Hypocrisy - The Fourth Dimension (1994)^{Release ID: 5173}

Hypocrisy add a melodic element to their death metal and create a varied and entertaining album.

The Fourth Dimension is really the link between the straight-ahead death metal of Osculum Obscenum and the melodic brilliance of Abducted. While I can't say I think all that much of Hypocrisy's first two albums, their melodic albums during the mid to late 90s are really entertaining. The Fourth Dimension sits somewhere in between, and I rate it accordingly. There are still tracks where the Swedes just play (admittedly powerful) no bells and whistles death metal, but then there are much more interesting slower, atmospheric tracks such as Apocalypse, Slaughtered and the title track.

The band switch between these styles throughout the 13 tracks and I have to say it makes for a thoroughly enjoyable affair, even if the band still needed to iron out a few areas at this point. In particular, the leads are still average, and the drumming is at times extremely pedestrian. But on the positive side, the lyrics have improved a lot since the very immature work on earlier albums, and the production is much cleaner, which suits this more structured performance a lot better. Peter takes over all vocals for this album too for the first time with the departure of Masse Bromberg and his screams and growls work perfectly well.

All up I'd say this is the first Hypocrisy album that I feel is worth adding to your collection. It's the first album that gives an insight towards the heights the band would reach in the oncoming years and a solid and reasonably consistent effort. Highlight tracks for me are Apocalypse, Reincarnation and the title track, but there is plenty to like among the 53 minutes of death metal on The Fourth Dimension.

While the early releases from Swedish death metallers Hypocrisy may not have changed my life, they did offer me a fair amount of enjoyment as a young fella during the early 1990's. I'd first discovered them through their 1992 debut album "Penetralia" which Neuropath vocalist Mark Wangmann had brought to my attention shortly after it was released & I'd subsequently followed them through their 1993 sophomore album "Osculum Obscenum" & 1994 "Inferior Devoties" E.P., both of which had performed a similar role in providing a fairly traditional brand of death metal that stayed largely within the limited capabilities of the various band members. "Inferior Devoties" had seen Hypocrisy further reducing their lineup from the five-piece they originally started as though with band leader Peter Tägtgren (Pain/Bloodbath/Lindemann/Lock Up/The Abyss/War) taking over the vocal duties from original front man Masse Broberg (Dark Funeral/Demonoid/Obscurity/Witchery) on top of his existing guitar & keyboard responsibilities which would see Hypocrisy going to market as a trio for the first time. They must have liked the simplicity it provided them with as the Swedes would return with that same lineup for 1994's "The Fourth Dimension" third album, a record that is known as being somewhat of a transitional record for Hypocrisy & one that I remember fairly fondly. A recent read of Ben's review of "The Fourth Dimension" has seen my interest being renewed though as Ben expressed that this record was somewhat of a step up for Tägtgren & co. with the adjustments that had been made to the more traditional Hypocrisy sound being most welcome. Let's see if I feel similarly then, shall we?

"The Fourth Dimension" was recorded & mastered at Park Studio in Stockholm during March & April of 1994 with Tägtgren once again handling the production duties as he had on all of Hypocrisy's previous releases. Those first three records all sound a little different from each other but there seems to be a feeling amongst fans that "The Fourth Dimension" sports a cleaner sound in terms of production. I see things a little differently though & would actually suggest that Hypocrisy's third full-length sounds a little weaker than the Swedes first two records with the murkier guitar tone not really complementing the powerful bottom-end of rhythm section, although it admittedly works better than it might have due to the slower tempo range that Hypocrisy tend to work within compared to their earlier work. Tägtgren had handled the vocals on several tracks from the band's earlier releases so he doesn't sound completely foreign here but I do have to mention that I prefer Broberg's more sinister tone over his deeper & slightly more gutteral growls which don't summon as much darkness & energy as his predecessor.

There's been a lot said about Hypocrisy's transition from a very conventional death metal sound to a far more Swedish melodic death metal one over the years with "The Fourth Dimension" most often described as the link between the two but, while I'm not disputing that theory, I will say that it's a fairly narrow-minded view to claim Hypocrisy's third album as a genuine melodeath release because it's not nearly as simple as that. You see, Hypocrisy tackle a few different sounds across the thirteen-song track-listing with classic death metal, melodeath & a slower doom/death style all receiving a decent airing. The album is bookended by the two excellent doom/death tracks in "Apocalypse" & the title track, both which form the highlights of the album along with the beautifully executed neoclassical darkwave closer "The Arrival of the Demons". That's right folks, the slower tempos & more atmospheric soundscapes employed here actually work very well for Hypocrisy & are somewhat of a highlight of the record. The remainder of the album sees the band switching quite regularly between their conventional death metal sound & the more melodic one their countrymen had been making into a national calling card at around this time. Unlike many punters though, I'm gonna have to bring things back to reality a bit by stating that this is still more of a death metal record than it is a melodeath one. In fact, I don't even think there's enough melody here to justify a dual primary tag & are comfortable for Hypocrisy to maintain their traditional death metal status at this point in their recording career. I feel that the fact that most of the more melodic material appears during the early parts of the album has certainly played a role in people incorrectly tarnishing "The Fourth Dimension" with the melodeath brush (depending on your preferences of course).

Given the dalliances with extra melody though, it was perhaps inevitable that I'd struggle with parts of "The Fourth Dimension". In fact, I'm gonna have to suggest that it was Hypocrisy's least consistent record to the time with the quality levels fluctuating as often as the band's stylistic direction did. You could easily respond to those claims with statements about my affiliations to the melodeath subgenre & I'd face a serious challenge in attempting to defend my position as there's no doubt that the more melodic A side is where I see my attention wavering. Thankfully there are a couple of the best tracks on the album (see "Apocalypse" & "Black Forest") mixed in with the flatter material during the early stages of the record but the B side is noticeably heavier which appeals to my taste profile much more than the more open & commercially accessible song structures presented on tracks like "Mind Corruption", "Reincarnation" or "Never to Return". It's not that I mind the reduced tempos & greater focus on atmospherics. In fact, I really enjoy those attributes when they're done well. It's more that the more melodic material sounds a little basic & lacking in sophistication which could perhaps be explained by Hypocrisy's still fairly limited technical abilities which are left more visible by the more open structures. Tägtgren's vocals aren't as unique as Broberg's either & I find them to be merely serviceable than they do genuinely engaging.

Despite these failings, I can't deny that there's still plenty to enjoy about "The Fourth Dimension", particularly during the back end of the album which tends to drag it out of the mire that I felt it would almost certainly end up in during parts of the record. I can't agree with Ben's statements about this being the first Hypocrisy release that's worthy of your purchase though as I actually think it was the Swedes weakest full-length to that time with their more US-inspired debut "Penetralia" still (perhaps unsurprisingly) being my pick of the three. I don't think this just comes down to the added melody though folks. While Hypocrisy may have expanded their repertoire a little with "The Fourth Dimension", they hadn't necessarily nailed those adjustments which leaves it feeling a little patchy as an holistic artistic statement. The first two Hypocrisy albums may have been less ambitious but I feel that they were more consistently successful at what they were trying to achieve, even if neither should be considered to be essential listening for our The Horde members either. 

For fans of Kataklysm, At the Gates & Bloodbath.