Review by Daniel for Burning Witch - Crippled Lucifer (1998)
Despite all my years of committed exploration into the metal genre, it still has a habit of surprising me quite regularly with releases that I've thus far overlooked but that very much demand to be heard. The 1998 compilation album "Crippled Lucifer" from Seattle's Burning Witch is one of the better examples of that concept that you're gonna find as it's a fucking pearler. Burning Witch were formed out of the ashes of death doom metal act Thorr's Hammer (whose 1996 "Dommedagsnatt" demo tape I'm a big fan of) & included the legendary Stephen O'Malley (Sunn O)))/ÄÄNIPÄÄ/Gravetemple/Khanate/Pentemple/Teeth of Lions Rule the Divine/Thorr's Hammer/House of Low Culture) on guitar & George Stuart Dahlquist (Asva/Sunn O)))/Goatsnake) on bass with Brad Mowen (Asva/Cryptic Slaughter/Lesbian/The Accüsed) & Jamie "Boggy" Sykes (Thorr's Hammer/Atavist) sharing the drumming duties on this release. The two 1998 E.P.'s that these individuals combined to create on this CD ("Rift.Canyon.Dreams" & "Towers") both offer a sound that's so cold & oppressive that it leaves virtually no hope left for humanity or existence in general.
The version of the release that I've explored kicks off with three of the four songs from the "Rift.Canyon.Dreams" E.P. which is probably the stronger of the two as far as I'm concerned, particularly because the first two tracks "Warning Signs" & "Stillborn" are utterly magnificent, virtually perfect examples of doom/sludge metal with hints at the band member's subsequent drone metal projects. The "Towers" E.P. is more solid than it is mind-blowing but it still contains an absolute beast of a song in "Tower Place" which I've also been forced to place in my Hall of Metal Glory, such is its immense weight & intensity. The production job could not have been better for this style of music with the thick & heavily down-tuned guitar tone sucking me in & slowly crushing me under its pure desolation & I'm often reminded of Melvins sludgier material. The vocals swap between a clean Electric Wizard style doom metal delivery & a savage & visceral hardcore one. I have a preference for the latter but I don't think this release would be what it is without the balance that's provided by having both.
Honestly, it was a big mistake to keep this CD at arm's length for so long as it's everything it's cracked up to be. The quality levels never dip below four-stars & there's a class in the execution that belies the pedigree of the artists in question. I fucking love this shit just quietly.
For fans of Thou, Cough & Sunn O))).