Between the Buried and Me - The Great Misdirect (2009)^{Release ID: 1740}

I need to catch up with BTBAM again. I really do! The Great Misdirect is known as one of the greatest albums from the band besides Colors, and was a masterpiece for me when I was still listening to them. But in the past year or so, I've only listened to a couple songs from their first two albums when assembling the Revolution playlists. With this nice revisit, let's see what I still think of this album...

Between the Buried and Me can chug through progressiveness faster than a train. Colors was once a true landmark for me. It continues the transition they had through their first 3 albums. With the new lineup of bassist Dan Briggs, rhythm guitarist Dustie Waring, and drummer Blake Richardson maintaining their places, the progressive hints from their earlier albums have evolved into a new essential part of the sound in Colors. The songs are longer and they all transition to each other like a multi-part suite. The earlier heaviness kept going, mixed with some fun wacky parts. Colors was a f***ing masterpiece for me, and so was The Great Misdirect. What do I think of the latter now?

Similarly to Colors' intro, "Mirrors" begins this album as its intro that almost doubles as a short soft song. A bit of the soft wackiness is already hinted in the jazzy bridge. "Obfuscation" can fit well as a single that should've been recorded and released between Alaska and Colors. It also shows the soft-hard blend they've used since The Silent Circus. All in all, a good start to the progressive action!

The best song for me is "Disease, Injury, Madness", having a different execution the same soft-hard blend. It starts in a progressive deathcore frenzy, then switches to soft and clean, all leading up to an excellent bluesy section in the second half. A unique standout! After that, "Fossil Genera - A Feed from Cloud Mountain" is a grand hint at the band's move away from their early metalcore. The first couple minutes show vocalist Tommy Rogers impersonating Mike Patton in a circus-like metal sound, a bit like a heavier The Decemberists. Then the rest is the usual extreme progressive metal before ending with an epic rising climax.

"Desert of Song" is the album's weakest link, though it's a nice bridge before the epic storm to come. It's a 5 and a half minute semi-acoustic ballad with some vocals by lead guitarist Paul Waggoner and well-done bass. It's a good place to breathe before one final adventure you won't forget... The 18-minute epic "Swim to the Moon" is the band's longest song to date, though the length hasn't surpassed Opeth's "Black Rose Immortal" or a few of Dream Theater's epics. I enjoy these progressive epics, but nowadays, I find the song's length to be a bit f***ing draggy. The soloing section has non-stop shredding in both the guitars and keyboards for a few minutes. Impressive, but fits more as a live jam. There's also an Alaska/Colors-like breakdown. Then it ends mellow after reusing the earlier riff. The track is still an epic highlight despite the extensive length.

Despite a bit of error that I now recognize when the band make literally one of their finest hours, it's still not too big of a deal. The transitions are almost never forced, and most of the songs are set up well overall. Tommy's vocals range from explosive growls in better quality to melodic cleans that no longer sound robotic. He appears less while still around a lot, allowing the other members to shine, including Blake whose drumming is so unique and heavy in the patterns. Between the Buried and Me continue the progressive journey they've had since The Silent Circus, and while The Great Misdirect isn't as perfect as I once thought it was, it's their finest hour of coherence!

Favorites: "Disease, Injury, Madness", "Fossil Genera - A Feed from Cloud Mountain", "Swim to the Moon" (despite being a bit draggy)