Review by Shadowdoom9 (Andi) for Megadeth - United Abominations (2007)
A friend of mine shared with me a couple tracks from this album, and they sound good enough to check out the rest of what it has to offer, as well as make another dive into one of Megadeth's albums. How does it compare to a classic like Peace Sells? Let's find out...
United Abominations marked the entrance of the Drover brothers; guitarist Glen and drummer Shawn. They were the founding members of power metal band Eidolon. But months after the release of this album, Glen left Megadeth to focus on family life, which also caused Eidolon to disband, apart from a 2015 reunion show and single. Those brothers knew how to add catchiness and heaviness to the less thrashy riffing the band had for 15 years up to that point. Freshness was added to the otherwise mundane.
"Sleepwalker" opens the album as a heavy yet melodic standout, as the snarls of frontman Dave Mustaine soar through the verses. The thrashy riffs and leads last heard in Rust in Peace are in full force, as is the tempo variation. All in an honorable highlight! What's next is "Washington is Next", which picks up some fast speed in the riffs and drums, while having some Maiden-powered melody, especially in the chorus that adds to the energy. The earlier speedy riffing is blended with the 1990 technical shredding. There are some decent choruses in "Never Walk Alone... A Call to Arms", but it's much more suitable for the radio.
The title track is the first of the two songs my friend showed me, which is fine, but the chorus is too repetitive to do any good. The second of those songs, "Gears of War" is a slower heavy/melodic composition with a brighter chorus. I like that one more. "Blessed are the Dead" is where Mustaine's vocals often get deeper or less gravelly. The song once again has the band's 90s hard rock/metal sound. "Play for Blood" has the groove-ish riffing of Symphony X, but none of that band's epic orchestration.
"A Tout le Monde (Set Me Free)" is a re-recording of a song from the band's 1994 album Youthanasia. This edition has greater energy and guest vocals by Cristina Scabbia from gothic/alt-metal band Lacuna Coil. Honestly, this is the kind of re-recording we need, one that enhances the song with a guest vocalist. Well done! "Amerikhastan" follows as an unnecessary attempt at a political attack, and it's hard for me to listen to it without cringing in disgust. We get one more memorable track in "You're Dead", reviving the early 90s thrash discretely yet pleasantly. "Burnt Ice" has impressive riffing that is sadly practically obscured by everything else. A strong yet uneven wrap-up.
All in all, United Abominations is a pretty good album with some weak moments. I suppose one day I can check out one of their surrounding albums like The System Has Failed or Endgame, maybe even another one of their earlier classics. But for now, I can savor the more high-quality moments of this album, helped out by the Drover brothers. Shawn would still stick around for the next few chapters of this journey of Megadeth....
Favorites: "Sleepwalker", "Washington is Next", "Gears of War", "A Tout le Monde (Set Me Free)", "You're Dead"