Review by Shadowdoom9 (Andi) for Within Temptation - The Unforgiving (2011)
When I was listening to Within Temptation and other symphonic/power metal bands over a decade ago, I thought Mother Earth was their best album. But ever since I've moved out of those metal genres into the more modern/heavy ones, my earlier revisit of that album made me not find the glory it once had. However, with my return to The Guardians, I've once again found my best Within Temptation album, but it's not Mother Earth. It's this one, The Unforgiving!
In my earlier melodic past, I didn't think The Unforgiving was super awesome. A couple tracks were too pop-ish for me back then. Now that I've experienced some time with more alternative bands before moving back to The Guardians, I enjoy them a lot more now! The album makes a perfect balance between epic and mainstream.
The intro "Why Not Me?" consists of just Two Steps From Hell-esque orchestration and narration by Dawn Mastin. That intro sounds like something out of Agatha Christie's Marple, Downton Abbey, or any other British drama series. Already heading into the band's different direction is "Shot in the Dark", including a new aspect that had barely done before by the band; guitar soloing. "In the Middle of the Night" is a catchy banger to get you pumped and jumping. The intro riffing almost made me think of "115" from the Call of Duty: Black Ops - Zombies soundtrack. Absolutely great vocals to enjoy there! Interesting how "Faster" is the name of a more mid-tempo song. When that track was released as a single before the album, it was the first sign of their new direction; the usual symphonic metal but heavier and more poppy than their previous albums like The Heart of Everything. That motive is similar to what Lacuna Coil were doing at that time, but in a better, more focused light. That song has really grown on me more than the other tracks, with its tasteful strength and less of the orchestral bombast bands like Nightwish seem to have relied on.
The exciting energy cools down for the first of a few ballads in the album, "Fire and Ice". Then comes what I still consider one of the best standouts in Within Temptation's career, "Iron". It's so heavy and epic, right from the intro riffing onwards. The song itself reminds me of DragonForce's "Cry Thunder" and it's better at that than those poor rip-offs like Warkings' cover of that song and Sabaton's "Union". Next track "Where is the Edge?" doesn't strike me as much as the highlights, but it's still a nice throwback to what the band had in The Silent Force. "Sinead" brings back the Nightwish level of orchestra while continuing the mainstream direction.
"Lost" is one of the few ballads I would ever truly love, filled with beauty, melancholy, and tearjerking acoustic/electric soloing. "Murder" cranks up the orchestration again, making something eerie and cinematic. "A Demon's Fate" is really fast and complex, making another memorable song. It's like the previous album's "Hand of Sorrow" gone The Phantom of the Opera! "Stairway to the Skies" is the ending ballad like in most of their albums. However, instead of just orchestra and vocals, the whole band is here!
There are many risks Within Temptation have gone through stylistically such as going the concept album route, going more mainstream, and adding in guitar solos. But the changes paid off! The Unforgiving is perhaps truly the most well-written album they've ever done. An unforgivingly fantastic blend of accessibility, epicness, and heaviness!
Favorites: "In the Middle of the Night", "Faster", "Iron", "Lost", "A Demon's Fate", "Stairway to the Skies"