UnhinderedbyTalent's Forum Replies

I have not been listening to many of the recent Horde playlists to be honest but have taken some time out whilst on holiday for the festive season to listen to this month's and can see how the more established and historic tracks work better.  I often find it easy to represent more old-school stuf on The Pit playlist since Daniel and Sonny usually pick from the 80's heyday with consistency which frees me up to venture for the more modern releases.  I have never had a strict rule around a specific proposrtion of the list being modern or from the current year.  Prefer the "organic" approach.

One thing that struck me when I played through this moth's Horde list was how little patient I have whatsoever for melodic death metal nowadays.  I have this mindset with death metal that it should never be diluted, otherwise it is not really death metal anymore.  Odd, as I don't mind melodic black metal.  Tracks three and four on the list soon got skipped and I was grateful of the down and dirty Darkthrone demo.  I think the last melodic death metal that I listened to regularly was Heartwork by Carcass.

Nasum are a band I should be flogged for neglecting like I do.  I keep telling myself that I need to spend more time with their stuff but somehow never quite get around to it.  I actually sat through that Imperial Triumphant track which is progress for me - I still don't get the hype around them though.  I will get around to a full Neuropath album review eventually but this track underlines the Suffocation influence brilliantly for me.  The diving guitars and stop/start rhythms are great.

Wasn't too keen on some of the more melodic death/doom tracks this month - I am familiar with Hamferð and Mother of GRaves but neither really floated my boat.  Still lots to enjoy though with Cough, Sir Lord Baltimore, Remembrance and Melvins being highlights.

Dymna Lotva were an interesting prospect, post-black metal and doom (with some folk) sounds as a mixture worked for me.  Playing the album through now as I type this.

I enjoyed another solid list this month.  HIghlights being Fork of Horripilation, Malokarpatan, Auriferous Flame and Faidra.  Benn meaning to spend some time with that Faidra album in recent weeks so will prioritise this coming week as work dies down.

Not convinced by Finsterfrost, Vertebra Atlantis or Sielunvihollinen though.  Still, plenty to go at though from this month's list.

Ben?  The Spotify playlist on the app itself is still showing as last month's selections?

I recalled that I had taken some time to review this one already:

It has taken me the best part of a decade to get around to undertaking an erstwhile and meaningful effort to review the release that is recognised by some as being “the worst album in the history of death metal”. With so much negativity flying around it is difficult to write a genuinely impartial review based on how an album sounds to you personally. A task made no easier by the fact that the band in question are one of your favourite bands in death metal, responsible for some of the greatest albums the sub-genre has seen, and they have undertaken a huge change of direction and seemingly alienated the vast majority of their fanbase.

Looking on the internet there are two camps of opinion (broadly speaking) on Illud Divinum Insanus. ‘The “this is Ear Rape” Camp’, have a clear standpoint from the outset of their argument. In this camp you are most likely to hear that this album is all the fault of either a) David Vincent and his “fucked up ideas” or b) Trey Azagathoth for letting David Vincent do “whatever the fuck he likes”. The more rational ones in this camp still exhibit an astonishing lack of rational thought by citing Pete Sandoval having back surgery and finding Jesus as being the source of the problem. In the face of such astonishing, evidence-based, and well-researched findings it is hard to see how any opposing camp could possibly exist.

Amazingly, the second camp of opinion, ‘The “this isn’t so bad guys” Camp’ has managed to flourish in the face of such vehement opposition from the aforementioned “Ear Rape” camp dwellers. This second group of more open-minded music fans acknowledge some very important distinctions in their argument when compared with their more reactionary counterparts. Namely, they admit that a) it is in David Vincent’s gift to do whatever the fuck he likes and that b) Trey Azagathoth was quite good at video games by this point and wanted someone else to run point on the album because he had done more than a few years of good shit and had earned some time with his feet up. They tend to also acknowledge that Pete Sandoval had a debilitating injury that required surgery and his belief change was a more than reasonable step in his recovery and he was rightly (and publicly) proud of what he had achieved with Morbid Angel so let’s leave him out of this!

If I had to choose sides, then go right ahead and sign me for the latter of the two camps. I might not agree with everything either camp say but there is far more wrong with the “Ear Rape” sentiment to justify any involvement there. I mean looking at old reviews I did for the follow up to this record, I slate it based on cursory listens and peer pressure so I have had a foot in the former camp at some point.

So, I do not like Illud Divinum Insanus. I do not hate it either and I think the general backlash against it is both unnecessary and misguided, showing the rather grandiose idea that bands somehow owe something to their fans to stay on the same trajectory their whole career. The fact is though that this is not a Morbid Angel album (well apart from the two main players being kind of well-established with the band name – oh and the band logo on the front of the record), in fact it is not really a death metal album when taken in its entirety. Clearly carrying a variety of musical influences in their heads at the time there are lots of non-metal as well as various other sub-genres of metal being explored here and whether you like it or not is up to you. Whether you like the industrial-tinged elements is a matter of taste (I personally do not like a lot of industrial metal but find the elements here quite measured and appropriate). If you find the “bangers” type dance beats abhorrent, then any hope you have of any return to form in the future being of a Blessed… or better still an Altars… level of accomplishment is slim to zero.

The point is that bands move on, and musicians influences change. Records that defined part of your life will always remain relevant and your favourite band now going off in some previously unheralded direction is not the end of the world. Illud… is a bitter pill to swallow after nearly a decade of waiting for a follow up to Heretic, with little to no warning of what was coming from these titans of death metal. References to Domination keep popping up in the more amenable camp but I do not see those as really all that relevant and perhaps are just over-exuberant attempts to provide some sense to Illud… and make it more palatable.

Fact is, both Trey and David can do whatever they like. Do you have to like it? No. Tim Yeung and Destructhor are no more to blame if you dislike this album than Pete Sandoval is – the album just isn’t for you.

It seems very simple to me. If you like death metal and death metal done like it was in the 90s, then you will not like this record. Stop listening to it and saying nasty things about it on the internet some eleven years after it was released and just get the fuck on with your lives. If you want to hear something different that to my ears is not all that appealing overall, then take a risk and form your own opinion.

2.5/5

January please:

Obscure Sphinx - "Nothing Left" (from "Epitaphs", 2016)

Hexvessel - "Ring" (from "Polar Veil", 2023)


January please:

Baest - "Crosswhore" (from "Danse Macabre", 2018)

Monument of Misanthropy - "Exceptionally Sadistic" (from "Unterweger", 2021)

Analepsy - "Food for the Maggots" (from "Dehumanization by Supremacy", 2015)

Skinless - "Deviation Will Not Be Tolerated" (from "Trample the Weak, Hurdle the Dead", 2006)

Vastum - "Vomitous" (from "Inward to Gethsemane", 2023)

10 to the Chest - "Glassed in the Face" (from "Split the Fuck Open", 2023)

Bloodbath - "Mock the Cross" (from "The Fathomless Mastery", 2008)


January please:

Nordjevel - "Blood Horns" (from "Nordjevel", 2016)

Immortal - "Immortal" (from "War Against All", 2023)

Olde Throne - "A Dying Land" (from "An Gorta Mór", 2022)


December 2023

1. Mystic Storm – “Riddle of Steel” (from “From the Ancient Chaos”, 2021) [Submitted by Vinny]

2. Iced Earth – “The Funeral” (from “Iced Earth”, 1990) [Submitted by Daniel]

3. Anacrusis – “Far Too Long” (from “Manic Impressions”, 1991)

4. Hellish – “The Ancient Entity of the Darkest Light” (from “The Dance of the Four Elemental Serpents”, 2022) [Submitted by Daniel]

5. Imperial – “Censure” (from “Thrasheurs 13”, 1998) [ Submitted by Vinny]

6. Slaughtbbath – “Tyranny from Sodom” (from “Contempt, War and Damnation”, 2017) [Submitted by Sonny]

7. Trastorned – “Witch Hunt” (from “Into the Void”, 2023) [Submitted by Sonny]

8. Possessed – “Demon” (from “Revelations of Oblivion”, 2019)

9. Coroner – “Mistress of Deception” (from “No More Colour”, 1989) [Submitted by Morpheus Kitami]

10. Flotsam & Jetsam – “Doomsday for the Deceiver” (from “Doomsday for the Deceiver”, 1986) [Submitted by Sonny]

11. Mystik – “Nightmares” (from “Mystik”, 2019)

12. Motörhead – “Locomotive” (from “No Remorse”, 1984) [Submitted by Daniel]

13. Nihilist – “Sentenced to Death” (from “Carnal Leftovers”, 2005) [Submitted by Daniel]

14. Megadeth – “Good Mourning/Black Friday” (from “Peace Sells…But Who’s Buying?”, 1986) [Submitted by Sonny]

15. Primal Rite – “Antivenom” (from “Dirge of Escapism”, 2018)

16. Forseen – “Soldier’s Grave” (from “Untamed Force”, 2022)

17. Take Offense – “Power in Our Hands” (from “Tables Will Turn”, 2011)

18. Scatterbrain – “Here Comes Trouble” (from “Here Comes Trouble”, 1990)

19. DOOM – “Ghosts of Princes” (from “Killing Field…+4”, 1988) [Submitted by Morpheus Kitami]

20. OverDose – “Straight to the Point” (from “Progress of Decadence”, 1993)

21. Upon A Burning Body – “All Pride, No Pain” (from “Southern Hostility”, 2019)

22. Virus – “Murder in the Moshpit” (from “A New Strain of An Old Disease”, 2013) [Submitted by Vinny]

23. Nervosa/Gary Holt– “When the Truth Is a Lie” (from “Jailbreak”, 2023) [Submitted by Vinny]

24. Exodus – “The Last Act of Defiance” (from “Fabulous Disaster”, 1989) [Submitted by Daniel]

25. Slaughter Lord – “Slaughter Lord” (from “Thrash ‘til Death 86-87”, 1998) [Submitted by Sonny]

26. Vektor – “Forests of Legend” (from “Black Future”, 2009)




Hi Ben, could you please add Romanian speed metallers, Knife Brigade?

Quoted UnhinderedbyTalent

I assume you mean Leather Brigade? Can't find a Knife Brigade, although that is a better band name.

Quoted Ben

Yeah, one too many sherberts when I typed that.  You are correct with Leather Brigade.

Asking three times does not alter the fact that you have missed the cut off for this month.  If you are still around for next month and you have actually locked in 3 clans instead of just 1 then I will consider it.


please add the 90s Australian thrash metal band allegiance 

Quoted Jackko


They are already on.  Just go to the Bands section and use the search function to save yourself some typing mate.


Hi Ben, could you please add Romanian speed metallers, Knife Brigade?


Let's stick with what unites us and not what divides us, so saying I agree Vinny, the Mānbryne track was a standout and their album is near the top of my list of things to check out soon.  As you've already listened to it, is it any good?

Quoted Sonny

I thought it was solid enough but not outstanding.  My fears of them being Mgla clones were not realised thankfully but I see little here to be attracting the top end of the rating spectrum, however I have only listened through a couple of times.

When I first heard that ambient track on Filosofem I was as repulsed as Sonny given at the time I had no enjoyment of ambient music at all.  As I have found myself a lot more interested in dark ambient in recent years I actually do not mind it all, I think I listen to more of Burzum's ambient and dungeon synth stuff nowadays than I do his conventional bm.  Horses for courses.

I am playing the album by Mānbryne following their inclusion on the playlist.  I plan to check out Sühnopfer and Branikald also based on this list.

Faetooth - Remnants of the Vessel (2022)


Female "fairydoom" project out of Los Angeles.  I would suggest it to be a blend of doom and sludge if (like me) you find "fairydoom" to be an unhelpful term.

Mānbryne - Interregnum: O pr​ó​bie wiary i jarzmie zw​ą​tpienia (2023)


Picked up from The North clan playlist this month, some Polish bm for this wet Thursday afternoon.

Ken mode - "VOID" (2023)

Since writing the below review back in October this year I have added VOID to my vinyl shelves and today marks its first spin.

Sitting completely off my radar for most of their discography to date, KEN mode came up in a random playlist this week and I found myself intrigued by their clear blend of core infused sludge that seems to have a constant threat of exploding into some mathy chaos. Grateful that this possibility is never realised VOID plays to the more appealing elements of how I like my sludge; reminiscent of Kowloon Walled City who I also stumbled across randomly.

This thoughtful and mature edge to VOID bleeds through on tracks such as These Wires which is an exhausting and emotionally charged near eight minutes of turbulent percussion and boisterous vocals tempered by the gradual build of the instrumental track (a la Russian Circles), We’re Small Enough that immediately follows it. Unafraid to bring the noise though, the crazed jazzy ending to I Cannot shows the versatility of KEN mode perfectly. Whatever track you listen to on the album you cannot deny how emotionally supercharged the whole thing is and the elements of control that are deployed on that energy make for a very interesting listen overall.

Whilst there is a sense of fight to the record, there is a frustrating futility to that conflict, an underlying tone of defeat being known but the level of tenacity in the energy of the tracks refuses to admit defeat. Monotone bass lines and an often-deployed plodding rhythm compliment the dark edge to the lyrics well without ever making for dull or lifeless compositions either. There is a level of intrigue that I maintain in listening to this record that I do not often find with most releases nowadays. VOID certainly has something to say but it is not limiting itself to shouting in my face, nor is it hiding behind conjecture either.

Not all elements work for me. The spoken word on Not Today, Old Friend certainly play to the aesthetic of the song but just feel out of place still somehow. The more noise rock portions of KEN mode are the more challenging for me overall even though they do tangle the most intricate of webs that I do still have to acknowledge the talent behind the creation thereof.

4.5/5


For the next playlist that's available, I'd like to suggest:

Coroner - Mistress of Deception (off No More Color)

Doom - Ghost of Princes (off Killing Field+4)

Quoted Morpheus Kitami

They will be on December's, thanks.


Hey Vinny, my suggestions for December are:

Flotsam and Jetsam - "Doomsday for the Deceiver" (from "Doomsday for the Deceiver", 1986)

Megadeth - "Good Mourning/Black Friday" (from "Peace Sells... But Who's Buying?", 1986)

Slaughtbbath - "Tyranny From Sodom" (from "Contempt, War and Damnation", 2017)

Slaughter Lord - "Slaughter Lord" (from "Thrash 'Til Death", 1998)

Trastorned - "Witch Hunt" (from "Into the Void", 2023)

Quoted Sonny

Thanks Sonny, perfect pick with that lengthy F&J track meaning that the playlist is now complete well ahead of schedule.  I can put me feet up for rest of month now.

I have no idea what “atmospheric sludge” is so hadn’t even noticed the change.  I lack the laser focus on the clans that others have.  Short answer, it’s fine as is.


My first four days at my new job have gone really well. The first 2.5 days were basically spent completing online training & inductions but the last 1.5 days were really interesting & encouraging. I'm really enjoying learning about managing a business in an entirely new industry (i.e. the construction machinery one) while the wider team seems to be embracing me & are really happy to have someone with my skill sets & experience coming into their business which has given me a much-needed ego-boost after recent events had dented my confidence a touch. The commute has been punishing though. It's been more like 95 minutes to get there in the morning & around 110-120 minutes to get home in the evening. Plenty of metal listening has been conducted during that time which is a bit of a concern for the state of my withered ear drums.

Quoted Daniel

Glad it is working out.  Although if they insist on embracing you then you can always go to HR of course :+1:


How can I submit my band to be added to the site?

Quoted Diabology

There's a thread for requests in each of the clan forums (suspect you want the one in The Pit) drop the request in this thread and Ben will pick up.

https://metal.academy/forum/13/thread/65

For December please:

Candlemass - "Dark Are the Veils of Death" (from "Nightfall", 1987)

KEN mode - "A Reluctance of Being" (from "VOID", 2023)


For December please:

Glemsel - "Ansigterne" (from "Forfader", 2022)

Hexis - "Exhaurire" (from "Aeternum", 2022)


For December please:

Tenebro - "Carne Umana" (from "Carne Umana", 2022)

Wharflurch - "Phantasmagorical Fumes" (from "Psychedelic Realms Ov Hell", 2021)

Universally Estranged - "Corrupted Mind Palace" (from "Dimension of Deviant Clusters", 2022)

Dismember - "Override of the Overture" (from "Like an Ever Flowing Stream", 1991)

Yatra - "Terminate by the Sword" (from "Born Into Chaos", 2022)

Devenial Verdict - "Ash Blind" (from "Ash Blind", 2022)


November 2023

1. Sadistic Ritual – “Area Denial” (from “The Enigma, Boundless”, 2022) [Submitted by Vinny]

2. Horrendous – “Ontological Mysterium” (from “Ontological Mysterium”, 2023)

3. Pentagram Chile – “La Furia” (from “The Malefice”, 2013 [Submitted by Sonny]

4. Daeva – “The Architect and the Monument” (from “Through Sheer Will & Black Magic”, 2022) [Submitted by Vinny]

5. Aura Noir – “Black Thrash Attack” (from “Black Thrash Attack”, 1996) [Submitted by Sonny]

6. Hellbringer – “Fall of the Cross” (from “Awakened from the Abyss”, 2016)

7. Sacred Reich – “One Nation” (from “Surf Nicaragua”, 1988) [Submitted by Daniel]

8. Combust – “The Big Game” (from “Another Life”, 2022)

9. Enforced – “The Quickening” (from “War Remains”, 2023) [Submitted by Sonny]

10. Forbidden – “As Good as Dead” (from “Forbidden Evil”, 1988) [Submitted by Daniel]

11. Num Skull – “Death and Innocence” (from “Ritually Abused”, 1988) [Submitted by Daniel]

12. Attomica – “Deathraiser” (from “Disturbing the Noise”, 1991)

13. Mutilator – “Tormented Soul” (from “Immortal Force”, 1987) [Submitted by Sonny]

14. Pestilence – “Systematic Instruction” (from “Malleus Maleficarum”, 1988) [Submitted by Daniel]

15. Bewitched – “Born of Flames” (from “Diabolical Desecration”, 1996) [Submitted by Sonny]

16. Vendetta – “Never Die” (from “Brain Damage”, 1988) [Submitted by Daniel]

17. Exumer – “Rising from the Sea” (from “Rising from the Sea”, 1987) [Submitted by Sonny]

18. At War – “Mortally Wounded” (from “Ordered to Kill”, 1986)

19. Solstice – “Who Bleeds Whom” (from “Casting the Die”, 2021)

20. Lamb of God – “Vanishing” (from “Omens”, 2022)

21. Blood From the Soul – “Dismantle the Titan” (from “DSM-5”, 2020)

22. Detritus – “Bright Black” (from “Myths”, 2021)

23. Terminalist – “A Future to Weave” (from “The Crisis as Condition”, 2023) [Submitted by Vinny]

24. Miscreance – “Fall Apart” (from “Convergence”, 2022)

25. Chemicide – “Inequality” (from “Inequality”, 2019)

26. Sadistic Force – “Cavern of the Wraith” (from “Aces Wild”, 2019)

27. The Lousy – “Demons on Parade” (from “Shut Up I’m Talking”, 2022)

28. Testament – “The Ballad” (from “Practice What You Preach”, 1989) [Submitted by Daniel]

29. Flotsam & Jetsam – “Hard on You” (from “No Place for Disgrace”, 1988) [Submitted by Daniel]

30. Warbringer – “The Black Hand Reaches Out” (from “Weapons of Tomorrow”, 2020)

Have finally gotten around to this playlist and picked up a few wins.  Never heard anything off Paegan Terrorism Tactics from Acid Bath before and have been spinning that record a couple of times since this list.  The Paradise Lost track got me itching to go back and explore their largely untested early material. Hell I even enjoyed the Jesu track, considering I normally find their material too accessible.  That Baroness track is quite infectious I also found.

Nice work Sonny.

Thanks Sonny, glad you enjoyed it.

Well done Xeph.

Really enjoyed this month's playlist.  Managed to get through it in one sitting this morning which is rare during work hours.

Fluisteraars continue to please me the more I hear from them with the largely shortened format of their releases making them a quick win.  My other major takeaway was a reminder to check out that Altar of Plagues record again as keep meaning to write a review for it but never quite get around to it.  Profane Order are new to me but liked what I heard here of them.

New Marduk and Tsjuder sound promising so must add them to the "to do" list.


After six weeks of trying, I finally managed to secure an interview which I attended yesterday. It went beautifully & I'm reasonably confident of receiving an offer but the only problem is that they want me in the office every day which means three hours of driving every single day. I'm not sure I can keep that up for long periods but I'm considering taking it anyway as it's very much in line with what I'm looking for.

Also, Sphere of Apparition Records have received the Neuropath CDs & tell me that they've come out even better than they expected. They sent me nine copies on Friday so I should receive them in the next few business days. Excited!

Quoted Daniel

Good luck with that.  I wouldn't envy the drive - I intend to never work in an office again if I can avoid it.  This is because of the commute/drive and the fact that it involves other people also.  Great news about the CDs.


My suggestions for November Vinny:


Testament - "Last Stand for Independence" (from "Dark Roots of Earth", 2012)

Quoted Sonny

Hi Sonny,


Daniel has already nominated a Testament track for the upcoming month, would you like to submit an alternative?

Only a couple for me for November please Daniel:

Altarage - "Cataract" (from "Worst Case Scenario", 2023)

Adramelech - "The Book of the Worm" (from "Psychostasia", 1996)


November for me please Ben:

Draugur - "Behold the Third Eye Vision" (from "By the Rays of His Golden Light", 2016)

Bathory - "Valhalla" (from "Hammerheart", 1990)


November for me please Sonny:

Corrosion of Conformity - "Wolf Named Crow" (from "No Cross No Crown", 2018)

Godthrymm - "We Are the Dead" (from "Reflections", 2020)

Kowloon Walled City - "The Pressure Keeps Me Alive" (from "Container Ships", 2012)


October 2023

1. Kill The Pharoah – “Bleed for Me” (from “Thrash Delivers”, 2022) [Submitted by Vinny]

2. Assault – “Antebellum” (from “A Blind Eye”, 2022) [Submitted by Vinny]

3. Rhythm of Fear – “Parasomniac” (from “Fatal Horizons”, 2022) [Submitted by Vinny]

4. Sarcator – “Ascend” (from “Alkahest”, 2022) [Submitted by Vinny]

5. Lucifuge – “The Great Unseen” (from “Of Night & Lust”, 2022) [Submitted by Vinny]

6. Graveripper – “Seasons Dreaming Death” (from “Seasons Dreaming Death”, 20230

7. KAT – “Porwany obledem” (from “Oddech wymarlych swiatow”, 1988) [Submitted by Daniel]

8. Cyst – “Curse the Fates” (from “Concussion Symphony”, 2002)

9. Opprobrium – “Curse of the Damned Cities” (from “Beyond the Unknown”, 1990) [Submitted by Sonny]

10. Besieged – “Internal Suffering” (from “Victims Beyond All Help”, 2010)

11. Vio-lence – “Serial Killer” (from “Eternal Nightmare”, 1988) [Submitted by Daniel]

12. Sodom – “Lead Injection” (from “M-16”, 2001) [Submitted by Daniel]

13. Destruction – “Reject Emotions” (from “Mad Butcher”, 1987) [Submitted by Sonny]

14. Go Ahead And Die – “Tumors” (from “Unhealthy Mechanisms”, 2023)

15. Paralysis – “Frozen Inside” (from “Above the Abyss”, 2023)

16. Nuclear Assault – “Cross of Iron” (from “The Plague - EP”, 1987) [Submitted by Sonny]

17. Meshuggah – “Paralyzing Ignorance” (from “Contradictions Collapse”, 1991) [Submitted by Daniel]

18. Cosmic Jaguar – “Temple of the Feathered Serpent” (from “The Legacy of the Aztecs”, 2023)

19. Helstar – “He’s A Woman, She’s A Man” (from “A Distant Thunder”, 1988) [Submitted by Daniel]

20. Scanner – “Grapes of Fear” (from “Hypertrace”, 1988) [Submitted by Daniel]

21. Demoniac – “Granada” (from “Nube Negra”, 2023) [Submitted by Sonny]

22. Deathhammer – “Crushing the Pearly Gates” (from “Electric Warfare”, 2022)

23. Slaughter Messiah – “Pouring Chaos” (from “Cursed to the Pyre”, 2020)

24. Algebra – “Inner Constraints” (from “Pulse?”, 2019)

25. Draghoria – “Terror Hypnosis” (from “Dangerous Species”, 2022)

26. Enemynside – “Suffered Defeat” (from “Chaos Machine”, 2019)

27. Necrokinesis – “No Future” (from “Necrokinesis”, 2020)

28. Anthrax – “Belly of the Beast” (from “Persistence of Time”, 1990) [Submitted by Daniel]



I'll give my vote to Black Sabbath's debut as ground zero for metal. Half of the tracklisting wasn't metal but all of the most important tracks were clearly metal as fuck so it certainly qualifies in my opinion.

Deep Purple had a few albums before "In Rock" Rex. Is "In Rock" the only one of their first four that you consider to be metal or would you like us to consider any of those earlier releases? I completely agree with you on Led Zeppelin. The greatest hard rock band that's ever lived but certainly not a metal band.

Andi, Morpheus, Ben, Vinny, Saxy, Xephyr, SilentScream, etc? Would any of you like to be involved in this exercise?

Quoted Daniel

Not for me thank you Daniel.



I spend an inordinate amount of time rating covers on here.  My mother is an artist and (as with everything else in my life) if time permitted I would spend more time exploring art.  I have a print of John Martin's "Sadak In Search of the Waters of Oblivion" on my wall above my music stack and plan to add more to my office/lair walls.

Have an internet acquaintance who I planned to meet whilst in the States a few years back but couldn't co-ordinate diaries, who does art for album covers.  Super-talented guy (also involved in a number of music projects) - his artwork is here:

https://kishorhaulenbeek.com/ 

Quoted UnhinderedbyTalent

I have never seen "Sadak In Search of the Waters of Oblivion" before Vinny, but it is fantastic and has a similar feel to some of Lewandowski's paintings.

Do you know any covers that Kishor has produced off hand? He does look very talented. I think hands are one of the hardest parts of human anatomy to capture well and he does them brilliantly (and quite a lot by the looks of it!)


Quoted Sonny

Hi Sonny, he lists the albums under any of the Illustrations (no paintings used) that have been used under the image on the website mate.  Black Harvest is his own band/project btw.

I spend an inordinate amount of time rating covers on here.  My mother is an artist and (as with everything else in my life) if time permitted I would spend more time exploring art.  I have a print of John Martin's "Sadak In Search of the Waters of Oblivion" on my wall above my music stack and plan to add more to my office/lair walls.

Have an internet acquaintance who I planned to meet whilst in the States a few years back but couldn't co-ordinate diaries, who does art for album covers.  Super-talented guy (also involved in a number of music projects) - his artwork is here:

https://kishorhaulenbeek.com/ 

Good to see this see the light of day Daniel.

Tenebrae - "Serenades of the Damned" (1994)

Having spare time to pursue my exploration of Canadian black metal is a real test at present but this does have the benefit of me being able to take it slowly and not just dive into any release that I find.  Today I wanted to look at some demos and I stumbled across Tenebrae (Latin word for "darkness") and their short discography that matches their short life together.  This five-piece managed just one full-length release before they split up.  Their demo that arrived some two years before their album is a suitably raw affair that contains some Emperor style symphonic keyboards to add into the mix.  The vocalist here is the guy who owns Sepulchral Productions (Martin Marcotte) and he gives a true to style grim and ghastly performance which is the standout performance on the release.  Those keyboards are not well represented in the overall sound and come across as amateurish and border on dungeon synth a little also.

The twin guitar attack works well alongside busy yet not always clear drums.  There's not really a lot on offer here that had not already been done by the Norwegians in the three or four years that preceded this release.  For a demo though, you get thirty-five minutes of sluggishly structured black metal that tries to run before it can walk on some occasions yes, but on the whole is still interesting listening (the last track however is a clusterfuck).  Not essential listening on my exploration but at least the influences are obvious.

Can be located on Bandcamp (on a "pay what you want" basis) or YouTube for anyone who is interested.

3/5

Following my immediate purchase on CD of VoidCeremony's debut album in 2020 after just a couple of streams online, I was keeping an eye out for the follow up for what felt like an eternity. With its bass-heavy presence the debut took the prog element of prog-death and put it on a plinth all of its own before surrounding it with some great OSDM vibes to ground proceedings nicely. Some three years later and Threads of Unknowing picks up essentially where Entropic Reflections Continuum: Dimensional Unravel left off. Damon Good's bass still commands a lot of attention (and rightly so) and that OSDM vibe is still present also, thankfully.

The main immediate difference to note this time is that production job that makes the drums sound like the are incredibly brittle. Despite the obvious hard work of Charles Koryn, his efforts are stifled somewhat by knob-twiddler, Gabriele Gramaglia. The leads shine well enough though. Soaring and uplifting, they do a quality job of expanded the soundscape of Threads... without giving us any pretentious traits to get annoyed over, These, cleaner, more progressive elements are the strongest part of the album for me and I agree that VoidCermony do work better as a progressive outfit as opposed to a technical/prog-death band. I do not have a problem with the vocals actually. I can see where the aversion comes from but I find them perfectly acceptable.

Whilst I am not as instantly blown away by their sophomore album, I still find Threads of Unknowing to be a solid record and one that does grow with each listen. Yes, it is bottom-heavy, with the second half of the record easily outstripping the first half, but this is still a mighty fine album, delivered by some very professional sounding individuals. Drums aside, I have no real issue here.

4/5

The debut EP from Isis shows a remarkable level of maturity. The build to opening track Poison Eggs sounds like it is written by a band some ten years into their existence, not just twelve months as was the case with the band at the time. This release shows just why Isis grew into staples of the sludge metal world. Whilst there are spades of aggression and harshness for the listener to feast upon, there is a restraint to elements of the violence also. Underlined by the tightness of the performances, as a whole The Mosquito Control is a real force to be reckoned with.

At not even a full half hour, there still feels a lot of activity to process on this EP. Tracks shift and lurch beneath the monumental weight of the noise created by the fusion of drums, guitars, bass and vocals. Yet no track ever descends into full-blown chaos, even on the manic Life Under the Swatter there is a more subtle passage that tempers the frantic pace and tempo really well, giving the listener a slight breather before launching them straight back into the pulsating fury of the track again. The standout performance on the EP is without doubt Aaron Turner's vocals. Rabid to the point of leaving him breathless, they fit so well with the instrumentation it is literally a marriage made in heaven. That is not say that the rest of the group take a back seat. The stabbing groove of the riff that starts Hive Destruction proper is infectious as fuck and I find myself clamouring for its urgent cuts as the slower, doomier riffs take precedent. Likewise, the motoring bass of Jeff Caxide drives this sense of urgency and control throughout the whole EP, whilst Aaron Harris puts an amazing shift in on the drums.

The heaviness on display throughout The Mosquito Control is relentless. Listen to any modern sludge act like Primitive Man and you will here the poisonous fury of Relocation Swarm as cornerstones of most of what they do. This is possibly one the heaviest releases I have heard in my life and the production and mix job leaves it all sounding so fresh and organic. This is oppressive music that is ironically very freeing an experience to listen to. You absolutely should give this the attention it commands. There are no short measures of focus allowed when listening to The Mosquito Control, close all the blinds/curtains, turn all non-essential devices off and let the music take you.

4.5/5

The promise of some Deftones influence in any band's sound instantly puts them on a solid footing for me to venture into checking out at least one or more of their releases. Narrow Head do not fail to live up to that promise either. There are times during Moments of Clarity when you could be forgiven for thinking they are the Deftones. They wear that influence on their sleeves with pride and do a very good job of representing the nu-metal/hazy alternative metal sound along the way. My problem with MoC is not that it anyway apes or simply copies an already well-sampled blueprint. The issue I have with this record is simply that is boring.

There is an overwhelming sense of positivity in the sound of Narrow Head that I just cannot bear. Notwithstanding that I am most definitely not a happy person 90% of the time, the good vibes here are still too much and the album fails to shine with any maturity or sensibility at all. Tracks just seem to merge into one. With no depth to the song writing there are no standout moments to pick up on and no variance in the emotions to hammer home any real point to the record.

My forays into The Gateway are very infrequent and it is the fear of finding records like this that give me that mindset. Far too safe and far too staid as a result.

1.5/5

For a while it was looking like my review of “Reeking Pained and Shuddering” was going the same way of 2020’s “I Speak the Truth…” in terms of me struggling to actually articulate any individual standout parts. As with that later release, the 2007 offering is upon first listen a chaotic and often unsettling affair, but on this particular ride that unsettling nature is delivered beyond just the maelstrom of sounds that we are presented with. To these ears, “Reeking…” presents with a lot more control and conscious effort to disturb the listener with some good old fashioned atmospherics and samples.


Look past the scathing vocals and clatter and clashes of industrial influence and you will hear a cinematic dark ambience to this record. I had to make a rare excursion into using my headphones to truly appreciate the qualities on show here (something which my ears will suffer for today I am sure). The time taken, sat in a dark hotel room with no external distractions to take my focus off the stimulation my ears where receiving gave me the chance to track the proper structures that sit in amongst the torrent of terror of most tracks. These consistent elements seem to take the form of droning atmospheres that provide a dense foundation layer to the tracks.


The samples from various horror films and other macabre sources, work well and add depth to what could otherwise be barren soundscapes in terms of a perceived human touch. Ranging from the dramatic to the downright weird, they offer snapshots of madness into an already demented routine. Here again though is where I struggle a bit with the record. There is a lot going on and so if you are looking for memorability, those snippets that you hold onto, subconsciously or otherwise, then you are going to struggle here. For me, there would be no dialling down of the extremity if a few less ideas made it onto the record as the consistent parts develop an environment all of their own. This is still a good record though, albeit one that I would not consciously be drawn back to on a regular basis. I am coming to view Gnaw Their Tongue releases as occasional jolts to the system to remind me that the blueprint of structures can be torn up and form can be sacrificed for all out expression of the true turmoil within some artists.

3.5/5


I know this is supposed to be a thread where members give out recommendations to others, but I wonder if I might make a request for recommendations here.

Due to the challenge I undertook to gain admittance to The Horde and my general preference for OSDM, I have very little experience with modern death metal. So, bearing in mind that I dislike dissonance and am not too keen on the more technical releases (although I don't mind a certain degree of technicality), could anyone recommend me some good death metal released in the last two or three years, please.

Quoted Sonny

Hi Sonny,

Here's some of my finds over the last 10 years. As a general starter for ten, I usually find that anything on the Maggot Stomp record label is a winner from an OSDM perspective.

Abraded - s/t  (2021)

https://metal.academy/releases/36951 - grinding, d-beat stomping goodness from Cleveland

Cerebral Rot - Excretion of Mortality (2021)

https://metal.academy/releases/28977 - a familiar blast of 90's death metal, incorporating death/doom, Autopsy-like values on production and musicianship as well as the squally depths of Demilich for good measure.

Corpsessed

Dumbass name aside, if you want some modern Finn-death then this lot will scratch that itch.  Debut is solid enough but does little to standout from the pack, their latest shows maturity abounding though.

https://metal.academy/bands/4677

Immolation

Although not perfect by any means, the last two Immolation records are perfectly respectable releases showing these guys can still kick it with the best of the new bunch out there

https://metal.academy/releases/650

https://metal.academy/releases/34382

Krypts - Cadaver Circulation (2019)

https://metal.academy/releases/10476 - Finnish death doom that I would think to be right up your street Sonny.

Seprevation - Consumed (2014)

https://metal.academy/releases/27051 - UK death/thrash that I picked up on when doing the Review Draft before we canned that.  Possessed, Sadus and Slayer influences are obvious but there's plenty death metal here also.

Undeath - Lesions of a Different Kind (2020)

https://metal.academy/releases/24108 - pure OSDM worship here, embrace it.





September 08, 2023 12:58 PM

I don't mind a good article or interview but (as you allude to Daniel) with barely enough time to keep on top of playlists and feature releases, not sure where the time to do engage on this would come from.  I think we are skirting around the elephant in the room in that forums in general are a dying artform - now that's not to say we should let them die - so with all the best will in the world, as forums continue to shutdown (MetalFi being one I am more recently aware of) there will only ever be small numbers of members of these niche communities looking for a new home.  In my experience this means about four or five regulars becoming new members somewhere else when forced to do so. I just do not buy into this notion that there is any halfway substantial quantity of people out there waiting to join a metal forum/site.  Not trying to sound negative, just being honest.

To pick up on Sonny's point about resources, I only use any website as one of many resources if I am researching anything, just to make sure I get consistent information usually.  So I don't personally feel there is any hinderance here on MA from a resource perspective.

September 07, 2023 07:11 AM



Personally, I'd like to see people taking whatever they like from the Academy so I wouldn't want to offer upgraded statuses to those that see merit in completing the clan challenges when there are so many other ways to contribute to the site. In fact, I'd argue that bringing new members to the site, regularly contributing to the forums, helping to close out Hall of Judgement submissions & participating in the monthly playlist & feature release activities all bring more to the wider community than progressively completing clan challenges in isolation. Besides, I'm not sure I'd be comfortable with individuals holding higher statuses than others on the Academy given that our original intent was to create an elitist-free environment where everyone is treated equally.

Quoted Daniel

I repeat: They aren't really "higher status."  They'd only be a measurement of how many clan challenges you accumulate.  On Metal Forum, there's a rank status but nobody ever brought it up on the forums.  It doesn't really feel important as it was more of a "way to go for getting this far" kind of thing, like a special cutscene from a Metroid game.  It was just there for fun, same as the badge system on Wikia.  Now I don't know how it works on Metallum, but if there's one thing I do know: this community cannot be compared to them because we're nowhere near as stuffy.  Honestly, if you're gonna gloat about it, chances are that the rest of the community will make fun of you for it.  Metal Archives is... special.  And this is coming from the autistic one.  Normal metal websites like this, Metal Forum and Metal Music Archives don't need to worry about it.

Quoted Rexorcist

By way of context, nobody brought it up at Metal Forum because nobody there cares.  It came as part of the new board config introduced in a hurry after repeated security issues and the admin has insufficient time to disable it. 

I am not having a go at you here Rex, but in terms of bringing new members to Metal Academy,  where do you think these people are after the site being here for a number of years already?  There's no orderly queue formed just waiting for some new game-changing feature or functionality to open the floodgates for new members.  This is why (and correct me if I am wrong Ben or Daniel) enhancements to the site are largely done with the existing community in mind and to help the founding members realise their vision and goals. 

"Motivation" to complete challenges is entirely personal I believe, if I have a vested interest in a genre/sub-genre and I want to discover more about it then there's a resource for it here (for the majority of circumstance).  There appears to be the intimation here that the challenges need to be completed to serve the purpose of their existence which is clearly not the case.  If I discover one new album or better still an artist via one of the challenges then they are a success. Plus I can complete any one of the remaining challenges without needing to be recognised for it - I have been afforded that luxury already.  

Finally, Ben and Daniel have entrusted the regulars here with not only feature release nominations but also the programming and publishing of monthly playlists for each clan.  That speaks volumes for the regard they hold the contributors to the site, better than any badge or merit status.

Again, not having a go, just adding some context from my experience of this great site.

September 06, 2023 07:41 PM

I think the current clan system works fine.  Simple reward from Metal Academy is not how many clans I end up with or not but how much new music I discover from the site as a whole (yes, a lot of it gleaned from the challenges section but also the feature releases and playlists give me plenty to run at as well).