"The Roots of Metal" Project

November 28, 2023 06:31 PM

How about " Got a Bone of My Own"? I've got it down as progressive rock/heavy psych.



Also, I revisited Deep Purple's 1972 "Machine Head" album yesterday & generally found it to be a hard/blues rock record although there are two clear heavy metal tracks included in "Highway Star" & "Pictures of Home". Anyone feel otherwise & want it included here?

November 29, 2023 02:21 AM

Heavy psych gets my vote.

Pretty sure most, if not all Deep Purple albums after this point are just hard rock. I know Rex said differently about Perfect Strangers, but that's no longer The Roots of Metal.

November 29, 2023 07:30 PM

Pretty sure most, if not all Deep Purple albums after this point are just hard rock. I know Rex said differently about Perfect Strangers, but that's no longer The Roots of Metal.

Quoted Morpheus Kitami

To be fair, I'd suggest that there's actually just as much metal on "Machine Head" than there is on "In Rock".


Today's track is " Slush Pan Man" which I regard as being stoner rock.



Also, I gave Thin Lizzy's 1972 sophomore album "Shades of a Blue Orphanage" a couple of listens yesterday. There's no metal there. It's a hard rock record in my opinion.

November 30, 2023 08:15 PM

Today's track is "Living With The Dying" which I regard as being genuine heavy metal.



December 01, 2023 01:14 AM

I'd say both get my vote for heavy metal.

December 01, 2023 07:03 PM

How about "Come Down"? I've tagged it as progressive rock.



December 02, 2023 06:48 PM

Today's track is "Blind" which I've got down as being hard/blues rock.



December 03, 2023 07:13 PM

Today's track is "Nightmare" which I've tagged as hard rock.



December 04, 2023 07:22 PM

The last track from "Mournin'" is "Don't Start Flying" which I've tagged as progressive rock.



This leaves me with a clear result given that I've only tagged a single track from the album as metal, Anyone come up with a different result?

December 05, 2023 03:30 PM

Come Down, prog rock.

Blind, very Led Zeppelin-ish, not metal.

Nightmare, uh, same as Blind, maybe a little bit of metal.

Don't Start Flying, rock of some kind.

I guess I got 1.8 or so tracks as metal. Not really metal.

December 05, 2023 07:04 PM

I completely agree Morpheus. I had just the one track tagged as metal.


Today we'll move onto a record that is tagged as metal on both Metal Archive & RYM in the 1972 self-titled debut album from Philadelphia's Bang, starting with opening track "Lions, Christians" which I regard as sitting somewhere between hard rock & heavy metal.



December 05, 2023 07:56 PM

A little late to the Night Sun - Mournin discussion, but my thoughts are it's not metal. However I did get an avant-garde vibe that I didn't see get thrown around as much as prog which I agree is on most of the songs as well. Heavy psych elements but not as much metal. Definitely influential. 

December 05, 2023 08:54 PM
Just had my first listen to Bang, that is fun as hell. My opinion is overall it is heavy metal. Maybe not as doomy as early Sabbath, but those hard rock riffs get a bit heavy especially for a 72 record. However, songs like Last Will and Testament lean more Led Zeppelin. Lions, Christians is very much a heavy metal song, so is The Queen, Our Home, and Future Shock. The others I could be swayed either way but lean towards hard rock especially Questions.
December 06, 2023 12:51 AM

I was very much in two minds between hard rock & heavy metal on “Lions, Christians” to be honest but in the end I decided that a both way bet was the best outcome.

December 06, 2023 01:33 AM

A straight mix in my opinion of both.

December 06, 2023 07:10 PM

Today's track is "The Queen" which I regard as being hard rock.



December 07, 2023 04:24 AM

I hear nothing that would put it as anything but hard rock.

December 07, 2023 05:42 PM

Today's track is "Last Will & Testament" which I've tagged as psychedelic rock.



December 08, 2023 12:33 AM

Curiously Pink Floyd-ish, not metal.

December 08, 2023 07:15 PM

Today's track is "Come With Me" which I tagged as being hard rock.



December 09, 2023 07:49 PM

This morning's track is "Our Home" which I consider to be hard rock:



December 09, 2023 09:03 PM
After listening again, It does feel more prog rock than prog metal, the guitars just don't go as heavy in "Our Home"
December 10, 2023 04:48 PM

Come with Me, hard rock I'd say.

Our Home, feels like something off a band like Kansas, not quite sure where, but prog rock.

December 10, 2023 07:12 PM

I've got traditional doom metal for this one: