The Gateway

After giving this another spin alongside White Pony for comparison, I have to slightly retract my first statement and align more with Daniel, even though I still don't think it's worthy of 4.5/5 praise. Ohms is definitely a modernization of their style and while I may have missed the stepping stone considering I haven't checked out Koi no Yokan, it's definitely a bit more than "just another Deftones album". It's much cleaner and tighter than White Pony, and while I think that makes it a bit less interesting overall, I also think that the mixing and balance of this album falls more in line with what I like. Although White Pony has this sort of unhinged and in-your-face atmosphere, most of that comes from Moreno's moans and breathing being piped directly into the listener's eardrums at all points in time. Ohms is more moderate and puts the mixing right in the pocket of where Deftones' sound probably should be, for better or worse. There are some tracks that go back to the older sound, like the beginning of "This Link Is Dead" and "The Spell of Mathematics", but it's not a constant assault. The synth experimentation also fits in really well, never feeling like it's out of place. It also should be noted that there are some hefty riffs in this one that are great as standalone features instead of always being accented by the vocals like White Pony tended to do. "Genesis", "Urantia", and "Headless" all have great chuggy riffs that hit harder than most of their previous material. 

So yeah, I think I wrote this one off a bit too soon. It's still a Deftones album, but it's a good Deftones album. Not good enough for me to bump it up to a 4/5, but I came around to it after a few more listens. 

https://open.spotify.com/playlist/1DUv4IxpnMgxgJOwvgRY0N?si=7H55Qh5SSeaSnOsLLvC8Ng

Tracklisting:

01. earthtone9 – “Star Damage For Beginners” (from “arc’tan ‘gent”, 2000)

02. Korn – “Blind” (from “Korn”, 1994)

03. Rage Against The Machine – “Killing In The Name” (from “Rage Against The Machine”, 1992)

04. Living Colour – “Bless Those (Little Annie’s Prayer)” (from “The Chair In The Doorway”, 2009)

05. Faith No More – “Evidence” (from “King For A Day, Fool For A Lifetime”, 1995)

06. Katatonia – “Lacquer” (from “City Burials”, 2020)

07. Primus – “John The Fisherman” (from “Frizzle Fry”, 1990)

08. Soundgarden – “Rusty Cage” (from “Badmotorfinger”, 1991)

09. Alice In Chains – “Would?” (from “Dirt”, 1992)

10. Dir en Grey – “Vinushka” (from “Uroboros”, 2008)

11. Waltari – “So Fine” (from “So Fine!”, 1994)

12. Puya – “Oasis” (from “Fundamental”, 1999)

13. Fleshwater – “This, If Anything” (from “Demo” E.P., 2020)

14. Armia – “Poza prawem” (from “Ultima Thule”, 2005)

15. Sevendust – “Praise” (from “Animosity”, 2001)

16. Issues – “Coma” (from “Headspace”, 2016)

17. Tool – “Schism” (from “Lateralus”, 2001)

18. Deftones – “Diamond Eyes” (from “Diamond Eyes”, 2010)

19. Five Point O – “Double X Minus” (from “Untitled”, 2002)

20. Tremonti – “My Last Mistake” (from “Dust”, 2016)

21. Body Count – “Talk Shit, Get Shot” (from “Manslaughter”, 2014)

22. Nothingface – “One Thing” (from “Pacifier”, 1996)

23. Klone – “Army Of Me” (from “Black Days”, 2010)

24. 鬱P [Utsu-P] – “インパーフェクトアニマルズ” (from “Algorithm”, 2014)

25. Bring Me The Horizon – “Kingslayer” (from “POST HUMAN: SURVIVAL HORROR” E.P., 2020)

26. Motionless In White – “Disguise” (from “Disguise”, 2019)

27. (sic)monic – “Illumination” (from “Somnambulist”, 2009)

I have made it clear in recent months that I have never cared for Primus, nor do I predict that I will ever care about Primus. They have always turned me off with their "look how quirky we are!" mentality to writing music that I just tune out. With Faith No More, you can still hear the cheese and it is on full display in the music, but I have always felt like, and with this album in particular, there has been some reality or seriousness attuned to it. And I have really enjoyed trying to pick it apart. As for the music itself, it is some of the best funk metal I have ever heard and helped lay a framework that most of us attribute to Rage Against the Machine. I really like most of the genre blending that takes place and all of it is crafted with the same amount of care; nothing sounds forced or underperformed. Very solid stuff.

9/10

https://open.spotify.com/playlist/4pMcw6OlTE81lj6gC4Gi5d?si=5ooW6dxBQHuE1xxeELMvwg

Tracklisting: 

01. Deftones – “Genesis” (from “Ohms”, 2020) 

02. Mudvayne – “Death Blooms” (from “L.D. 50”, 2000) 

03. Rage Against The Machine – “People Of The Sun” (from “Evil Empire”, 1996) 

04. Biohazard & Onyx – “Judgement Night” (from “Judgement Night: Music From The motion Picture”, 1993) 

05. Fair To Midland – “Walls Of Jericho” (from “Fables From A Mayfly: What I Tell You Three Times is True”, 2007) 

06. Faith No More – “Midlife Crisis” (from “Angel Dust”, 1992) 

07. Alice In Chains – “Man In The Box” (from “Facelift”, 1990) 

08. Bad Brains – “Soulcraft” (from “Quickness”, 1989) 

09. Denzel Curry – “Bulls On Parade (Triple J Like Version)” single (2019) 

10. Hollywood Undead – “Time Bomb” (from “New Empire, Vol. 1”, 2020) 

11. Seether – “Dangerous” (from “Si Vis Pacem, Para Bellum”, 2020) 

12. Velcra – “Test Animals” (from “Consequences Of Disobedience”, 2002) 

13. Poppy – “Bloodmoney” (from “Disagree”, 2020) 

14. Dir en Grey – “The Final” (from “The Unraveling” E.P., 2013) 

15. Armia – “On jest tu on zyje” (from “Duch”, 1997) 

16. Incubus – “New Skin” (from “S.C.I.E.N.C.E., 1997) 

17. Nothingface – “The Sick” (from “An Audio Guide To Every Day Atrocity”, 1998) 

18. Alter Bridge – “Cry Of Achilles” (from “Fortress”, 2013) 

19. Exotic Animal Petting Zoo – “Thorough.Modern” (from “Tree Of Tongues”, 2012) 

20. Katatonia – “Ghost Of The Sun” (from “Viva Emptiness”, 2003) 

21. Tremonti – “Brains” (from “All I Was”, 2012) 

22. Machine Head – “The Blood, The Sweat, The Tears” (from “The Burning Red”, 1999) 

23. Avatar – “Colossus” (from “Hunter Gatherer”, 2020) 

24. Life Of Agony – “This Time” (from “River Runs Red”, 1993) 

25. Pleymo – “Blohm” (from “Keckispasse?”, 1999) 

26. System Of A Down – “B.Y.O.B.” (from “Mezmerize”, 2005) 

27. Coal Chamber – “I.O.U. Nothing” (from “Rivals”, 2015) 

28. Korn – “Rotting In Vain” (from “The Serenity Of Suffering”, 2016) 

29. Maximum The Hormone – “What’s up, people?!” (from “Bu-ikikaesu”, 2007) 

Hate is a strong word, so I'll say that I strongly dislike System of a Down. It's been one of my hot musical opinions for quite a while, and sadly it hasn't changed when revisiting Toxicity. I can see the appeal since, like Saxy said, SOAD reinvigorated the Nu-Metal genre in a way that only they could have. Their songs are manic and crazy, keeping the listener on their toes at all points with their constant swaps between stripped down, but still complex melodic sections and crunchy chug sections. 

There's only one problem with their style though; I find it incredibly, unbearably annoying. I can't point to any individual part of SOAD's sound and say it's objectively bad, like I don't think that Serj is a bad vocalist and their riffs hit pretty hard, but something strange happens when you put it all together. It's incredible how much willpower it takes me to listen to Toxicity cover to cover, since there's always this urge to just skip to something else with none of the riffs or sections getting any sort of reaction out of me. 

"Chop Suey!" is obviously a classic that's been joked about for almost two decades now, "Aerials" is always a nice one to go back to every now and again, but no matter how many times I try, SOAD can't win me over. I think this'll continue to age well for the people who enjoy it since I doubt any other band will be able to capture the same sort of style as SOAD has, but I'll be seeing myself out now. 

2/5

While I do know the Linkin Park track in question, I'm not sure that I've ever heard a track by System of a Down or Deftones, and I've never heard an album by any of these bands.

So yeah, it's worth noting that one person's musical journey can be very different to another's. Hearing anything by these so called giants is educational for people like me.

As I've said in the past when Lateralus popped up here, I was (and still am) a massive Tool fan and they still scratch a certain itch for me that no other band can. Their riff grooves and overall songwriting is unmatched when it comes to Alt Metal, even though they can go off the deep end a few too many times. Aenima sits below 10,000 Days as my second favorite Tool album, beating out Lateralus by quite a large margin. Even though the interludes are pretty silly and kind of unnecessary, I prefer how they're done in here over Lateralus' strange atmospheric drones that begin and end out of nowhere. For better or worse they're more memorable and, for me, actually add to the album experience. While Tool did try to go for humor I really think it's a nihilistic, ironic sort of humor that never really bothered me in the same way it seems to bother Saxy. 

That being said everything in-between the interludes is fantastic, with pretty much every song except for maybe "H." being a Tool necessity. The amount of anger and cynicism towards the world comes out heavily in Aenima and makes the complex riffing hit just a bit harder. "Third Eye" is a bit too drawn out for my liking, "(-) Ions" never fails to make me exceedingly uncomfortable even though I know that's the point, and "jimmy" is definitely forgettable compared to the rest of the album. That said this is definitely still Tool at (almost) their best, so the end product is still going to get high marks from me. "Stinkfist", "Eulogy", "Forty Six & 2", and "Pushit" still have killer grooves and fantastic, emotionally charged vocals that still hold up as being essential to the Alt Metal genre. 

4.5/5

Hi everyone. So we've been listening to your feedback on our initial Metal Academy Radio clan-specific playlists & we've returned with a slightly adjusted format for September in that we've focused a lot more on the primary subgenres rather than giving equal playtime to all subgenres covered by a clan. We've also started to make these playlists interactive as we're now taking our clan members suggestions for track inclusions with the intention of expanding this further as some of the less populous clans start to fill out.

Here's the September playlist for The Gateway. You'll notice that it's a lot heavier on the alternative metal & nu metal than it is rap metal & funk metal this time. It also starts out a lot stronger & more exciting. Please let us know what you think as we're still figuring out the best way to approach these playlists.

https://open.spotify.com/playlist/5J3efRNvm33LfWm2tstNMO?si=3KEljQY7T8mpSDdmkp3X0w

Tracklisting:

01. Soundgarden – “Beyond The Wheel” (from “Ultramega OK, 1988)

02. Ill Nino – “La Epidemia” (from “Epidemia”, 2012)

03. DJ Spooky That Subliminal Kid & Dave Lombardo – “B-Side Wins Again” (from “Drums Of Death”, 2005)

04. Faith No More – “We Care A Lot” (from “Introduce Yourself”, 1987)

05. Last Crack – “Energy Mind” (from “Burning Time”, 1991)

06. Bad Brains – “God Of Love” (from “God of Love”, 1995)

07. Tool – “Stinkfist” (from “Aenima”, 1996)

08. Finger Eleven – “Quicksand” (from “Tip”, 1997)

09. Puppy – “Entombed” (from “The Goat”, 2019)

10. Chevelle – “Point #1” (from “Point #1, 1999)

11. Spineshank – “Stovebolt” (from “Strictly Diesel”, 1998)

12. Deftones – “Bored” (from “Adrenaline”, 1995)

13. Body Count – “Talk Shit, Get Shot” (from “Manslaughter”, 2014)

14. Bullet For My Valentine – “Don’t Need You” (from “Gravity”, 2018)

15. Mudvayne – “(Per)version Of A Truth” (from “The End Of All Things To Come”, 2002)

16. Alice In Chains – “Hollow” (from “The Devil Put Dinosaurs Here”, 2013)

17. Junius – “The Queen’s Constellation” (from “Eternal Rituals For The Accretion Of Light”, 2017)

18. Mushroomhead – “Sun Doesn’t Rise” (from “XIII”, 2003)

19. Twelve Foot Ninja “Mother Sky” (from “Silent Machine”, 2012)

20. O.S.I. – “Free” (from “Free”, 2006)

21. System Of A Down – “Sugar” (from “System Of A Down”, 1998)

22. Slipknot – “Psychosocial” (from “All Hope Is Gone”, 2008)

23. Korn – “Oildale (Leave Me Alone)” (from “Korn III: Remember Who You Are”, 2010)

24. Eths – “Crucifere” (from “Soma”, 2004)

25. Sevendust – “Black” (from “Sevendust”, 1997)

26. Disharmonic Orchestra – “Stuck In Something” (from “Pleasuredome”, 1994)

27. Otep – “Rise, Rebel, Resist” (from “Smash The Control Machine”, 2009)

28. In This Moment – “Iron Army” (from “A Star-Crossed Wasteland”, 2010)

29. Ocean Grove – “Intimate Alien” (from “The Rhapsody Tapes”, 2017)

I was actually surprised by how much I enjoyed some of this playlist too, particularly the more intense stuff during the second half. In fact, I actually don't mind a lot of the heavier nu metal stuff which I don't often admit to myself. The funk metal & rap metal stuff is largely hit & miss for me personally & that Corey Feldman album is one of the worst things I've ever heard in my life & was very much a novelty inclusion. There's actually a lot worse I could have included from that album which is saying something. Who knew Corey had made a pop/metal record after he'd ceased to become even remotely relevant??

I'm really glad that Deftones grew out of this initial style. They managed to pick out the strongest elements and expand upon those, leaving the choppy Nu-Metal songwriting and terrible production behind for Around The Fur. While sufficiently aggressive, the guitar tone is pretty atrocious and each song feels haphazard and pointless, mirroring my thoughts on other early Nu-Metal groups like Korn. The smooth, ever-present vocals don't mesh too well with the style of riffs they chose, making the whole thing a pretty confusing affair. I also find a lot of early Nu-Metal like this to be incredibly awkward with all of the whispering and free-form vocals like in "Nosebleed". I guess these are supposed to be emotional and angsty? Whatever the intent was, it definitely doesn't work on me. There are some good riffs in here and it's definitely a piece of Nu-Metal history, but I couldn't help but get more and more annoyed the longer I listened. I'm really grateful that they smoothed out their sound to something way more unique and interesting in such a short period of time after Adrenaline. 

2.5/5

This is for The Gateway members. Two alternative metal releases in 2019, each from a band with an entirely different metal past! Which one has the greater edge? Choose one and explain the reason!

Got around to writing a full review on this one. After revisiting it again, I think it is on par with their debut but both succeed in different ways. I'm surprised at how much their sound matured since their song structure remained the same for their entire time as a band. 

4/5

Inspired by Chris Van Ettan splitting hairs over which genre an album from a different clan has (thrash or speed metal, death metal or grindcore, power metal or trad metal and sludge vs. stoner vs. doom), I decided to continue the DIS vs DAT activity with an interesting twist; instead of voting on which album has the greater edge, we do it with genres from one of the clans instead. Single-genre clans (like The Gateway and The Sphere) would be divided into hidden subgenres that some of us have heard of but are never listed in the site (for example, alternative metal vs nu metal, industrial metal vs neue Deutsche härte). This should be a nice interesting challenge for Chris and other members of the site. Got two or three albums from a different genre in the same clan and same release year but can't decide which one has the greater edge? Share them here!

There are some interesting opinions here which is what makes these monthly feature releases such fun. Personally, I think "Lateralus" is an amazing record & Tool's best work but it's not perfect. Unlike "Aenima", I don't think there are any weak inclusions however tracks like "Mantra" & "Faaip de Oiad" definitely aren't as engaging as the better material. "Aenima" isn't far behind as far as overall quality however I do  find tracks like "Intermission" & "Die Eier von Satan" to be pretty hard going. Minor faults aside though, they're both classic releases as far as I'm concerned & I've never placed their other albums (with the exception of the horribly underrated live release "Salival") into that category. 4.5/5 each from me.

Primus' debut record is about everything you would expect out of Primus, from the technical but downright funky Les Claypool bass lines to the overall weird atmosphere this album gives off. From an objective musical standpoint this album is incredible, with the guitar, bass, and drums playing very complex and well written passages that have incredible coordination with each other. I've obviously listened to Primus before, but I've never sat through an entire album of theirs, and while their gimmicky weirdness does start to wane after a few songs, I was surprised at how much I ended up liking this album. There are a few duds, but no one does heavy, funky, and nasty slap bass lines quite like Mr. Claypool in this kind of genre. Obviously slap bass gets used in Jazz to similar and even more outrageous effect, but it's refreshing to hear bass used so well in Alternative music like this. I feel like this record could grow on me even more, so I'm going to throw a 4/5 on it. 

As for the discussion that's going on above me, it's a very interesting one for this album. I'm in agreement with Daniel's toolbox analogy; a Metal release should be judged on how many Metal elements it consistently uses. But that can come down to musical theory as well as overall composition. The more I write and figure out my review style, the more I wish I studied a little bit more music theory, because that sort of knowledge helps in being more objective about music, for better or worse. Metal tends to have much more dissonance than Rock/Hard Rock, and that all depends on the types of chords and scales used, which give Metal its signature dark/evil/grating sound. Obviously other genres that aren't metal use minor scales, but couple that note choice with a lot of gain from your gear, crank that volume up, and suddenly you have something that sounds like metal. Frizzle Fry does have those dissonant chords plus driving and loud riffs, especially on the signature track "John The Fisherman", but I agree that it's hard to definitively say that it's distinctly Metal. While you can call it "Funk Metal", it can easily be called "Progressive Hard Rock With Slap Bass". Funk Metal itself doesn't have much ground to stand on in my opinion, especially since upon further research the main bands for it are apparently Red Hot Chili Peppers, Jane's Addiction, Rage Against the Machine, Faith No More, and of course Primus. I'm guessing people felt the need to distinguish bands that used slap bass or bass heavy elements from other Alternative Metal/Rock bands? Because I wouldn't really call any of those particular bands as mainly "Funk Metal". 

In any case I'm also with Saxy in that I never want to be one of those people who judge an album based on how much gain the band puts on their guitar. It's silly to judge albums on genre placement alone, even though it can be a fun discussion for these kinds of albums that sit on the edge of many, many genre classifications. If I was able to cast my vote in the Hall, though, I'd have to say this belongs in non-metal. 

I'll cast another vote for Dirt. Angel Dust is an interesting album, but it never really clicked with me. But Stayley's great vocals and Cantrell's outstanding riff-smithing work wonderfully together.

Dirt 2 - Angel Dust 1

Hashed out a review for this one as well even though I've never been a KoRn fan whatsoever. I have a pretty...aggressive opinion at the end that was very hard to write in a way that didn't call fans of KoRn out, but I still stand by that this album just feels like more of a personal project for singer Jonathan Davis than anything. 

Sometimes you just gotta yell into a creative void to help you get over your problems, and his experiences just happened to resonate with a large group of younger people at the time. I honestly really dislike KoRn, but I can't act like the start of Nu-Metal wasn't an important stepping stone to the other...questionable modern metal trends that have popped up from the 2000's onward. 

1.5/5

Threw up a review as well. I listened to The Battle of Los Angeles a lot many years ago, but never checked out this full album. 

I think what bumped up the score (4 out of 5) for me was the amount of creativity in this compared to Battle of LA. Rage has been and always will be pretty monotonous with their one-note choruses and overused buildups, but this one has a ton of neat solos, sound effects, and bass lines that keep it much more interesting than any of their other albums for me. Plus this is probably the most angry de la Rocha has sounded on any of their albums. 

This was, surprisingly, my very first look at Deftones, I don't think I've ever heard a single song by them unless there's one from White Pony. I can't say I'm a massive fan but there's definitely something here for me with the noisy and punky riffs they throw down. I listened to a lot of Chevelle a few years ago and after checking this out I can definitely say that Chevelle are budget Deftones. These guys do what Chevelle and other bands like them want to do, but just don't quite get to the level of something like this. The...intimately evocative vocal style sort of puts me off after a while but it does fit with the noisy aspect of the album, so maybe I just need to give it a few more listens to really nail down the overall feel of the album. Definitely going to have to check out White Pony sometime in the next couple of days to get the full story here.  

I got into rock/metal in 1999, at the age of 12, so kinda grew up during the heyday of nu metal when Kerrang TV was new and metal bands were topping the charts! 

Post you clan-specific top 10 lists for 2019 here.

I'm with you Xephyr. I always wanted to like this album as I'm a huge fan of Faith No More. But it doesn't come close to the genius that follows, and the vocals are a big reason for that.

I can't see them doing it purely for the money. I mean they've likely been offered a ridiculous amount of money over the years but have always turned it down.... until now. Hhhmmm… it doesn't reek of financial desperation to me. It seems more like unfinished business.

Tell us which Gateway-related bands & releases you regard as either heavily overrated or cruelly underrated.

Here's some information I stole from The Blast:

Ex-KORN drummer David Silveria has countersued the group, claiming his former bandmates owe him almost a million dollars. 

The 46-year-old musician, who left KORN in late 2006, sued his former bandmates in February 2015, claiming that his exit from the group was merely a hiatus and that he was rebuffed when he tried to return to the band in 2013. Silveria said he still had ownership interest in KORN and asked a judge to force the band to reveal how much money they've made since he left so that he can get his rightful share. KORN countersued and the two sides reached an agreement in 2016 that called for Silveria to give up his rights to KORN royalties going forward in exchange for a lump sum. 

But Silveria now claims his 2016 agreement with KORN "omitted any reference to the 2003 agreement between the partnership and SoundExchange," which administers royalties from non-interactive streaming recordings. "The Settlement Agreement was also silent on the issue of how SoundExchange royalties were to be apportioned." 

KORN sued Silveria last month, claiming that he contacted SoundExchange in July 2018 saying he was entitled to his cut. The band said they informed Silveria that this was in direct violation of the settlement agreement he reached and to withdraw his claim to SoundExchange. Silveria apparently did not do so, causing SoundExchange to place a hold on all payouts related to KORN.   

In his countersuit, Silveria claims he was unaware the band had been receiving money from SoundExchange since 2003 and alleges KORN's deal with SoundExchange was entered into without his knowledge. He claims the band concealed the deal and the payments from him and now he is after what he believes he is owed. 

He is suing for breach of contract, among other things, and is asking for damages in excess of $750,000.

Slipknot vocalist Corey Taylor has flat out denied the claims that he's defrauded Chris Fehn of money that was rightfully his. Taylor made the denial on Twitter, responding to a fan who responded to the news of Fehn’s ousting by calling Taylor “dickish.” Taylor replied:  

“You think that’s dickish, try being wrongfully accused of stealing money from someone you cared about, and having a lot of your fans believe it.” 

In a second, since-deleted tweet, Taylor replied: “Fuck I Would LOVE that”  to a suggestion that they get original Slipknot frontman/percussionist Anders Colsefni back in the band.

Maynard tweeted this update on the new Tool record this week:

“Update- Midway through mixing. Most likely be a few recalls. Then some arguing. Then Mastering, Artwork, Video, Special Packaging, etc. Best Ballpark Guess- Release date somewhere between Mid May and Mid July. More focused updates to follow as we progress.”