Review by illusionist for Agalloch - The Mantle (2002)

A benchmark of twentieth century ART

The Mantle blends traces of black metal, acoustic folk, and post-rock in a way unlike anything else I have heard or ever will hear again. Bergtatt: Et eeventyr i 5 capitler, an album I adore equally, is the closest possible comparison, but Agalloch's crown jewel shines a different hue than Ulver's. They build atmosphere the most effective way in metal: by utilizing each instrument to reflect their emotions (no immersive synths or try-hard 'concepts' needed). For a work with such minimalist tendencies, the atmosphere is crushingly thick. This album is a journey front-to-back, constantly weaving a texture so unique yet so tangible that you have no choice but to drown in it every time it graces your ears. It is cold and frostbitten, yet with a core of warmth to it deep inside...like a dying fire on a winter night. You will feel like a solitary wanderer timelessly traversing desolate, snowy woodlands like the elk on the front cover. At other times, you will be empowered by waves of stunningly gorgeous soundscapes. There is a mysterious allure that resides in Agalloch’s second album. It is difficult to grasp with words, but whatever it is...it's special. It is albums like this that make music worth exploring, sharing and reviewing. These songs will be the soundtrack to my melancholy winter days for years to come.