In Flames - Foregone (2023)^{Release ID: 42570}

Another band I grew up with that I loved then decided to get mediocre on me. However, Foregone is the best album from these guys since 2000. I actually caught myself a little toe tappy, a little head boppy, a little smile on my face for once. Still nothing compared to their 90's releases which still are some of the best melodic death releases of all time but this is solid. Harsh vocals are back in a good way, nothing too extreme but they made me feel good. The melodies are there, but also a bit repetitive. I had fun. A solid, good refresher of the In Flames style and am proud of them boys for making a decent record again. When you're not quite sure if they can ever make anything great again they come back and make a solid effort. Still not sure if they have it in them to make another Whoracle or Jester Race but I will not complain and this is a direction I will gladly accept and spin from time to time. 

In Flames followers wanted the band to return to their earlier melodic death metal sound, and they've finally done it in their 14th album Foregone! Part of the motivation might have been from The Halo Effect, a new band formed by former members of In Flames to revive the old-school melodeath. I was looking forward to returning to listening to In Flames after a couple-year break, especially since my brother likes one of the album's singles. However, the album is a bit disappointing...

Now don't get me wrong. There's actually some positive light in this offering. After all, this marks the band's return to melodeath form that was strong in the late 90s. The band currently led by guitarist Björn Gelotte and vocalist and Anders Fridén still have a bit of sweetness in the music, and not the good type, more like a mushy love poem. The poppy metalcore part of the recent sound is no longer fully around, and when it does appear, it's in a more interesting balance with the heaviness. It's quite strong and sensible, but again, too sweet for a melodeath album.

"The Beginning of All Things That Will End" is a two-minute folk-ish acoustic intro that's nicely sentimental. The action kicks off with the single "State of Slow Decay", which pleasantly surprised fans with heavy riffing, drumming energy, and metal soloing, bringing back the glory of the band's earlier era and At the Gates. This is straight on metal heaviness that's entirely different from their previous album I the Mask. And that's the single my brother likes from this album. Absolutely strong and promising! "Meet Your Maker" is another excellent metal track. "Bleeding Out" works out quite well in the chorus. There are two title tracks that tricked me into thinking it was two-part suite when it ain't, starting with "Foregone, Pt. 1" which is the best throwback to the Jesper Strömblad era of melodeath fury with a memorable chorus. Though I wish it was longer...

"Foregone Pt. 2", on the other hand, is far too sweet, though not as weak as their previous two albums. That sh*tty composition has nothing to do with the first title track! And look, another stinker, "Pure Light of Mind"! The next track "The Great Deceiver" is pretty great, adding true heavy strength to the melody. "In the Dark" is a big shining moment for their new rhythm guitarist Chris Broderick, formerly of Jag Panzer, Megadeth, and Nevermore, as he adds technical color to the soloing.

"A Dialogue in B Flat Minor" continues the sound of Sounds of a Playground Fading as a heavier sequel. "Cynosure" is quite bad though, I'm not sure what they were thinking there. The deeper growling vocals work well in the "End the Transmission", better than the rest of the album. Unfortunately, the clean singing sounds sh*ttier than the rest of the album there. And why is "Become One" only a bonus track? That's probably the best non-single song, with the great riffing and soloing of melodeath, along with a catchy chorus. For that amazing song to be left out in many editions is a total bummer.

A band making almost a full return to their roots after a couple decades is rare, but that happened with the new In Flames album Foregone. While some songs still show the band at their worst, there's a good amount of positive surprises. They can show how capable they are in their melodeath return, despite the overpowering mainstream....

Favorites: "State of Slow Decay", "Meet Your Maker", "Foregone, Pt. 1", "The Great Deceiver", "In the Dark", "Become One" (bonus track)

It is nice to hear In Flames returning back to a sound that is closer to melodic death metal such as Come Clarity. But that is not the complete story. Foregone still relies a lot on pretty standard instrumental riffage that, while certainly pleasant, does not do very much to distinguish each track from the next, whether that be through the same prominent key center on almost every track, or lack of tempo variety. This record still has its fair share of clean vocal choruses, but due to the lack of instrumental variety, this also seeps in to the vocal variety as well.

I wish there was more to say about Foregone. It has the pieces of a modern day Trivium album, but without any of the variety that band provides.

Best Songs: Meet Your Maker, Foregone Pt. 1, Pure Light of Mind

P.S. I've given this a few more listens since I initially reviewed it and I found that the return to melo-death is not as triumphant as I originally envisioned. While I am certainly no elitist who thinks clean vocals do not belong in death metal, when there is an instrumental lead, it is not able to compliment the vocals well, clean or harsh. It just makes those vocals feel superficial. In Flames can make an excellent melo-death album, but their years of The Court Jester and Whoracle are well behind them.