Review by Shadowdoom9 (Andi) for Poppy - I Disagree (2020)
From surreal performance art YouTuber to experimental popstar to metal screamer, Poppy, born Moriah Rose Pereira, has revolutionized both the internet and music scene. However, I've barely encountered any of her work, only knowing her collaborations with her highly acclaimed collaborations with Bad Omens and Knocked Loose. So now it's time for me to dive into her diverse world...
Her 3rd album I Disagree marked her transition from electropop into experimental alt-metal. The album's themes are empowerment and destroying the destroyer. It's clear that a lesson to learn is to disagree with life's conventionalities that can drag you down.
"Concrete" shows Poppy reinventing the pop metal wheel, by combining anime-style electropop with metal shredding. Two different worlds collide as catchy hooks battle against brutal breakdowns. At one point, an audience chants her name which then leads to a pop rock bridge and the last of the metal shredding. Truly an energetic banger! Then the title track shows more of her creativity. The chorus is quite playful as Poppy sings like an angel, telling us to "let it all burn down, burn it to the ground". After which, her devil side strikes back against her manipulative ex-collaborator Titanic Sinclair, "I disagree with the way you continue to pressure me". She can burn away her abusive past and walk away without batting an eye. "Bloodmoney" takes on some electro-industrial, leaning into a bit of hardcore dubstep.
The electronic side continues on in "Anything Like Me", which also drifts into cacophonic metal and continues the directly empowering lyrics, "sorry for what I’ve become, because I'm becoming someone." Then "Fill the Crown" encourages liberty for all, "you can be anyone you want to be, you can be free". The edition of this album I'm reviewing includes a bonus cover of "All the Things She Said" by t.A.T.u., and interestingly enough, this is one of my favorite tracks here, fitting in the "metalizing covers" category by adding in dark alt-/industrial metal drama while staying true to the original. If that isn't Poppy's most emotional moment, I don't know what is! After that, "Nothing is Need" dives into dreamy soft pop, like something Ariana Grande would make. There's not much metal there, unless you count some lead guitar melodies. As a heavier listener, I find that one bland, though not a total disaster.
Poppy can let her ideas run loose in "Sit/Stay" with lyrics against having to obey like an animal. She wants to show that she is an independent individual and motivates us to have that same feeling of freedom. Then we have the explosive "Bite Your Teeth" with its straight-on metallic energy. "Sick of the Sun" is one of the more ethereal tracks here. 6-minute closing epic "Don't Go Outside" has a soft acoustic intro, and... I know this album fits well as an alt-metal release, but this track is the closest to that genre, maybe even the post-grunge style my brother likes. The music and lyrics revisit many of the earlier tracks, most notably the title track, "Let it all burn down, we'll be safe and sound".
I Disagree is a fine example of the experimental creativity Poppy has, expanding the boundaries of modern music. Although it's too poppy (no pun intended, maybe) for me to listen to on a regular basis, she deserves some great appreciation from fans. And we will disagree with the haters....
Favorites: "Concrete", "I Disagree", "Anything Like Me", "All the Things She Said", "Bite Your Teeth", "Don't Go Outside"