Review by Shadowdoom9 (Andi) for Botch - The Unifying Themes of Sex, Death, and Religion (1997)

From Seattle, Botch was known for contributing to their development of the noise-powered mathcore genre in the late 90s. The band would release two albums before splitting up in 2002, though they would reform two decades later for a new single and reunion tour. Botch shared their hybrid sound with fellow mathcore pioneers Converge and The Dillinger Escape Plan, and would plant the seed for later bands like Norma Jean and Every Time I Die. During Botch's 20-year split, the members would go on in different bands like Minus the Bear, These Arms are Snakes, Roy, Russian Circles, and Sumac.

This unique ambitious sound can take on a variety of different influences such as Helmet and Black Sabbath, putting them together into their own. You can hear it clearly in The Unifying Themes of Sex, Death and Religion, a compilation of demo EPs released before their two albums. It spawned an extended re-release in 2002, entitled Unifying Themes Redux, with more previously unreleased tracks. Whichever release you get, expect some complex high-energy hardcore chaos...

The frantic "God vs. Science" showcases the metallic chords of guitarist Dave Knudson. "Third Part in a Tragedy" has some of those hardcore jumps that Norma Jean would later have. Then slowly they turn, step by step, "Inch by Inch"... Some slight industrial from Nine Inch Nails is added to the metallic hardcore that can be heard in Eighteen Visions. They've actually covered "O Fortuna" by Carl Orff, turning an opera song into a mathcore track. A little too much of a joke, but I can accept it. Then we slam into "Closure", which is from a various artists compilation. A true trail of noise and destruction!

"Contraction" adds a little more melody to the hardcore, though not as much as The Plot in You would in the 2010s. Then on "Ebb", Knudson paints his guitar notes on the bass grooves of Brian Cook and the screamed vocals of Dave Verellen. "Stupid Me" is kinda stupid in the cliche chanting. The drama is lost by sounding laughable. "In Spite of This" is the 5-minute epic with killer riffing. They never need to go Meshuggah levels of djenty to sound this heavy.

I suppose I can one day check out the extended Unifying Themes Redux, but as much fun as I had with the original, hearing a lot of this for 70 minutes might be wearying. Still you can witness how well Botch can do their music, giving you a great complex time....

Favorites: "God vs. Science", "Third Part in a Tragedy", "Closure", "Ebb", "In Spite of This"