanks to this, it comes nowhere near Paranoid as a whole.  In fact, its typical structure is also why I'm keeping this brief, because there really isn't a lot stylistically that's unique enough to talk about.

Well, I'm largely impressed with this album.  From what I can remember, this seems more focused on doing different things with typical heavy metal songs than Blizzard of Ozz.  This is a great continuation of a solo career built on two great albums, and I highly recommend it for any metal fan that wants darkness in their music, even for extreme metalheads.

91/100

Budgie debut maybe?

Forgot to post the hint for today's Horde album.  I'll do that, and then I'll post the review for Bark at the Moon.

Less heavy than before.  Hard rock.

Especially since my mouse is acting up a little.

Looks like your list is restored with a different name: https://metal.academy/lists/single/261

Whew! An epic list like this shall not be lost.

I had to remake it due to the late reply.  Can we implement a notification that says, "Are you sure you want to delete it?"  It serves as a good warning before the accident actually happens.

I think this track is at least hard rock heavy metal for its edge, but most of the songs on the album really aren't QUITE as heavy so it might require a second listen.

Damn, I don't even remember the first five.  They were probably Scorpions albums as they were the first metal band I really got into.  One of them might've been, as is my opinion, Appetite for Destruction, and another might've been Dirt.  At first I was into heavy metal, and thrash took some time, but after checking out Helloween and Blind Guardian, I wanted more power metal pretty quickly.  Basically, my journey into metal started with hard rock, and I forced myself into more extreme genres overtime.  Black was the last one if I recall correctly.  I remember the first three death metal albums I've ever heard: Symbolic, Unquestionable Presence and Focus.  I don't even remember how grind started, but my first two black metal albums were At the Heart of Winter and Bergtatt.

Maybe, but there are some albums that would attract multiple people.  Not saying Paranoid is necessarily one of them, but in the end the decisions won't cause a massive riot one way or another.  I mysel largely don't care which clan we put it under.

Besides, it's obvious that the people who attribute "prog" to different genre tags have different meanings

They shouldn't though in my opinion.

I agree.  Unfortunately, they do.  So I reserve those tags.

But Empire feels to radio-friendly for me, that's the thing.  And I repeat: it doesn't need to be overly technical, but I'd appreciate a little more in Empire.  There's some, but most of the album gave me radio-rock vibes.

Besides, it's obvious that the people who attribute "prog" to different genre tags have different meanings, and I don't tag a prog electronic album that way unless it feels less radio friendly and conventional.  New and proggy are also two different things.

Considering that they were working their way up to that, I wouldn't be against the tag.  I'll give it a spin today, as I've been meaning to.

I don't need them to be SUPER technical, but a little more than that.

Heh, I just realized, your hard rock vs. heavy metal opinions are like my prog opinions, and vise-versa. :P

In the case of our closer, it really pushes that line between hard rock and heavy metal, but I think I'd go 60% hard rock, 40% heavy metal.  There's definitely some heavy psych in parts, but I'm not really convinced it's a primary.  But when I think about it, stoner metal seems a little like a direct subgenre of heavy metal when you count bands like Spiritual Beggars.

This is another case of too many subgenres of metal to really judge.  We have three kinds of metal on your tags, even though I would add heavy metal to Iron Man.  In other words, the most accurate way to do it would simply be to call it a "metal" album again, which we can't really do on Metal Academy, so it's another screwy situation.

Btw, you said "Electric Wizard," not "Electric Funeral."

It's hardly prog, either.  Honestly, Queensryche genre tags seem to be the result of fanboys who love lumping things in with cooler tags for credibility.

I was a pretty big fan of Draconian's 2020 album, but never made the jump back to their earlier stuff. Seems like I might have to remedy that as it looks like they're incredibly consistent straight from the start. I only have a few go-to Gothic Metal bands so it'd probably be worth branching out a bit. 

I remember a little of a buzz around that album when it came out, but I never got around to a lot of goth metal back then.

Draconian - Arcane Rain Fell (2005)

Genres: Gothic Doom Metal

The gothic doom sound pioneered by My Dying Bride and Type O Negative would be replicated by a large portion of the gothic scene, including Draconian, who mastered the basics of the genre on the debut without much creativity attached.  Doom and gothic fans seem to love their second album, Arcane Rain Fell, so I guess this was the most exciting part of exploring their catalogue.  When I turned this on, I was hoping for a serious improvement over the original and a stone-cold classic.

It's obvious that the band is becoming more poetic with their lyricism.  There seems to be a stronger focus on the imagery of the scene they're a part of.  And thanks to a stronger idea of using faint foregrounds as atmospheric tools, such as the choral backing vocals on The Apostacy Castle, the album has a stronger effect on the listener than before.  Because of this, the emotional core of the band is a little stronger here.  The elements that made the debut album good to begin with have a stronger harmony and balance.  This also means that certain aspects are going to shine at certain times even more than they did on the last album.  It was easy for certain focal points to shine when there was less harmony, but with a stronger sense of harmony from everything and stronger skill from the band, the focal points (when given extra strength), such as the bombastic gothica of Heaven Laid in Tears or the intro's slow sludge, feel more impressive.  In other words, the band is able to recreate the last album and all of its strengths with one difference: they've become a BAND.

Having said this, there are two problems I have with this album.  First, in following completely in the vein of the last album, it also recreates the sameyness problem.  While all of the songs are enjoyable, we know what we're getting.  And the second problem is that the lady singer is severely underused.  The male is given total priority, and it's kind of a shame.  I mean, as absolutely beautiful as our ending 15-minute track is, it's same old Draconian.  So the end all be all is that this is a slight improvement over a pretty good debut, and Draconian know who they want to be which from a moral perspective is perfectly fine, but from a musician's perspective it hurts their creative prowess.

76/100

Planet Hemp - A invasão do sagaz homem fumaça (2000)

Genres: Rap Rock, Conscious Hip Hop

Looking through my log, I noticed: I don't have very many rap rock albums up there.  I've never had a rap rock binge, likely because few people seem to take it very seriously.  Well, since I'm back on a hip hop binge, and since the RYM charts have recorded over 1200 rap rock albums, mixtapes and EP's, I decided now was a good time as any to check out the genre.  However, I am NOT into RATM, so I didn't head to them.  I wanted to try somebody totally new to me.  Looking through each album's genre tags to see what I might like, I came to this Brazilian band which apparently included punk, dub and samba into their mix.  That sounded like a WILD ride, so

I have to say, for a consistently attitudinal album loaded with catchy and maybe poppy beats, this was one of the most varied albums I've ever heard. Each song has its own strong identity with different levels of attitude, different kinds of beats and genres, and some variations in rapping styles between the two MC's.  There was practically no way to tell what was going to happen next.  I mean, beat-wise, it took creative genius to keep it this catchy and experimental at the same time.  They made room for a couple of punk songs (one of which is constantly changing in its two minute runtime without ever losing its aura), and they even start off one song with a very psychedelic samba chorus before switching into hip hop with those same instruments playing.  They found a way to surprise me with a hip hop verse IN a hip hop album.  Damn.

Even on our third-to-last track, Quarta De Cinzas shos the band's fascinating ability to balance out hip hop vibes with the folksier instruments of their native home.  The beats and melodies are constantly operating at full power, and so every song is catchy in its own way.  But if I had to pick one song to take with me, it would be that beautiful song I just mentioned.  And the best part?  They follow it up with a hardcore punk song, and then with a reggae hip hop track as a closer, and it feels so right because they already used stronger hip hop influences in the earlier tracks to set up the atmosphere for the controlled chaos that makes the album so enigmatic.  In other words, this is almost an experimental album in the sense that the band has incredible passion for the whole world of music and not just for hip hop, and that's the kind of passion I find rare in modern hip hop.  Only a few highly diverse artists like Tyler the Creator and Death Grips have that special brand of musical passion.

No skips, no bad songs, all surprises and hip hop attitude.  This 2000 album is practically a tribute to all those 90's genres that the radio burnt out, but also justifying what was so beloved about each one.  I honestly can't believe what I've heard.  This is the kind of rap rock album I would've done, although I might've chosen different genres.  Plant Hemp needs to make more albums, they really do.  This album alone proves that they had a creative capacity on par with the future artist Tyler the Creator.  I'm thinking this is a top ten hip hop album for me.  In fact, I'm seriously considering putting this in my top 100.

100/100