Review by Daniel for Commander - The High 'n' Mighty (1987)

It's always exciting when one of our more well-educated members nominates a feature release from an artist that I'm completely unaware of, particularly when they also announce that it's somewhat of a favourite of theirs & that's been the case with the 1987 debut album & sole release from Los Angeles four-piece Commander. One look at the sword-adorned cover artwork gave me a fair indication that "The High 'n' Mighty" might play in the more epic US power metal space too & that's generally my sweet spot when it comes to The Guardians so I thought I'd take a step outside of my comfort zone by reviewing a The Guardians feature release for the first time in a while. I'm glad I did too as I got some enjoyment out of this record, even if it may not be enough to see me returning to it in the future.

Commander's debut sports a production job that suits the material very well. It's got a raw, mid-80's edge to it that I'd suggest fits nicely within the vinyl format but it also contains a powerful guitar sound that is really effective for this brand of metal which sees these Americans attempting a combination of US power metal & traditional heavy metal sounds, thankfully never touching on the European power metal sound that I struggle so much with at times. There's no doubt that Commander were consciously going for an epic feel on some of this material & they pull it off quite well for the most part. The guitar work of Dave Macias is excellent & is the major drawcard here in my opinion. He doesn't try for anything particularly original but pulls off everything he attempts with confidence as he was clearly an accomplished musician. He needed to be too because he had some ground to catch up given the patchy performance from operatic front man Jon Natisch whose soaring higher register delivery openly showcases his vocal flaws with a number of pitchy moments scattered across the tracklisting, Sure, he can pull off some ear-piercing screams at times but he can also make me feel like someone's running their fingernails down a chalkboard at others. It's kinda weird that his performance is perfectly fine on some tracks yet we see him virtually ruining others so I can only guess that the limited budget the band had to work with didn't allow them the time to hide Natisch's inconsistencies.

Upon first listen, I have to say that I really struggled & the reason for that is the strange way that Commander have ordered their tracklisting. I'm conscious that Karl mentioned that opening track "Knights of the Round Table" is one of his all-time favourites but I found it to be almost unlistenable personally & easily the weakest track of the nine included so I guess it comes down to personal taste. It was a bad way to start the album as it saw me getting my guard up early which likely resulted in me not picking up on the increased quality over the next couple of tracks. There's a flat period through the middle of the album too with neither of "We're Ready" or "Terror" doing a lot for me. Thankfully though, the back end of the tracklisting saw me starting to see some promise in "The High 'n' Mighty" & by the time I'd given the record a couple more listens I felt that I was better able to distinguish its strengths & weaknesses.

As you can probably tell from my previous statements, it's pretty clear that I find "The High 'n' Mighty" to be an inconsistent release with the quality levels spanning the full width of my ratings profile. The high point is utterly devastating in the incredibly epic US power metal classic "Die By The Sword" which is honestly one of the best examples of the movement I've ever encountered & saw me replaying that song in isolation a number of times. The title track & an excellent cover version of Rainbow's widely praised "Kill the King" are also of a very high quality, the more metallic format actually seeing me preferring the latter over the legendary original. "Wizard", "Return of the Goths" & "The Blade Shines On" are all pretty decent too but the three weaker numbers that I previously mentioned ensured that my overall score was never going to ascend as high as Commander would have intended. Unfortunately, it's Natisch that's largely responsible for Commander's shortcomings as I don't think there's anything wrong with the weaker tracks from an instrumental perspective.

Look, if US power metal is your absolute favourite brand of metal then you'll probably want to hear "The High 'n' Mighty" at some point but I think it's also pretty clear as to why I hadn't heard of Commander before because their shortcomings leave them struggling to break out of the third tier for the most part. This is a little disappointing when you take into consideration the obvious potential in this band had with the stronger material being a clear indication that Commander could well have produced the full package with a little more time. As it stands though, "The High 'n' Mighty" will remain a predominantly enjoyable release that's limited by an inconsistent tracklisting & vocal performance.

For fans of Heir Apparent, Hittman & Fifth Angel.