Bands with stacks of albums that no-one cares about

Ben
Ben
The Fallen The Horde The North The Pit
First Post June 14, 2021 11:42 PM

Is anyone else fascinated by bands that have craploads of albums, despite no-one appearing to care about them, let alone think they're actually good? I always want to know what keeps them going. If I was going to start interviewing bands, I reckon it would be more interesting to interview this sort of band than the ones that everyone knows.

Today's case in point... Paganizer. This Swedish death metal band has 25 releases on Metal Academy, with 11 of them being full length albums. None have more then 67 ratings on RYM and none have more than a 3.33 score. How do they keep going? Why do labels keep putting out their releases? Don't they just make a loss?

To be clear, Paganizer are one of stacks of unknown but prolific bands out there. They're just the latest one I've added to the site.




June 15, 2021 05:20 AM

I've not looked into it in any depth, but would guess this is a relatively recent phenomenon. With the availability of home recording software and internet distribution, such as Bandcamp, it is possible for anyone with the knowledge and skill to issue albums virtually at will. I have seen more than enough evidence of this in the black metal community where some acts treat Bandcamp like some kind of Twitter feed, spewing out their every musical thought no matter the quality.

A band I actually quite enjoy who have released 23 albums in fifteen years, with the highest number of ratings on RYM being 16, is a fellow countryman of yours Ben, who goes by the unfortunate name of The Horn. His weird black metal is all based around the Egyptian Book of the Dead and his is certainly an original voice. What keeps him going is sheer enthusiasm, I'm guessing because he can't make much money from it, although I have bought a CD or two!

June 15, 2021 07:52 AM


Is anyone else fascinated by bands that have craploads of albums, despite no-one appearing to care about them, let alone think they're actually good? 

This sounds so mean, hahaha.

Yeah, I find bands like this interesting. In my experience, when I listen to stuff like this, they usually aren't much worse than big names. They're usually just bands doing stuff that someone else already did better 10 years prior. But hey, if you like the genre/style, it means you've just discovered a nice collection of albums to dig through. I'm not the kind of guy who needs artists to do something innovative or unique to enjoy them so I can have a great time with C list stuff like this. I think especially when the artists come from countries where the music market isn't as competitive, it might be easier to get on a label and get your albums put in local shops/online, and then no one outside that circle will ever find them.


June 15, 2021 11:52 AM

I would suggest that this Stuttgart-based heavy metal band fits the mold to a tee:

https://metal.academy/bands/1272


June 15, 2021 12:02 PM
Amidst the sea of unrated darkness, there is one bright shining spot of reviewed hope. It's right there where you're standing with your Danger Zone review, Daniel!
June 15, 2021 07:10 PM

Another prolific releaser of material is Belgian black metaller and doomster Déhà who has released 19 albums and 6 eps since 2018 under his own name as well as other stuff in projects like Slow, Imber Luminis, Clouds, Yhdarl and Aurora Borealis, to name but five! I haven't listened to them all, but he has released some good stuff, particularly as funeral doom project Slow, black/doom project Imber Luminis and his four album A fleur de peau series under his own name. Highest number of ratings on RYM - 58. Respect to these guys who do it for love not money.

June 16, 2021 12:45 AM

My "Darkness and Hope" quote above reminded me of another Pearls Before Swine comic, which I've also just made a parody of:


June 16, 2021 03:02 AM

BUT WHAT ABOUT THE FROGS??? (267 releases by the way)


Ben
Ben
The Fallen The Horde The North The Pit
June 16, 2021 03:26 AM


BUT WHAT ABOUT THE FROGS??? (267 releases by the way)

Quoted Xephyr

Yeah, I think bands like Phyllomedusa and Déhà are just pumping out digital music without assistance. There are an increasing amount of bands that release multiple releases a year in this fashion. I guess I was more thinking about bands that have released over a dozen full length albums through a label on CD and / or vinyl. That costs money and resources, and I just don't know how they keep convincing labels to keep doing it when they clearly haven't established a sizable fanbase.

Speaking of which, I added Thor to the site on the weekend. Sure, his 1985 album Only the Strong has 230 ratings on RYM, but the next 20 full lengths haven't surpassed 33.

https://rateyourmusic.com/artist/thor

Ben
Ben
The Fallen The Horde The North The Pit
June 16, 2021 03:30 AM

Thanks for reminding me of the frogs Xephyr. That's a couple of days of my life trying to find decent cover images for 267 releases, all of which contain either frogs or trees, that I'll never get back. By far the most difficult artist to add to the site! Buckethead have more releases (340 albums), but at least his covers are interesting.

Ben
Ben
The Fallen The Horde The North The Pit
July 22, 2021 03:07 AM

Here's another band that I just added today: Lucifugum

17 full length albums, with only the debut having more than 52 ratings on RYM. None of the last 11 albums rate higher than 2.78 (if you ignore the most recent album that only has 3 ratings).

I admire their passion and longevity, but what keeps them going?!



July 22, 2021 04:25 PM

I've had a quick look at Lucifugum and it appears that they are a Ukrainian husband and wife duo who own and run the label their albums are released on. So maybe they use black metal as a kind of relationship therapy. "What do you want to do this weekend love? We can go to the garden centre and buy some new patio furniture and a few begonias. Or, if you'd rather, I've been working on a few songs in scorn of the bastard Nazarene, so we could go down to the basement, light a few candles, maybe sacrifice a goat and record a new album. It's completely up to you." 

Ben
Ben
The Fallen The Horde The North The Pit
July 22, 2021 09:57 PM

Haha... I think we can expect a triple CD concept album by the end of COVID.

July 23, 2021 12:54 AM

Lucifugum... That name sounds like a pack of chewing gum made by Lucifer or Satan, like in this Pearls Before Swine comic (and on its 15th anniversary!):


October 30, 2021 08:07 AM

Just looking at some of the albums in the Anniversaries section and one is by a black metal outfit I've never heard of called Ceremonial Castings who have fourteen albums on here with no ratings and a highest number of ratings on RYM of 64 with some in single figures. Judging by the covers, these are professional releases and all are available on CD, although they are released on Dark Forest which apparently was a label founded by one of the band's members. Seven of the fourteen have average ratings of below 3.00 which isn't a good sign either. Might check them out just to see what none of the fuss is about, but they play symphonic black metal which was never one of my preferred genres of BM so maybe too much of a chore. Some of their covers are very good though.

Ben
Ben
The Fallen The Horde The North The Pit
April 28, 2022 10:33 PM

The latest addition to Metal Academy of a band that has stacks of releases that no-one's ever heard of is... Transmetal. This Mexican death / thrash band has no less than 26 full length albums! Only one of those albums has over 50 ratings on RYM, being El infierno de Dante from 1993. They must have a following in Mexico, as they also have a bunch of live and compilation releases. Anyone willing to give them a listen?


April 29, 2022 12:43 AM

Apparently El infierno de Dante has Glenn Benton on a couple of tracks, so they must at least have grabbed his attention somewhere - maybe a support band from a Deicide Mexican tour? Benton's presence here is probably why that is the most popular of their albums.

April 29, 2022 05:17 PM

Iron Attack! from Japan have (listed on RYM) 59 full length albums, none breaching 50 ratings (as of now). I have heard almost 40 of them! And they are all strong, solid pieces of Neoclassical Power Metal. Some have J-Pop style vocals while others are purely instrumental. I don't expect you to add all of these to Metal Academy... but I wouldn't be complaining!

Ben
Ben
The Fallen The Horde The North The Pit
May 03, 2022 10:08 PM


Iron Attack! from Japan have (listed on RYM) 59 full length albums, none breaching 50 ratings (as of now). I have heard almost 40 of them! And they are all strong, solid pieces of Neoclassical Power Metal. Some have J-Pop style vocals while others are purely instrumental. I don't expect you to add all of these to Metal Academy... but I wouldn't be complaining!

Quoted SilentScream213

Was that a challenge? That sounded like a challenge! :yum:

May 03, 2022 10:35 PM

That was definitely a challenge!!

Ben
Ben
The Fallen The Horde The North The Pit
May 05, 2022 12:52 AM

I've already spent over an hour on this challenge, and all I've got to show for it is a list of releases. It has taken all of my Batman detective skills to discover release catalogue IDs so that I make sure I don't miss anything. I've also attempted to translate all titles into English to keep things consistent. I've only failed with one, being 秘封奇塊遺産 1 , for which the best attempt I can make translates to Secret Lump Heritage 1. Somehow I don't think that's correct, although the Japanese can be wonderfully weird at times.

So now I just need to find high quality artwork for all 80 releases (I won't be adding the single or the split), format them all to 1000 x 1000 while removing any obvious blemishes I discover, then add them all to the site one by one.

If the above gives you the impression that I'm not enjoying myself, you're wrong. I love this shit!


MIA001 Metal God Knows… SINGLE

MIA002 Blave Heart EP 2007 29/04/2007

MIA003 Unleashed in the East Album 2007 17/08/2007

MIA004 Iron Attack! Album 2007 24/12/2007

MIA005 Evil Mountain Album 2007 31/12/2007

MIA006 Cave Attack! Album 2008 9/03/2008

MIA007 Blade of Ancient Temple SPLIT 2008 25/05/2008

MIA008 Dead Heat Refrain Album 2008 16/08/2008

MIA009 Devil's Daughter Album 2008 13/10/2008

MIA010 Thunder Concert Album 2008 30/12/2008

MIA011 Savage Flames Album 2009 8/03/2009

MIA012 Sparking Album 2009 5/05/2009

MIA013 Far East Judgement Album 2009 15/08/2009

MIA014 Crying Destiny Album 2009 11/10/2009

MIA015 Miss Understanding Album 2009 30/12/2009

MIA016 Vampire Concerto Album 2010 14/03/2010

MIA017 Best Collections Compilation 2010 5/05/2010

MIA018 Black History Compilation 2010 5/05/2010

MIA019 Arashi No Hurricane Album 2010 14/08/2010

MIA020 Pre-Historic Eruption Album 2010 11/10/2010

MIA021 Poltergeist Album 2010 30/12/2010

MIA022 Concerto of the Scarlet Elements Album 2011 13/03/2011

MIA023 Angel Mountain Album 2011 13/08/2011

MIA024 Bullet Wind Album 2011 16/10/2011

MIA025 Deamon's Seal Album 2011 30/12/2011

MIA026 STAR DUST Album 2012 27/05/2012

MIA027 Guitar Odyssey - Instrumental Best Compilation 2012 11/08/2012

MIA028 Sailing Destiny - Vocal Best Compilation 2012 11/08/2012

MIA029 Paper Moon Album 2012 7/10/2012

MIA030 Burn in Hell Album 2012 30/12/2012

MIA031 Heaven's Sword Album 2013 26/05/2013

MIA032 Plastic Mind Album 2013 12/08/2013

MIA033 Fairy Tale Album 2013 13/10/2013

MIA034 Thundercrack Album 2013 30/12/2013

MIA035 Sail Up EP 2013 30/12/2013

MIA036 Artemis Album 2014 27/04/2014

MIA037 Scarlet Furor Album 2014 11/05/2014

MIA038 Icicle Fall Album 2014 16/08/2014

MIA039 Sentimental Symphonia Album 2014 12/10/2014

MIA040 Raise a Flag Album 2014 29/12/2014

MIA041 Dim.Starlight Album 2014 29/12/2014

MIA042 Takasago Army Album 2015 26/04/2015

MIA043 Death and Rebirth Album 2015 10/05/2015

MIA044 Star Dust Memory Compilation 2015 14/08/2015

MIA045 Sister of Puppets Compilation 2015 14/08/2015

MIA047 Shanghai Moutan Album 2015 30/12/2015

MIA048 Triumph Album 2015 30/12/2015

TRNA-10012 Sangoku Attack! Album 2016 20/01/2016

MIA049 Space Galaxy Album 2016 24/04/2016

MIA050 Bullet Blitz Album 2016 8/05/2016

MIA051 Twilight Under World Album 2016 13/08/2016

MIA052 Takasago Army 2 Album 2016 13/08/2016

MIA053 Uchu to Fantasy Album 2016 9/10/2016

MIA054 Perpetual Nightmare Album 2016 29/12/2016

MIA055 Power and Glory Album 2016 29/12/2016

MIA056 80's Graffiti Album 2017 30/04/2017

MIA057 Keep Your Faith Album 2017 7/05/2017

MIA058 The Hard Facts of the Scary Touhou world Album 2017 11/08/2017

MIA059 Spirit of Shumshu - Battle of Shumshu Album 2017 16/08/2017

MIA060 Mystique Concerto Album 2017 15/10/2017

MIA061 Holy Krieg - Crimson Axis Album 2017 29/12/2017

MIA062 Demon City Fantasy Story Album 2017 29/12/2017

MIA063 80's Graffiti 2 Album 2018 29/04/2018

MIA064 The Seventh Sin Album 2018 6/05/2018

MIA065 Unknown Flowers Album 2018 10/08/2018

MIA066 Iserness Kreuz Album 2018 10/08/2018

MIA067 Future and Past Album 2018 14/10/2018

MIA068 Illusion Crisis Album 2018 30/12/2018

MIA069 Deutschland's Advance Album 2018 30/12/2018

MIA070 秘封奇塊遺産 1 Album 2019 5/05/2019

MIA071 Red Justice Album 2019 12/08/2019

MIA072 Blue Faith Album 2019 12/08/2019

MIA073 Japonism Album 2019 6/10/2019

MIA075 Follow the Destiny Album 2019 31/12/2019

MIA074 Daitoa Holy War Album 2020 31/12/2019

MIA076 Labyrinth with Vampire Album 2020 22/03/2020

MIA077 Little Daybreaker Album 2020 5/05/2020

MIA078 Perfume of Silence Album 2020 11/10/2020

MIA079 No Loser, No Winner Album 2021 21/03/2021

MIA080 Maze of Gradation Album 2021 24/10/2021

MIA081 Flame of Deliverance Album 2022 24/03/2022

May 05, 2022 05:10 AM

There are some fantastic album titles there Ben: Cave Attack!, Pre-Historic Eruption, Bullet Wind, Holy Krieg - Crimson Axis and my favourite The Hard Facts of the Scary Touhou world!

I may have to check some of these out...

...[edit] OK, after checking out a couple of tracks on Hard Facts of the Scary Touhou world, I don't think I'll be delving any further. I'll be charitable and say it just isn't for me. It puts me even more in awe of your unswerving tenacity and dedication though Ben!

Ben
Ben
The Fallen The Horde The North The Pit
May 05, 2022 06:40 AM

Because I know you're all desperate to get an update on my Iron Cross project, I've managed to find decent quality images for all of them. Rest assured that all 79 releases will be on Metal Academy in time for the weekend!


May 05, 2022 09:44 AM

While there are a couple metal projects with a lot more releases, that's probably the biggest amount of anime cover arts I've ever seen from a metal band.:heart_eyes::see_no_evil: