Review by Sonny for Edge of Sanity - Crimson (1996)

There is sometimes a danger that progressive metal becomes a bit too full of itself, tending towards the bloated and overblown, in a similar way that prog rock did in the 1970s. However, when it comes to producing an album with an overarching concept that requires a complex narrative arc, then the versatility of progressive metal is profoundly suited to achieving the aim. Where it works particularly well for me is when it is utilised as a storytelling tool by bands from the more extreme metal genres. Enslaved and Opeth are two particularly brilliant examples of this and more recently the like of Blood Incantation and Monolithe have taken that route with some pretty far-out sci-fi themes.

Now I only relatively recently came across Crimson, but it is an album that can confidently stand shoulder-to-shoulder with any of those previously mentioned. Taking a really solid grounding in swedish melo-death with some terrifically memorable riffs and a chunky guitar sound, then drawing on more diverse progressive elements, both instrumentally and songwriting-wise, there is a genuine feeling of a story unfolding and of the listener taking a journey with the band throughout the tale. As a single, forty-minute track, there is always a danger of either being too monolithic or too complicated, but repeating motifs ensure the listener remains connected and the track has a feeling of consistency, whilst still driving itself forward. The actual concept itself is a pretty bonkers sci-fi story, but that isn't really the point.

In truth Crimson isn't overly proggy and this is still, at its heart, a melodic death metal album, but the gentle, reflective moments, complete with those impressively recognisable Mikael Akerfeldt clean vocals and the gothic interjections that sound like Andrew Eldritch is guesting, provide a satisfying contrast to the death metal riffs. Technically the performances are great, and the songwriting is not a sterile exercise in tech-death precision, but is warm, human and relatable. This is one of the most enjoyable progressive metal albums I have heard, with enough hooks to make even a forty-minute track memorable, enough riffs to satisfy that underlying death metal craving and contrasting tonal shifts via the use of disparate elements from outside of metal to make it a more emotionally engaging listen.