January 2025 Feature Release - The Revolution Edition

So just like that we find that a new month is upon us which of course means that we’ll be nominating a brand new monthly feature release for each clan. This essentially means that we’re asking you to rate, review & discuss our chosen features for no other reason than because we enjoy the process & banter. We’re really looking forward to hearing your thoughts on our chosen releases so don’t be shy.

This month’s feature release for The Revolution has been nominated by myself. It's the 1997 "In the Memory Of..." debut album from Melbourne-based Christian metalcore outfit Callous, a band that were often floating around the scene during the latter stages of my time playing in metal bands but whose recorded output I've not taken the opportunity to check out until now. It's interesting that they shared members with extreme metal bands Mortification & Paramaecium at various stages in their evolution. Please join me in assessing the merits of this underground release from the early days of the metalcore movement in Australia.

https://metal.academy/releases/56500

Here's my review:

As some of you have probably realized over the last year or so, my taste in the more conventional brand of metalcore tends to lean quite heavily towards the 1990's as I'm firmly of the belief that the metalcore scene has largely lost its direction in more recent times with most of the hardcore influence that defined the genre having now been lost, rendering the genre title almost completely redundant at this point. I mean, I can't honestly believe that many hardened punks get all that much out of the modern-day melodic metalcore record with its crisp production & technically precise performances, not to mention the generic, cookie-cutter vocals that sound virtually indistinguishable from the last metalcore record you listened to. I'm not saying that people shouldn't enjoy that stuff as it certainly has its positives. What I'm trying to say is that, outside of the vocal style, it has very little to do with hardcore punk which is kinda the point now, isn't it? Anyway... that's the reason that most of my time in The Revolution clan is spent seeking out unheralded gems from the early scene &, to be fair, it's been a fairly rewarding exercise of late. Over the last few months my attentions have been directed towards the earlier examples of the metalcore sound to come out of my home country of Australia, partially because I was in & around the live metal scene at the time & had some exposure to some of the bands it contained. One artist whose name I saw floating around the Melbourne scene at the time was Callous, a band that was partially formed by past & current members of some of the more extreme Melbourne metal bands I was listening to at the time, namely Christian death metallers Mortification & underrated doom/death exponents Paramæcium. On paper that idea has always seen my curiosity being tweaked so I've had Callous' sole 1997 album "In the Memory of..." on my list for many years now & it's time to finally see what these guys have to offer.

"In the Memory of..." was one of the very first full-length metalcore albums recorded in Australia but you'd never know it as it's a very professionally composed & executed piece of art in its own right. The production is excellent for a self-released debut with the accomplished song-writing benefiting from a bright & attractive production job. The guitars are right upfront in the mix & hit you across the face in just the right way while the rhythm section offers plenty of bottom-end depth. The vocals are suitably vicious too which is a big drawcard for Callous, even if you will have to overcome one obvious obstacle if you're to fully appreciate this record. That's right, it's the unapologetically Christian lyrics which can sound pretty preachy at times. Thankfully, I've never been one to worry too much about what a band is going on about in my metal music but even I found myself struggling to hold back a cringe through a few of the tracks from the B side so if that's a real deal-breaker for you then don't say I didn't warn you.

The Callous sound is made up of a few different components but I think it's fair to say that it mainly sits somewhere between metalcore & hardcore punk so the use of the metallic hardcore tag I see being used across the internet these days is just about spot on. This record sounds a little bit more flashy than your average hardcore record with the guitars have a cleaner & more metallic sound but many of these songs are built around what are more or less open-string hardcore riffs. There's a little more melody included than you'd generally expect from hardcore too though with tracks like "Lost Hope" & "Twice Begun" feeling as much like alternative metal as metalcore to tell you the truth. Through the back half of the album you'll also notice the band taking a little more creative license with their arrangements by veering over towards post-hardcore for brief periods. I appreciate the effort but feel that Callous are at their best when they're at their nastiest so I tend to gravitate towards the more traditional hardcore-based numbers, even more so than the chuggier metalcore material.

The tracklisting is very consistent & one gets the impression that the various band members that made up Callous had already paid their dues over a number of years because there's a class to their delivery that I find quite attractive & which leaves me of the belief that they were probably incapable of producing anything that was noticeably subpar at this point. In saying that, the tracklisting does seem to look like an inverted bell curve when you look at it in fine detail. The best material is loaded towards the front & end of the album with the first four songs getting things off to an excellent start. The weaker material is still pretty decent though so it's not a major big deal but you'll certainly notice when things pick up again for closer "No Apologies" & the excellent hidden track which should definitely have been better highlighted by inclusion in the proper tracklisting given that it's one of my favourite songs overall.

While "In the Memory of..." may not be the most memorable metalcore record you'll ever hear, it was certainly a fine way to kick off a recording career, particularly given that it was self-released. It's a shame that Callous didn't go on to much in the future. To be honest, this album was very close to a four-star rating & it was only the slight drop in quality through the middle of the album that saw it falling just short. Still... it's a travesty of justice that this release has seen so little publicity over the years because I'd take it over some of the more widely acknowledged 90's metalcore records like Earth Crisis' "All Out War", Converge's "Petitioning The Empty Sky" or Arkangel's "Prayers Upon Deaf Ears", not to mention Aussie metalcore godfathers Mindsnare's 1995 debut E.P. "Under Fire". I can only think that it was Callous' religious messaging that cost them greater commercial success which is a real shame & yet another blemish on the record of the Christian faith.

For fans of Mindsnare, Day of Contempt & Ultimatum.

3.5/5

This 1997 album appears to be the only release from the Aussie hardcore punk / metalcore outfit, which is a great shame because this was a genuine surprise and I enjoyed it massively. I don't know what "real" metalcore fans think of it because, to my ears, this sounds first and foremost like a punk album with a metallic guitar sound, which is no problem to me at all. I'm not a large consumer of metalcore, but one of my bugbears with it being that so many of the modern bands sound alike and I have real trouble telling both the bands and their songs apart. But because of the marked punk component, this has a lot more character than some of the more modern metalcore bands I have listened to. In fact I am not even sure that some of the punk component even counts as hardcore, sounding catchy and melodic, more like second wave UK punk acts like Angelic Upstarts or Anti-Nowhere League, although elsewhere they do have a Minor Threat vibe going on. One of my favourite punk albums is Suicidal Tendencies' debut (their best by a country mile) and I found that springing to mind several times whilst listening to this. I must admit I didn't even realise that Callous were a christian-themed band until reading Daniel's review but, to be honest, I don't care one way or the other because I am more interested in the abrasive timbre of the vocal performance than the actual lyrics themselves and it still sounds pissed off and angry, no matter the lyrical content. In fact, let's face it, some of the straight-edge punks could be even more preachy than any christian act are ever likely to be.

I think that ultimately "In the Memory Of..." appeals to me so much because it has a strong individuality and character due to it having such a prominent early punk influence - a trait which is often just vestigial in more modern metalcore, leaving it often sounding very samey with everyone wanting to be Converge. Sadly it seems that most genres tend towards conformity at some point - and even punk itself fell into that trap with the endless stream of cookie-cutter skate / pop punk acts that proliferated in the wake of Green Day and Bad Religion's early success. If I am going to explore metalcore further with any chance of satisfaction, then I guess these earlier days of the genre are the best place for me to start.

4/5