Review by Shadowdoom9 (Andi) for Brainstorm - Plague of Rats (2025)
In over a decade of me listening to metal, I had not heard a single song or album by Brainstorm. Not even my first few years of metal, when heavy/power metal was my main target. That's rather surprising, isn't it? After all, they've released 14 albums in 3 decades and are part of the German power metal league alongside Masterplan and Blind Guardian. The lyrical themes seem to center around Native Americans, and a couple tracks each guest star one of the two vocalists of Leaves' Eyes. Sounds cool in theory...
However, I'm not getting much greatness from this offering. The vocals by Andy B. Franck sound a bit strained, the riffing is generic, and the drums sound like they just wrapped paper over some opened food cans and called it a day. Maybe I would've loved this a lot more 10 years ago when I was a not-so-firm power metal-loving teen.
The "Intro" (embedded to the next track in some editions) has some nice synths and a western vibe, which sounds like a promising start. Then the generic action begins in the first full song "Beyond Enemy Lines" (actually its second single), becoming instantly forgettable. It just doesn't have the memorability of other power metal bands I still enjoy and remember. The soloing doesn't pack that much of a punch, but it's one thing I can remember until the end. Having better rhythm is the next track and first single "Garuda (Eater of Snakes)", sounding quite exotic in the hooks. Despite some slight monotony, it still stands out as well! Unlike a few tracks we'll skip here. More of those native elements appear in "The Shepherd Girl (Gitavoginda)", although the bland commercial writing ruins the beauty of the music.
The song that features Leaves' Eyes clean vocalist Elina Siirala, "Your Soul That Lingers in Me", is actually a great improvement. Her impressive vocals blow away most of those tough issues. Awesome! But on the other hand, Leaves' Eyes keyboardist/harsh vocalist Alex Krull's guest spot in "From Hell" has made me cringe. His vocal contrast with Franck is far too much of a stretch. And the guitar solo is barely memorable. All of that make an epic f***ing fail. An unnecessary throwback to 15 years ago when I was still into radio pop sh*t is in the riffing melody of "Crawling". Franck's vocals don't help much there either. I'm just relieved the album is about to end.
If you're more experienced and appreciative of power metal than I've ever been, you might enjoy Plague of Rats way more than I do. I only consider this an impressive achievement based on the fact that it's their 14th album. Only two of the 10 tracks (11 including the intro) are memorable standouts, while the rest are either bland or bad. And I'm not even gonna check out that Rick Springfield cover in the Digipak edition. I prefer to get my English-sung German metal elsewhere. Good day, sirs....
Favorites (only true standouts): "Garuda (Eater of Snakes)", "Your Soul That Lingers in Me"