Rexorcist's Forum Replies

The Gerogerigege - Instruments Disorder

Genres: Harsh Noise

Listening to noise albums helps drown out unwanted sounds when doing outside work, so I've kind of forced my subconscious to become interested in critiquing noise music.  Just started this iconic one, and it's not the first of their albums I've heard.  I heard a couple of their "Senzuri" ones ages ago in prep for this and later forgot.

Current top 10 noise albums (not including noise rock, pop, punk, etc., unless the album falls under both straightforward noise and one of these genres.)

1. Uboa - Impossible Light (100)

2. Full of Hell & Merzbow - Sister Fawn (100)

3. Man Is the Bastard - The Lost MITB Sessions (100)

4. Uboa - The Origin of My Depression (97)

5. Cabinet - Hydrolysated Ordination (96)

6. Full of Hell & Merzbow - Full of Hell & Merzbow (96)

7. The Caretaker - Everywhere at the End of Time: Stage 5 (95)

8. Lingua Ignota - Caligula (95)

9. Uboa - All the Dead Melt Down as Rain (95)

10. Alder Deep - Chapter 2: Kobolds, Goblins, Cretins, Fiends (95)

WHOA.  Didn't think I had ten five-stars.

This Heat - "Health & Efficiency" single (1980)

This single from a critically acclaimed London experimental rock outfit contains just the two lengthy tracks but spans over nineteen minutes in duration. The title track is an ambitious & highly engaging eight-minute rock effort while the B side "Graphic/Varispeed" represents one of the earlier forays into drone territory & sounds nothing like the rest of This Heat's material. I thoroughly enjoy the title track as it possesses a live electricity & vitality that's rarely found in rock music these days. "Graphic/Varispeed" is probably the reason a lot of people discover this E.P. & it's not bad but does tend to suffer from being overly long at over eleven minutes with very little variation on its theme.

For fans of Can, The Fiery Furnaces & Matmos.

3.5/5

I binged the two studio albums and this EP a while back.  Overlong yes, but fun,  You know, those were two of the first post-punk albums I ever heard, and I couldn't get into them at the time, even though I admited they were pretty good.  I feel similarly to the debut, but Deciet is just phenomenal.

My jazz fusion studies will conclude with just a couple more albums by the following artists: Casiopea, Bela Fleck and Henry Threadgill.  Just when I think I'm done with the jazz fusion studies, I find a couple extra details I need to get done.  After that's all done, I'll head onto post-bop.  But first!  I'm at the point to where I can safely binge another metal band for the list challenges.  I only have four bands to get through.  This time, it'll likely be Destruction.

Right now I'm on UFO Tofu by Bela Fleck.  So far, it's pretty good, but nowhere near the heights of the debut.

I suppose I'll end my Hiromi study with this year's release, Out There, and then likely move onto Hermeto Pascoal for the next couple days.

Didn't think Takanaka was gonna do a country fusion track, but it's pretty bitchin'.

Uboa - All the Dead Melt Down as Rain (2025)

Genres: Death Industrial, Dark Ambient

I had no idea Uboa had a new EP out a couple months ago.  I just now checked wondering if she had a new album announced.  Didn't expect one so soon, and I'm super happy about this because Impossible Light and Origin of My Depression are just flatout phenomenal, doing much of what Lingua Ignota does but creepier and more wild.  Sitting pretty at 37 minutes, this EP manages to do A LOT and never break its horrifying vibes.  This one was extra-diversified in its range of ambiance, noise and industrial sounds.  This is as freakishly creepy as I'd expect from Uboa, and almost reaches the heights of Impossible Light.

95

Pain of Salvation - Remedy Lane (2002)

Genres: Prog Metal

Here it is, the final of the four Pain of Salvation albums for my marathon, and the final album before I complete my Prog Metal Challenge List.  To recap, my ratings for the first three albums fluctuated drastically from the general consensus.  People say that Entropia was a great metal debut, but to me it was a bit imbalanced and not heavy enough.  I almost adored Concrete Lake, and I thought the much-beloved Perfect Element was a good but somewhat overdrawn album with too much fixation on post-metal influence that seemed to take away from the identity of the first two albums.  And now, here I am, at the general opus.

While I loved the instrumental direction the short opener took, the next track, ironically named Ending Theme, so was I in for more of the typical prog metal sound that I was so weary of when my marathon began with the debut's first couple tracks?  Fandango seemed to answer my question: not entirely.  Fandango's general sense of rhythm is totally xylophonic, not built in metal energy while the backing effects and percussion deliver a strong sense of surrealism.  This is basically an experimental track, and I mean almost Residents level, even though it clearly uses the same instruments as previous efforts, so that was a damn good sign.  But unfortunately, the next two tracks, while great and beautifully melodic, only provide faint ventures from the standard to other areas, so I'm not so sure what'll happen next.  The eight minute Trace of Blood has some nice piano melodies scattered around, but remains high-level typical.  The next track, This Heart of Mine, seems to have some Gabriel-era Genesis influence in the vibes, but not very strongly.  Undertow was kinda lame in comparison.  It just repeate the same slow melody over and over again and only differentiated itself by being more quiet.

Things got pretty proggy again on the more active track, Rope Ends, which knows how to put together a decent rhythm while maintaining the very reason I listen to prog in the first place.  This one didn't stop being catchy, even when it was going wild.  I get a nice follow-up with some Latin folk influence on Chain Sling, which showcases the best of the band's previously established strengths.  Easily a winner of a song.  Dryad of the woods continues the folk rock focus and is a nice and soft tune on its own, but even slow songs have more pizazz, and while this was nice and emotional, it was also missing that special something.  After the title track, which is a largely prog electronic two-minute segue with a tamed but epic approach, the next track is immediately shamed as it falls into only decent melody and standard behavior for the band.  Purely palatable, not remarkable.  Same with the track after that, but then the ending, Beyond the Pale, gets back on track with a proper ending that takes the overall vibe of the band to a good strength, ending with one of their more emotional and rhythmically healthy takes of the modern prog sound.

Well, I didn't get the magnum opus everyone was bragging about, but it has plenty of strengths among the traditional sound.  This was a very enjoyable album overall, but I'd say that instead of it being one of the greatest I've heard, it's more on the level of Dream Theater's underrated debut.

87

Pain of Salvation - The Perfect Element I

Genres: Prog Metal

After turning this album on, immediately after concluding One Hour by the Concrete Lake, I certainly wasn't expecting the verses to be orchestrated in NU METAL.  But that didn't tell me this was gonna end up a nu metal album, just that this album was gonna end up wild and varied just like the previous efforts.  Honestly, there's really no way to tell with these guys.  But it's pretty obvious from the slow melodic structures and the nu metal influence that they were trying to appeal to the modern alternative crowd without being an alternative band.  You can easily tell from the way our singer occasionally shouts in a very similar manner to Wayne Static.  Despite this, post-metal also reigns pretty strong in the background, having a larger say than any other kind of influence in the album.  This creates a strong sense of ballad-based serenity throughout a good chunk of it.  These are good tracks with a strong sense of progession and some fine melodies, but in comparison to the wide range they went with on the debut and managed to balance out beautifully on the second, this seems a bit less inventive.  For example, the first half of Her Voices is made up of this until it takes an immediate shift into speedy Arabic influence, as if they suddenly became The Tea Party.  But there are songs that are practically entirely made up of the post-metal influence, like the titular closer.  And unfortunately, the songs, while quite enjoyable, are a bit too similar too each other in moods, and the melodies are often a bit light.  So in short, this was a GOOD album for me, but not brilliant.

82

Pain of Salvation - One Hour by the Concrete Lake (1998)

Genres: Prog Metal

I don't feel like doing another track-by-track review today, so I'll just cover the most important stuff.  Hearing the actual music kickstart with a beautiful piano metal intro already told me there was a Symphony X similarity that might end up going through the whole album.  As a huge fan of Symphony X, I adored the neoclassical piano focus.  While I can't say this was "groundbreaking," I was certainly impressed with the healthy upgrade in balance between melody and progression, as well as a totally new sound for the band.  On top of which, metallic moments seem to be a bit heavier and more layered, which was an issue for the more metal-oriented songs of the debut.  The occasional industrial backdrops also help with that, as well as with more robotic guitar tones and riffs.  And of course, there's always a little room for a softer and more contemplative song with some violin attached.  But these elements don't often overpower the standard dramatic prog metal aspects, but rather add light influences for the most part.  In fact, it's enough to make sure most of these songs feel different enough from each other to almost be different subgenres of prog metal.  Handful of Nothing, for example, is quite mechanical in its handling of hardcore punk influence, never really steering into "metalcore," though.

I gotta say, though.  Only about half the time the melodies manage to really impress me.  For example, a wonderful collective of rhythms takes up the bulk of Home, but in comparison, a track like Water feels a bit empty.  Thankfully, the former happens a bit more often.  A track like Home is followed by an incredibly proggy yet catchy track like Black Hills, making for an excellent pairing.  Hell, I'd say Black Hills even astounded me, managing to be better than the already grand Home.  On top of all that, the various sounds and feelings connect well with the emotional focus of the theme, centering around the dystopian devastation and pollution of the world due to man's lack of sympathy for the world around them.  The theme isn't very story-based, but it does an excellent job sharing the lead character's feelings of despair.  Of course, it goes without saying that it takes a while for that hidden track to really pick up, about four out of six minutes.  But once it does, it really does, going into some beautiful avant-garde that perfectly covers what the album went through in a very quick time.

Major improvement over the last.  This is considered the weakest of the first four Pain of Salvation albums?  I might not agree with people's general consensus on the debut, but the improvement here seems like a very good sign for what's coming next.

93

Pain of Salvation - Entropia (1997)

Genres: Prog Metal, Prog Rock

Today is the day I finally finish my second list challenge: the Prog Metal 2nd Decade Challenge, and it'll happen on my Pain of Salvation marathon.  I'll be getting through at least the first four PaS albums, potentially ending at the album I need for the final review on this challenge list: Remedy Lane, the fourth album.  I never really got interested in Pain of Salvation for some reason, but I'll gladly check them out for the challenge.

Entropia is a concept album about a struggling family in a fictional titular world, and the main characters are basically detailed in a pretty poetic collection of lyrics that are also standardly "prog concept album."  I an't say there was anything here that made me feel too heavily.  Now I'm not saying that I didn't have any good expectations for Pain of Salvation's debut, but with the genre-tagging on RYM simple saying Prog Metal for primary and Prog Rock for secondary, I had a pretty good idea of what this album would sound like: standard guitar tones for prog metal and catchy mid-level progression that's only proggy enough not to stay off the radio.  The opener and the next song (not counting the pretty lame trip hop segue in between) are so standardly 1990's prog metal that it's not even funny.  Dream Theater obviously ended up manifesting a lot of emulators, such as Shadow Gallery and Evergrey.  Is it catchy?  Yeah, but I've totally heard this before.  In fact, I need it to be a little proggier.  Save the radio prog for Rush, guys.

Now I was pretty thrown off by the funk aspects that kicked off the nine-minute People Passing By.  That's considered to be one of their better songs on this album.  The song has a tendency to switch between these and blackened riffs in the same percussion tone like they naturally go together.  I wouldn't say that, but at least the prog improves here.  But it just isn't catchy enough or even heavy enough to really support my prog metal needs until the end when it pretty much just goes back into the standard behavior of the album.  After a totally standard ballad, the album takes a much catchier and outlandish turn with Stress, boasting instrumentation that even goes into Cardiacs territory with its hyper-melodic nature.  Unfortunately, while the instrumentation's awesome, singer Daniel Gildenlow's melodies are just lame and don't pair well with the song much.

Things get largely standard again on Revival, which tries to capture the same spirit as Stress but only really succeeds in one aspect: matching the singer's melodies to the instrumentation.  Now for the most part, To the End is the best the album had to offer.  Everything was energetic, in perfect harmony, and catchy while maintaining that intriguing unpredictability of People Passing By, even though its style is standard.  Next comes Nightmist, which is much less melodic and more built on maintaining an ever shifting atmosphere between fast and funky, slow and dramitic, and surprisingly hyperactive for a couple seconds, but I don't feel like banging my head to this one, even as the funk returns in small bits.  It seems more like a display of how proggy they can be without setting up the experience as a "song."  Plains of Dawn feels like it's going for more of a tonal balance as a slightly-symphonic prog rock song, and it kind of works, but also just tells me that they should've done some more about balance and behavior from previous songs on the album.  And finally, there's that ending segue (the segues have been largely unremarkable, by the way), Leaving Entropia.

A lot of people were very impressed with this debut, but it seemed generic at times, proggy but imbalanced at times, and showed a lot of compositional strengths that weren't always lived up to.

73

Tyler the Creatore - Don't Tap the Glass (2025)

Genres: Pop Rap, Dance

So one of modern hip hop's most experimental and wide-ranging artists, a total genius in the field, has now done a pop rap and dance album.  Is this selling out?  What reason would Tyler have to sell out?  It's his right to do a pop album if he wants, so judging it based on that merit, this is extraordinarily catchy and clever.  This so-called pop album might not be "experimental," but it's totally unpredictable.  The behavior of the album fits perfectly within the Tyler the Crator canon, cleverly combining many of the tricks and techniques this guy used in the past, even if he's using more pop-oritented genres than soul-oriented ones.  The production is almost constantly balancing out multiple facets with ease.  Maybe fans will miss the more thematic elements of his lyrics and music, but sometimes, a guy just needs to have some fun.  Tyler obviously considered that, and I'd say this is a very fun album full of good bangers.  I'm putting it in the same league as Bjork's Post.

93.5

Behemoth - The Shit ov God (2025)

Genres: Blackened Death Metal

Even though I believe in God, I've made a point of forgiving people for sins that don't really affect me. Now matter how much I bitch and whine, there will be people who disagree with me on philosophy, so might as well accept it as a part of the natural world while acknowledging the difference in philosophy. So I've heard all the Slayer albums, a good deal of Bathory, and am of the opinion that the best death metal band is Septicflesh. But Behemoth really made their point of hatred towards religion a million times over, so do we really need it again?

Considering how familiar this album is, I'm going to have to say "not this time." Behemoth's "The Shit ov God" is obviously built specifically to get anti-religious people to buy the album, as if they're relying on edge factor. Newsflash: that's how people LOSE interest. Hell, Wes Craven used to think being edgy was what mattered most, and his early career was pretty downhill once he hated and disowned his own porn flick, and switched right to THEMES, which made his movies much better overtime. But Behemoth took the opposite route.

Now the two good things that can be said about this album are that the production is absolutely perfect. The crystal clarity is some of the finest in metal, but that's to be expected from veterans. As well, half the riffs are quite catchy, which really does help. I found myself really enjoying the bits that got quite proggy, like the midtro of O Venvs, Come. So there's a strong metal energy here that can help everything be at least fairly enjoyable to some, but this is also an extremely typical album for them. I said half the riffs were catchy, but the other half are so standard that you can pull them off of any obscure crap lost in the RYM charts. So only half the time does the production justify these performances. As well, taking a look at the lyrics, they feel thrown together and basic. The overabundance of old-timey / medieval phrasing seems to distract from that aggressive, angry nature that they're trying to promote so brutally, so the ancient vibes and the religious anger kind of contradict each other like matter and antimatter.

So this most recent entry in the Behemoth catalogue was an attempt at bringing back the vibes of their most beloved work, The Satanist, but the quality steers a bit closer to their middling debut, Sventevith. Fun moments and boring moments are held together with a strong metallic presence and pure diamond production, so while it's perfectly listenable, it has its problems.

64

Freddie Gibbs & The Alchemist - Alfredo 2

I;d say this is in the same league as Alfredo 1.  Might be slightly better, might be slightly worse.

This sucks so much. I cannot express how much this guy and his music has meant to me over the years. I guess we all saw it coming one day soon, but we kept hoping that it would be tomorrow and not today. Now today is here and another metal icon has gone to join Lemmy in metal Valhalla. R.I.P. Ozzy.

On the major plus side, his farewell tour just got done.  So he did what he wanted to do throughout his life, and went out with a bang bigger than the theory.  Gonna blast Paranoid today in his honor.

So soon after his grand farewell tour with his iconic band, we've lost the forefather of metal himself... Ozzy Osbourne.  He struggled with Parkinson's for years.

As Yahweh heard you pray every concert, so may the world hear your legacy until the End Times.  Goodbye, beloved Ozzy.

There are very few DJs that can get away with playing 10+ minute tracks as you risk boring your audience & losing the dancefloor with club-goers becoming less & less patient in the Spotify age. Most DJs would only play a portion of an eleven-minute track. It's really just the big-name international stars that can confidently get away with playing the full run time as their audiences will generally lap up whatever they dish out & are usually off their heads anyway. For your average club DJ, the full length of a track like "Undisputed Attitude" would probably only be safe as a closer to a headline or closing set. The uplifting, euphoric atmosphere making it work really well in that capacity too.

That's true for any genre, but it's quite common in EDM for people to try, about as common as in prog rock, and that's what makes it a key factor.  Bands like Shpongle prove that.  Even Deadmau5 has his ten minute hits.  His fans typically listen to Strobe in its full form.  But yes, it takes a special artist to pull it off continuously.

As a defender of Naked Flames and his side of the controversy after reading his quite lengthy description of it, I was quite excited to learn that he had a new album out.  But sheesh, 7 HOURS LONG?  I mean, I consider the guy a house genius, but this had better be the most creative 7 hours on Earth.  I might only get through an hour or two a day for a week or so.  I can safely say, track Undisputed Attitude is a little bit hard to follow the beat of, but it sounds freaking brilliant.  Very nice to have my choice for #1 house artist back, or at least #1 outsider house artist back.  Not like I'm a master of house music or anything, but hey.  At least the guy knows how to keep an 11 minute song going.  That's an essential factor for club music.

Yep... along with most country music outside of the gothic stuff, although I admittedly have a Townes cover album that I absolutely love.

Does that include Johnny Cash (preparing mace)?

Yay! Now I’ll know which folk records to steer clear of. ;)

Staying clear of John Denver and Townes van Zandt...???

GODDAMN THEY FINALLY PUT COUNTRY FOLK ON RYM.  Man, that one makes me happy. I've been using that tag for a while but efforts to get it up in my time there didn't produce any fruit.  I'll give it a couple weeks to flesh out before I retag any albums I might've missed.  Not sure about Willi Carlisle getting the tag, but I'm on board with Gillian Welch.  And I'm really happy John Denver's getting the tag.

Green Carnation - Journey to the End of Night (2000)

Genres: Prog Metal

Green Carnation, a prog band formed by ex-Emperor bassist Tchort, is a band I've put off for a long time so I can focus on other kinds of metal and other genres in general, but I finally have the freedom to check out one of the three bands I need left for one of the Metal Academy prog metal list challenges. Even though I only need to review one of their albums, I wanted to go back to the beginning, as I believe a real student should expand further than just one album per band as the lists are exclusively formed.

So starting with the debut, I was quickly introduced to a psychedelic atmosphere that I had never heard before. The thirteen minute opener, In the Realm of the Midnight Sun, was an obvious effort in putting together various styles in a way that fit and could justify the length of 13 minutes. Now I'd say as far as progressing the various genres in one song goes, there wasn't any problem with that. But there's something that really needs to be addressed: some of the rhythms outshine other parts of the song by country miles, so the song still feels inconsistent in that way. I thought to myself, "I supposed that's where the leading criticism comes from?" I had other epics to check out before I could be certain of that. Another product of the inconsistency is how some metal moments are much heavier than others. I suppose the drums were improperly mixed, feeling a little faint for what they were striving to achieve. But by the third epic, which totals tracks 2-4 into 45 minutes, it kind of becomes a cycle of reused tricks in different epics, creating a sense of overlength. Even the fact that several shorter songs take up the end doesn't really detract from this.

For a first attempt, there's some good genre balance and ambition here, but the lack of original rhythmic ideas tells me that this was merely the band tackling too much at once and only fairly succeeding more at the intrigue rather than the music. It's a fine first attempt in that way, but more or less decent in other ways.

68

I think you'll find that if you've already rated a release & then add a review to it then it'll maintain the original date & won't be pushed onto the main page. Could that be the case here Rex? To get around that you need to delete your rating before posting your review.

Ah.  Okay.

The reviews are being misdated again.  I was scared that my multiple Darkthrone reviews from this week were accidentally deleted because of a glitch.

Fates Warning - A Pleasant Shade of Gray (1997)

Genre: Prog Rock

I can always get behind the idea of changing your sound a bit. Fates Warning have slowly done that over the course of several albums, but typically, they will remain a metal band. It's not so apparent in A Pleasant Shade of Grey, in fact I'd go as far as to say it's not a full-on metal album, but rather rock with a couple metal influences. And I'm totally cool with that. I was hoping this album would be one of the absolute berst of its type, but Fates Warning has only impressed me once in that vein out of several albums, so my expectations were closer to the 9/10 vein.

From what I've studied, Fates Warning are basically a top 10 in prog metal as far as popularity and influence goes. Of course, when you're going to tackle prog, you have to be careful that your technical melodies and the harmony of the instruments don't come off as wonky. Part II was fairly guilty of that during the verses, so the first two parts didn't really do much for me musically, despite setting a good preconceived standard for the rest of the album. But it took way too long for me to get to a spot to where I could feel like absorbing an atmosphere, bobbing my head, getting intrigued, etc. Part 5 had a good level of psychedelic intrigue to it, but it simply wasn't strong enough to stand out amongst the masses of prog rock or metal IMO and it didn't justify the wonkiness in the other parts of the song. Things started to feel more fleshed out and make more sense in the second half, featuring better examples of prog that took a few key directions that cemented the second half as superior to the first. But when the band was trying out some metal in the fix, the softer focus of the album got in the way of heaviness, making it feel more like general rock, so while they have every right to make a rockier album, any metal should actually be metal.

it shows this vintage group of prog metal pioneers somehow struggling to maintain proper atmosphere, being more focused on maintaining a softer presence that they only occasionally succeed at. This is also to say that when it was trying to be metal, it wasn't heavy enough. They have every right to change their sound, and this was a pretty good attempt with a few good songs, some interesting technical ideas and a little bit of experimentation that never broke the flow. But sometimes it feels a little empty, and sometimes the rythms are a bit wonky, so the album feels incomplete.

74

Farewell to Tim Cronin, founding member and drummer of the incredible stoner act Monster Magnet.

I'd have to think about this.

1. Blind Guardian - Imaginations from the Other Side

2. Neurosis - Through Silver in Blood

3. Symphony X - Behind Smoke and Mirrors

4. Metal Church - Metal Church

5. Blood Incantation - Starspawn

6. Guns 'N' Roses - Appetite for Destruction

7. Judas Priest - Painkiller

8. Killing Joke - Killing Joke 2003

9. Wuthering Heights - Far from the Madding Crowd

10. Megadeth - Rust in Peace

Way back in 88, John Peel played 3 songs from 3 different SubPop singles in a row, Big Cheese by Nirvana, Trapped by Swallow and Sweet Young Thing Aint Sweet No More by Mudhoney. It didn't have the name grunge back then (or I may have been unaware of it), but this was the dirty guitar sound that I was looking for at that time. I have the Glitterhouse version of Superfuzz Bigmuff EP from 88, that opens with Touch me I'm Sick which is a better opener than the SubPop version, and for me this EP is the sound of grunge along with Bleach and the debut Tad album. I love every bit of it , but especially the opener and the epic closing tune In 'n' Out of Grace. I saw them touring the EP (supporting Sonic Youth who were on the Daydream Nation tour) at Strathclyde University and they were as electric as you imagined. I'm not sure they bettered this EP and the earlier singles, but for me this is a nostalgic 5/5.

A good 9.5 last I heard it and the best Mudhoney so far.  I went on a MAJOR grunge binge early one years ago when I started out as a music buff.  I was a bit more pretentious and rockist back then... but hey, I've gone through a few hundred grunge albums and have dedicatedly sought out rare obscurities everywhere.  For me, the ultimate grunge "sound" belongs to in utero, but it's not quite a perfect albums.  Thanks a lot, "Rape Me."

Well, it's official: I am a Septicflesh nut.  I loved it.

Listening to this again for the purpose of this hall.  Some of these tracks have some major metal energy, pre-NWOBHM technique aside, and it completely appeals to my metal side.  Considering how many different types of metal we get, I feel that it would be unfair to call this just "hard rock."  Apologies, but I'll be voting no for this one.

I've passed this nomination uncontested Andi.

I consider death metal deathcore anyway, so even though I couldn't vote, I pretty much support this.

Also, I support symphonic death metal, being a Septicflesh fan.

Shadow of Intent - Imperium Delerium (2025)

Genres: Deathcore, Melo-Death Metal

There are very few deathcore bands I get excited for, and Shadow of Intent is one of them.  Hell, one of my hottest music takes is that their debut, Primordial, is the best deathcore album I've ever heard, but of course, I've only heard 120 right on the zero.  I'm certain Metal Academy has a quite a few people who've beaten me in that vein.  As far as Shadow of Intent goes, I though their first three albums practically cemented them as the greatest deathcore band in the world, but found myself a little disappointed in the generic fourth, Elegy.  I had no way of knowing where this would go.  All I could do was beg the deathcore gods that Shadow of Intent learned from the experience, and hope for the best.  I mean, it's another 55 MINUTES of deathcore, and it's easy for deathcore to get tiring after 55 minutes.

By the way, let me point out just how grotesquely nerdy I can be: I've been working on a ranked list of every artist I've ever heard.  I'm obsessive, apparently.  I take the top 5 (or bottom five, depending on how often the artist makes good albums), and tally an average.  That's the short version, anyway.  Shadow of Intent has an average of 88.2 out of the top five, including Elegy, and I'm really hoping I can raise that bar today.

Now the issue I had with the last two albums was that the music wasn't quite as diversified as before.  What I loved about Primordial is a careful shift between symphonic metal, deathcore, prog metal and melo-death, a very careful balance on par with the mix of prog, symphonic, neoclassical and power boasted on a couple Symphony X albums.  But if all tracks are doing all of these things, then the diversity caves in on itself.  Now the opener, "Prepare to Die," boasted the majority of these signature traits in a single track with a fixation on symphonics, whereas the follower, "Flying the Black Flag," only barely touched on symphonics and focused mostly on speed and edge.  Taking that as a good sign, I can safely say that both songs were good jams that already proved themselves to be better than the decent but disappointing fourth album, Elegy," and potentially on par with the sophomore, "Reclaimer."  The third track, "Infinity of Horrors," seemed to stylistically be placed between the two songs in terms of sound and genre balance, and I ended up interpreting that as a sign of potential lack of creativity, leaving riffs, melody and speed to the the job, which is fine, but not a perfect situation.  By the fourth track, I was wondering where the prog metal that made the first three so good was?  It was largely absent in place of general speed and riffs.  I had come to know what to expect from this album in the long run, which I was hoping wouldn't happen.

Thankfully, there was a key difference that helped track five, They Murdered Sleep: it was much more crushing with its slower tempo and extra heaviness, so I'll take what I can get from that at least.  With the atmospheric intro of track 6, The Facets of Propaganda, I found myself wishing they would play into the vibes the set up in the intros more often, and thankfully this track did a little of that before returning to the general deathcore form.  But this is also one of the more well composed and catchier tracks, being a bit more thought-provoking on both an atmospheric side and a technical side.  By this point, I just figured, "It's only going to be fairly diversified between songs, so let's just see how generic it does or does not get overtime."  I even got bored with detailing each song, but that's easily because I was hoping for more than "pretty good."  Although, Vehement Draconian Vengeance did a great job showcasing their best abilities with better composition and production, and it already had strong points on both accounts.

In my hopes that Shadow of Intent would improve their game, the only thing I can say right now is that they're in the same league as before, but not the same ballpark.  There were a couple of great songs I can take away from this, but otherwise, it only managed to get Elegy kicked out of the band's top 5 slot on my major list.  It's basically a couple of great hits and some technically-proficient filler with great production.

76.5.  This knocks out Elegy with a score of 72, adding 0.9 to the average score, making it 89.1, raising Shadow of Intent's position from #566 to #522.

Shining - Divided You'll Stand & United You'll Fall (2025)

Genres: Heavy Metal

Yes, I'm tagging this as heavy metal as opposed to black metal, because out of the five songs, only one is black and the other is about halfway there, being the end and the beginning.  Now I'm one for branching out, and there's only so much creativity a man can do writing mostly straightforward (albeit good) DSBM.  But this album didn't really do him any favors.  While branching out, he's still a bit too focused on the vibe of the genre rather than the compositions of the songs, so the most this album really achieves is a couple of decent tunes and a couple mediocre ones.  The strongest things that can be said about this album otherwise are that the production is good and the vocals aren't bad, but it kind of feels like Shining accidentally took a few cues from freakin' Psycho Synner, and compared this so-so work to the works of Psycho Synner to make it look good.

56/100

I was JUST listening to Ropes to Infinity out of the blue yesterday.

That made it to the bottom half of my top 100 when I first heard it.  Might still be there.

It would appear that I’ve rated every one of the releases with over twenty ratings which is perhaps more of an indication that I really should get a life more than anything else.

Do any of us really have lives?

Not being Lynchian here, we're music nerds.

Yello.  We can always use another metalhead here.

You can get a fourth clan by writing reviews in the Clan List Challenges.  Complete a list challenge for each of your clans, then you can joing the Revolution no problem.  Just make sure they're actual reviews and not mere comments and you're good to go.

Only 77 albums so far have a 20+, so I changed the address to minimize it to 19 to see what I could add with my rating.  I only got one to get there, but Iron Maiden's Piece of Mind debuts at #38.

Bringing up 18 to 19, I rated Crack the Skye and Sunbather.  So if anyone wants to add one of these two and hasn't, here's your opportunity to see them debut in the 20+.

Looks like I'll be active in the Sports Countdown on MoFo as well.  Right now I'm on Pride of the Yankees.  So far, the only flaws I can see are that the direction isn't "amazing" but works well enough, and that Cooper's a bit too old for the younger Lou Gherig.  I'm really liking the character drama.  Everyone bounces off each other beautifully.

This is based on the number of their albums in my top 100.

1. Guardians (29) - This was the metal spirit that introduced me to the genre as well as the world.  Songs like Dazed and Confused would influence many later songs that lured me in, oftentimes by bands such as Scorpions or Metallica or Dio.  And then you add the symphonic stuff, much akin to the artist that my father introduced to me at 15: Meat Loaf, changing my world, and suddenly you've got the perfect clan for me.

2. The Fallen (23) - I feel like the Fallen has a bit of an unfair advantage with so many subgenres under its belt, but taking influence from the Sabbath side of things can in fact go a long way.  There's metal that sends lightning through your veins, and then there's the stuff that crushes your soul.  I can't deny that Neurosis had a big say on expanding my metallic horizons.

3. Infinite (19) - While most post-metal hasn't had much of a say in my metal affairs, the progressive and avant-garde stuff is the kind of thing that really gets my brain pumping.  Starting with Dream Theater, I eventually moved to Tool, Symphony X and similar bands, and I especially love how it can move into practically any genre with ease, from power to death.

4. Horde (15) - As with many, my first venture into death metal came through Symbolic, and it wasn't long after until the heaviest shit imaginable was not but pussy to me.  Although there aren't very many death songs or albums I could call favorites, they keep managing to find my way to my top 100 albums

5. North (14) - Sometimes you need to just sit down and embrace the darkness, or the sadness, whichever you prefer.  Folk metal and viking metal are quite fun on their own, but the black metal easily outshines it on my charts.  Nevertheless, Moonsorrow, which encompasses all three, is one of the finest examples of each of the three as well.  It just sends you back in time the way LOTR does.

6. Pit (9) - Thrash was a pretty slow venture.  Believe it or not, when I first heard Master of Puppets and Ride the Lightning, I didn't really get into them beyond a couple songs.  But further ventures into heavy, power and death helped me to overcome that.  Master of Puppets and Ride the Lightning have both spent time as my number 1 metal album of all time, although speed metal struggles to keep up with thrash's output IMO.

7. Gateway (5) - There is very little alternative metal that I'm in love with.  The only example I can think of right now is Dirt by Alice in Chains because I went on many grunge binges in my early days online.  Otherwise, quality alt-metal is something I appreciate critically rather than being engrossed in personally.

8. Revolution (5) - I love almost all kinds of punk.  I went through various binges in a variety of punk genres, but metalcore isn't one of those that I've been able really grip beyond a few key bands.  Especially when the subgenres like deathcore kick in, metalcore's more of a guilty pleasure rather than a serious venture.  Still, I found that alt-metal can be much more imaginative in the whole, hence albums like Lateralus and White Pony.

9. Sphere (1) - Although I consider Killing Joke's Extremities an industrial metal album as well, there is extremely little industrial metal in my chart because much of it gets more monotonous than it needs to be, even the much better ones.

Swans - Birthing (2025)

Genres: Exp. Rock, Post-Rock

Frontman Michael Gira, who practically WAS Swans ever since the band's inception, confirmed that this will be the last of this run of lengthy, atmospheric "big sound" Swans albums.  So I'm expecting a finale as grand as anything that came before, or at least in the league of To Be Kind.  I've heard every Swnas album at least twice, and I may even listen to this twice today depending on my mood just to maintain that statement.  But wehat really makes me happy is how everyone's going every kind of gaga, including Lady Gaga, over this album.  At this point, any small mistake is a disappointment and an insult to their near-indomitable output.

The first thing you may remember about modern Swans is how often they do lengthy, drawn out, atmospheric songs with drone, noise and classical elements.  The first eight minutes of the first 20-minute opener are built on the classical droning.  And if you're a real Swans fan, you can deal with it.  They've gone way longer and way worse on the "repetition" department for no good reason, and then it immediately shifts into a beautifully fitting combo of industrial rock and Lunacy-style noise.  But in this effort to maintain a powerful sonic presence, it does lack melody, which Swans have been known to rock as easily as atmosphere, especially since this song is rooted in several chapters alone.  But most of the songs operate this way, with some fluctuations in distinct genre and sopund but never once breaking its overpowering flow.

So in short, this album is basically a two-hour breather, diversified in nature but more rooted in atmosphere than music.  It certainly hits all the right buttons in the former department, and it was a great way to relieve myself of chore-related stress once all those were done.

92

Oh, shit.  Hope you guys pull through

Tool - "Fear Inoculum" (2019)

Oh, my fucking God! What in the actual fuck is going on here then. This isn't just a contender for the most underrated record of all time. It's EASILY the most underrated record of all time in my opinion. "Fear Inoculum" is the best thing that Tool have ever done as far as I can see & is the culmination of everything that preceded it. The production is utterly spectacular. The performances are as amazing as anything I've ever experienced. Every single note is presented with clear intention & serves its purpose beautifully while the song structures are fully realised, despite their indulgent length. There's more dynamics & a greater focus on atmospherics than ever before with the tension created being so thick you can almost touch it. This one is going right in the middle of my Top 100 Metal Releases of All Time list so I can't possibly fathom how it's been so apathetically received by the vast majority of the global marketplace. I can only put it down to the general impatience that the internet/Spotify age has proliferated over the last couple of decades.

For fans of Karnivool, Soen & Mastodon.

4.5/5

I wouldn't say it's their best, but I agree with most of what's said here.  People who don't like this album don't seem to realize that that band's been slowly merging from an alt-metal band to a prog rock band overtime, which each album steering further away from the roots slightly but surely.  I gave it the same rating.  My guess is that in some years people will warm up to it the way they warmed up to other albums overtime.

It's my opinion that a large portion of the releases tagged as tech death on other websites are mistagged as the understanding of the genre is pretty atrocious these days. For example, the biggest names in tech death are all much better served by the progressive death metal tag (Death, Cynic, Atheist, Pestilence, etc) & the dissonant death metal tag has made the tech death tagging on bands like Gorguts & Ulcerate redundant too. The same can be said of the more brutal acts we're referring to here as labelling Cryptopsy's first couple of releases or the vast majority of Dying Fetus' back catalogue as tech death is stretching the friendship as far as I'm concerned. I'd even extend that to some of the earlier Nile releases like "Black Seeds of Vengeance" & "In Their Darkened Shrines" which only seem to receive the tech death tag due to the speed & brutality of the drumming which is inherent in all brutal death metal so I can't see the need to go there personally. I'd prefer it if the tech death tag was reserved for genuinely technical yet non-progressive bands like Suffocation or Spawn of Possession. 

Personally, I find dissonant death to be its own subgenre rather than an offshoot of death.  Some of it is structured a bit too conventionally.  I mean, Gorguts can keep both, but if it ain't tech it ain't tech.  Now I'll keep the Nile tag, considering that they're my current favorite of this so-called category because of their outlandish elements, incorporating some crypt-crawling doom into the mix.  My review of Darkened Shrines was about as glowing as any review I'd give a good Coppola.  I guess instead of a "subgenre," it's more like a "niche offshoot," though I'd still consider it a bit more relevant than something like "downtempo deathcore."  And of course, most of the brutal stuff only has mild tech to it if any at all.  Can't expect much from the majority of slam, so it's a fine line, especially when some albums by the same acts will be either more tech or more brutal than others.

Here's my new top ten for death, including deathgrind and deathcore.

1. Septicflesh - The Great Mass (Symphonic Death)

2. Morbid Angel - Formulas Fatal to the Flesh (Death)

3. Septicflesh - Communion (Symphonic Death)

4. Nile - In Their Darkened Shrines (Brutal Tech Death)

5. Blood Incantation - Starspawn (Death)

6. Napalm Death - Throes of Joy in the Jaws of Defeatism (Deathgrind)

7. Symbolic - Death (Tech Death)

8. Edge of Sanity - Crimson II (Melodic Death, Prog Death)

9. Gorguts - Colored Sands (Tech Death, Dissonant Death)

10. Shadow of Intent - Melancholy (Deathcore)

The sound that people are calling "thall" is so clearly just a slight variation on djent that I see no real reason to consider it as it won't add much (if any) benefit for our members. My personal preference is to avoid dissecting our music into more & more silly pigeonholes wherever possible. The more we do it, the less variety there is in each subgenre for people to discover. 

Metalcore djent, really?  It should only really be c onsidered a subgenre if it sounds THAT different.  But what with the name origin, this kinda does sound like a "silly pigeonhole."  I use "prog metalcore" as an easy descriptor on my charts, but if it's gonna convince me it's a legit genre, it really has to have a different presence that multiple bands can relate to, not a select few.  I imagine either way, even if Daniel thought this was legit, it would just be ignored anyway because it's one genre falling into two clans.

Arcade Fire - Pink Elephant (2025)

Genres: Indie Rock

I'm actually huge on Arcade Fire, believe it or not.  They introduced me to the glory that is indie rock and were the first steps intro exploring genres beyond classic rock.  Their debut, Funeral, changed my life.  I find their first three albums to be an unbeatable indie trilogy, so I've been holding onto the hope that this Everything Now behavior would end soon.  And it looked like it would from the album WE, but Pink Elephant says otherwise, gruelingly otherwise.

I got excited when I heard there was a new Arcade Fire album, but upon hearing the Year of the Snake single, I lost interest.  This album goes for ambient tracks, indie pop, indie rock and a little alt-dance, neo-psych, and yet, NOTHING is given any real focus.  These songs hardly even feel "written."  They feel like AI generated knockoffs where the order is specifically "try not to use any rhythm."  This is especially painful dureing the songs that are longer than five minutes.  There's barely any melody involved in the instrumentation until Ride or Die, which is seven of the ten tracks in!  How could Arcade Fire of all people forget to include a rhythm?  I mean, I'm willing to defend Everything Now as a palatable pop album, but not this.  The melodies that raised the rating slightly on Ride or Die are once again betrayed just to include some basic sound effects and distortions that fail to justify anything.  I mean, even our two lead singers sound completely bored.  Are the even trying to be passionate about their music anymore?

No, I really don't think they are.  It seems obvious to me that the band has lost their passion and are trying to let ambiance fill in that gap, not realizing that the "gap" is really a "hole in the heart."  This is one time where I really can't defend their actions.  Pink Elephant's very existence is an insult to their glory days and the poopularity of indie rock in the 2000's kickstarted by albums like their first three.  This is the first time I have been unable to defend an Arcade Fire album.

28/100

Blood Incantation - Absolute Everywhere (2024)

Genres: Prog Death Metal

This is it, the conclusion of my Blood Incantation marathon.  This is the album that gave me reason to check them out, and I finally have room for them on my albums log as my need to explore other genres made me late to this party.  A death metal album taking influence from the 70's German rock and electronic scene?  For a wacko like me, that's a dream to good to be true.  But what with all the dick-sucking going around for this album, one can't help but wonder, does it live up to the legend, or is it overhyped?

Immediately the prog rock and prog electronic influences are used as key ingredients in the hyperactive death metal, but the album also makes a point of switching genres mid-song from death metal to prog rock two minutes into Stargate Pt. 1.  I have to admit, while the instrumentation was beyond magnificent, rivaling the best aspects of their incredible debut, the sudden genre switch was a little jarring.  I would've preferred a little more buildup and a little more death in the beginning.  Was this a bad omen, or would I learn to accept that after hearing the rest of the album?  Stargate Pt. 2 was an intriguing and powerful prog electronic track that recalled all the best aspects of Tangerine Dream and Vangelis while remaining a Blood Incantation song, proving that they've mastered the art of electronics after having struggled so much with it on their previous ambient EP, Timewave Zero.  In the last two minutes, it carefully turns into a prog rock song with some beautiful Tullian flute.  Even the last bit of death metal feels pretty naturally handled.  Pt. 3 makes for some fantastic death metal in both technique and production.  There's this middle section of acoustic guitars mimicking the worldbeat vibes of The Tea Party, but it doesn't last long enough, unfortunately.  And some of the electronics that make the album so unique are present at the end, but not for long.

The next epic, the three part Message, begins with a more upbeat, melodic and almost alternative take on death metal, one that recalls the noisy but anthemic and somewhat aquatic atmospheres of Biomech.  But after 50 seconds, they switch back to the same old death metal.  Thankfully, the extremities are met at a capacity I have only ever dreamed about!  They go back to the original format after another 50 seconds or so, which is an interesting take and makes me glad there's more of that new sound involved. But once again, the standard but impressive death metal sound overtakes the balance.  I mean, they're playing some excellent riffs that make me wanna rip my shirt off and fly into the sun with a bottle of whiskey, but shouldn't they take the time to really expand on the new tricks?  Part 2 goes right into the prog rock, pulled right out of the 70's British scene with surprisingly authentic melodies that blend with the death sound on occasion.  It even has vocals that sound way too much like Roger Waters.  But if they could do that all along, then they SHOULD'VE used them a little more in previous tracks to expand on the various tricks they were trying to play.  Still, this one revived both the Pink Floyd prog and the more conventional kind of prog in one go while maintaining the atmospheric strengths of previous Blood Incantation albums.

And then... Part 3 took me by 100% surprise by introducing itself with a power metal riff of all things.  It has a tendency to switch things around though, as, once again, the power metal was not lived up to.  But it DID do an excellent job of maintaining many of the past sounds and tricks at a reasonable balance beyond that while delivering on of their best epics since Vitrification.  This one is easily the most epic-feeling song on the album, recalling the whole spirit of the band and its improved sense of effects and reverberations, as well as Faulk's wonderful drumming.  This song is also an excellent example of how our two guitarists have impeccable synchronization.  All is a relatively perfect harmony until in fades into aquatic sound effects, bringing our epic to a close.

This also closes my epic adventure in the Blood Incantation catalog.  What with this genre-tagging including space rock and Berlin school, I was stunned that a death metal album was finally attempting these things.  It's been 30 years since Emperor put synths in black metal, so an album like this is way late.  However, was it perfect?  While I admire a band for trying to reinvent the genre, there were some areas where the unique tricks and extra genre choices needed a little more balance.  If they fix that on the next album, you may end up having the greatest death metal album in the world.

97

Blood Incantation - Hidden History of the Human Race (2019)

Genres: Tech Death Metal, Prog Death Metal

Although I've heard largely raw praise for this sophomore album by Blood Incantation, there's an ongoing debate as to whether or not this is an improvement over Starspawn.  My immediate thought was that it was due to a change in pace.  Normally, I like changes in pace, but only if the artist keeps the established identity as well.  I had no way of knowing which would reign supreme on this album.

Its opener, Slave Species of the Gods, is absolutely brutal and a little sludgy.  This was obviously going to be a deeper album that before, and I appreciated the stronger focus on heaviness and progression, especially since this means they're attempting a new direction.  However, despite all the skill they put into it, this is a more generic song on the whole.  On Starspawn, the band took all familiar traits of death and maximized the full potential.  There seems to be less trickery on this opener, so hopefully that would be remedied on later tracks.  I had an 18-minute closer to look forward to, after all.  The Giza Power Plant was seven minutes, which would normally leave a lot of room for some new tricks.  But the most it did was switch from a brutal song to a slower and more ambient one for four minutes before ending on the brutal note.  Now this had incredible moments about it, but it was largely boasting things that were done with more creativity on Starspawn.  Track 3, Inner Paths (To Outer Space), goes into a very deep and sombre opening before slowly emerging as a prog metal track in a similar vein to the folk track on Star Spawn, Meticulous Soul Devourment.  Taking MSD's place as the "vibe" track, this one also includes drowned dialogues like in the cut ambient track from Live Vetrification before fully crossing the bridge into prog death metal, and then finally into brutal death, never once losing sight of the balance, pacing or atmosphere, feeling right at home with Giza Power Plant and artistically contradicting Slave Species of the Gods.  Obviously, the intro song is totally outshined, and would've been more properly placed as the second track.

Now it was time for the majesty.  I had full faith that Blood Incantation would amaze me with another nearly 20-minute epic of raw art, but kept the idea of monotony in mind due to the poorly placed intro song's generic behavior.  It was obvious from the start that the heaviness had been improved on.  This is probably their heaviest and most thunderous track, or at least it starts that way.  And let me tell you, it's very good.  They put together something that remains brutal and challenging throughout.  A few surprises wait throughout the eighteen minutes, but that's only a few.  Otherwise, this is simply a great effort technically and production-wise, but I was hoping for something mindblowing.

This sophomore, in my opinion, is a little more generic.  It carries some of the Starspawn weirdness and a few little traces of what's to come on their legendary third album, but otherwise, I'll say it's simply a great way to introduce death metal to someone.  Another great effort on their part, but not five-stars.  Honestly, I wonder if they were simply trying to sell or to get noticed?  They didn't betray their talents, but much of the identity was gone.

93, just like Live Vitrification.

Blood Incantation - Timewave Zero (2021)

Genres: Space Ambient

I've mentioned before that, while I like ambient, I've struggled with it as well.  Even in a slow-paced ambient album, things need to mutate and change for it to draw me in.  A fine example of sluggish non-rock that mutates over a long period of time would be Basinski's Disintegration Loops.  Excellent delivery of its theme.  But if things aren't really going to happen, then I'll lose interest.  Timewave Zero seems to be a good example of how little can happen in an ambient album.

It looks like this was their practice run in developing what would come to be Absolute Everywhere, so a couple of lesser-known failures may be expected, but it would still be nice if this were a good album.  These two long tracks, sometimes separated in four movements depending on the release, are very simple and very "easy."  A band like Blood Incantation likely knows by now that activity is a large part of their identity.  Such rambunctious behavior was made present as early as Demo II (I have yet to find a complete Demo I).  But from hoew easygoing and predictable this 40-minute EP is, it's safe to say that the band decided to make a little extra money by passing off this practice run in the world of space ambient as a release.   Every atmospheric trick they try to pull off might be reminiscent of space, but only because these tricks were perfected with much more originality by the likes of Tangerine Dream.  It finally takes a turn by introducing a guitar melody halfway through the second 20-minute track, and even then it just fades away after a few minutes without changing gears at all.

I'd really have to say that this is the worst of the Blood Incantation releases so far.  I understand that the practice is necessary, but the idea of releasing it was nothing more than a cash grab.  Maybe they'll be much better at the space ambient thing one day, but this practice run is nothing more than that.

58