Tristania - Ashes (2005)Release ID: 3363
So while I can't say I'm a Tristania "fan," I certainly appreciate how they've more or less become the kind of band I was looking for by the third album: a band that was willing to try a bunch of new things and differentiate songs. The way I see it, a band good at multiple genres is a band with multiple talents, and I prefer a band with multiple talents over a band with one talent. And of course, I'd like for it to show on a full album time and time again. Although struggling with this on their first two albums, Tristania mastered this personality aspect on their third, and continued it on Ashes.
Ashes sees a dramatic shift from the symphonic sound in the long run. The entire purpose of this album is to morph songs from genre to genre by using mood to keep the flow intact. This album succeeds at this in every aspect, and may even be better at this than the previous album where they finally nailed the craft. We have instances of symphonic blending with atmpsheric ethereal wave to bring out Tristania's strong gothic presence while still maintaining a metal edge as we see influences ranging from death metal to metalcore. And it all fits the sadness and anger of this work.
However, while a part of me would like to give an album like that five stars, there are two major problems getting in the way of that. First of all, one of the strongest aspects of World of Glass, the previous album, was that the vocal melodies and the instrument's melodies paired together beautifully despite being so different. There is much less melody here in the vocals, leaving the instruments to deliver many beautiful melodies. On top of that, the production is a little fuzzier, slightly drowning the vocals.
I think this is a well made album for its strengths, and it continues exactly what I wanted to see from Tristania in a diversity aspect. But its flaws are pretty obvious. Otherwise, this is an album where Tristania rely on their personality, and it makes for a good release in need of remastering.
