The Hall of Judgement: Black Sabbath - Vol 4

Daniel has requested that this release be submitted into the Hall of Judgement.

Request: Daniel would like to see Black Sabbath's "Vol 4" album removed from The Guardians so that it resides solely in The Fallen under the Stoner Metal genre.

This change will remove the Heavy Metal genre from the release.

Member comment: "As with Black Sabbath's first three classic albums, the age-old consensus that 1972's 'Vol 4' is a 'heavy metal' record doesn't stack up to closer scrutiny, at least not when you take into account the modern metal genre tree. If the album was released today as the debut release from a new band then I feel confident that it'd be tagged as a stoner metal record which is in line with my long-term feeling that it doesn't sit all that comfortably alongside your Judas Priests & Iron Maidens.

For the record, this is how I've tagged the album:

01. Wheels of Confusion - Heavy psych

02. Tomorrow's Dream - Stoner metal

03. Changes - Piano rock

04. FX - Experimental

05. Supernaut - Stoner rock

06. Snowblind - Stoner metal

07. Cornucopia - Stoner metal

08. Laguna Sunrise - Chamber folk

09. St. Vitus Dance - Stoner rock

10. Under The Sun - Stoner metal

As you can see, more than 50% of the tracklisting falls outside of the metal space however the stoner rock & heavy psych inclusions are also closely aligned with the stoner metal tag & there is enough genuine metal to qualify for the Academy anyway. Given that we've recently voted to have 'Vol 4' added to The Fallen under the Stoner Metal genre, I'd like to see it removed from The Guardians & the Heavy Metal genre so that it resides solely in The Fallen under Stoner Metal."

NOTE: Only members of The Guardians &/or The Fallen could vote on this judgement.