Review by Saxy S for Megadeth - Rust in Peace (1990)

Before I started listening to music on a critical level, I begrudgingly enjoyed a couple of Megadeth's early records because all of my friends hated Metallica. I knew about Dave Mustaine's history with Metallica and, of course, the drastic style changes of thrash metal between the two bands. I think most people who enjoy the early Megadeth records (Killing is My Business through Rust in Peace) like how uptempo they are, the riffage and the solos. No one in their right mind is listening to a Megadeth record for the lyrical themes.

Now that I am older and have listened to a lot more music, I find Megadeth are just plain boring. When I listen to thrash in 2025, my go to classic names are Metallica, Testament, and Kreator, while bands like Slayer and Megadeth lose me every time. As for Rust in Peace in particular, I can provide credit where it is due, for a late 1980s thrash album, this is produced wonderfully (amendment: I am listening to the 2004 remix version of the album). Besides the messy guitar solos, every instrumental part is articulate and David Ellefson's bass lines are given a lot of presence to give the songs on this record huge momentum. And even though I've never really enjoyed Dave Mustaine's vocals, this early 19990s era of Megadeth, including albums like Rust in Peace and Countdown to Extinction are some of my favourite vocals timbre's of his.

But now we get to the juicy parts. I know my opinions on thrash metal are far from conventional, considering I have gone on record multiple times and said that Reign in Blood is the weakest of the big four 1980s thrash albums. Like with that album, Rust in Peace represents a tired trend in thrash that does not resonate with me. That trend being a complete disregard for writing memorable hooks and instead making a rif-fest and hoping for the good favour of the neoclassical fans with endless guitar solo wanking. I'm no pop apologist who thinks that guitar solos don't belong in music, but they have to be tasteful and Megadeth filling each song to the brim with blistering solos is the antithesis of tasteful.

The compositions are also very patchy. Both of the albums bookends "Holy Wars... The Punishment Due" and "Rust in Peace... Polaris" are divided into two distinct passages that do not belong together. I hated the constant increase of intensity on "Hangar 18" as well. The sequencing does stable out during the albums middle portion with "Take No Prisoners" and "Lucretia" having a decent form, strong groove and less intrusive soloing. And I cannot deny that the first half of "Rust in Peace... Polaris" is really great. But when it comes to sequencing, because Megadeth don't modulate any of their songs to different key centers, after a brief period of time, even the records more infectious riffs become a chore since we've already heard them earlier in the album. "Poison Was the Cure" borrows heavily from the first section of "Holy Wars... The Punishment Due" while the finale of "Rust In Peace... Polaris" sounds really cool, it can't help but but use a similar tempo and key as "Take No Prisoners".

I cannot state it enough times for risk of getting crucified that thrash is a hard sell for me. I don't hate the genre, but I am disappointed in what it has become. As thrash moved further and further away from its speed metal roots with Slayer's Show No Mercy, early Helloween and Venom, melody becomes an afterthought in the genre. And no thrash band of the 1980s suffers from this more than Megadeth. Metallica seemed to do just fine during their legendary run, which is likely why Mustaine left the group in the first place. Rust in Peace is an album that should have been put to bed a long time ago.

Best Songs: Take No Prisoners, Lucretia, Tornado of Souls