Review by Rexorcist for Septicflesh - Mystic Places of Dawn (1994)

Septicflesh has become my new favorite death metal band.  They understand proper application of symphonic and neoclassical theatrics, and it all started with their debut, which was built for expressing.  This is an album that switches from brutal death to gothic to death doom to symphonic black like it's absolutely nothing, and this kind of behavior is a major risk in the metal community as it can lead many to believe there's no focus.  So does this behavior pan out?

The opening title track has heavier guitars rather than drums, which feels appropriate considering the song's sense of despair.  It also showcase extremely sludgy vocals which remind you that you're listening to a genre called "death metal."  Out next song is Pale Beauty of the Past, which switches between melodic gothic synth-oriented sadness and raw extremities with occasional black touches.  It's a more "epic" track with a very different guitar style and a healthy progressive outlook on the constant changes that death metal songs go through.  This one song gives you every area of Septicflesh's love of variety.  It's almost like a Meat Loaf song.  Track 3, Return to Carthage doesn't hesitate with brutality, going close to slam and grind levels while boasting black metal tremelos that may be backed up by a gothic chorus.  There are even power solos that sound fresh out of an F-Zero soundtrack.  Crescent Moon is a much slower ballad, going into death doom territory with the kind of post-metal emotion you'd expect from Solstafir.  There's a simplistic side here that relies on the listener to be drowned in the reverb and melody in order for any theatrics to appear in the mind.  This song might be overlong, but it's a fantastic experience.

Chasing the Chimera starts out with a slower approach as well, but is more reliant on the deeper and more evil aesthetics of death metal.  There's also more room for melody, and this melody feels adventurous and intriguing, like something thrilling is about to happen to you in the real world.  Because of the stylistic and tonal choices, it feels like a spiritual sequel and even epilogue to the previous epic track.  The Underwater Garden continues this as well, leading me to hope for speed and aggression very soon.  It carries much stronger gothic elements this time around, using gothic guitars and heavy synths the like of which may stem from Emperor's sophomore album, Anthems to the Welkin at Dusk.  Thankfully, nearly two minutes in, there's a ferocious black metal section, leading me to believe the point of this seven-minute song is to be a magical journey into classical metal's various applications.  In fact, the middle section is just mocking you when it switches from death metal speed to neoclassical pianos and then combines the bass guitars with gothic melody.

Behind the mask is a three-minute symphonic black album which feels like something right out of Emperor's debut, if not for Spiros Antoniou's impressively guttural voice.  I definitely approve of this, having chosen Emperor as my favorite black metal band.  The fact that these guys maintained the Emperor approach while being themselves is impressive, especially since they effortlessly go into a death metal jam for most of the third act without losing the grip, before going back into the symphonic black metal but heavier than before.  Next comes a slow and heavy intro into Morpheus, which brings us some Therion violins to give us an ancient feel, a staple of several later albums.  This gothic / symphonic death song is all about that vibe, and doesn't waste any of the magic from previous gothic touches shown on this debut.  If the last track was Septicflesh's homage to Emperor, this is their homage to Therion, who used to be a death metal act before switching to symphonic metal, also with gothic tones.  We end with Mythos, an epic that first dives right into Prince of Egypt territory and continues into a classical world of war, magic, loss and victory.  Even though it's an entirely different genre, it keeps the best qualities of the album strong and healthy.  Great ending.

It would be unfair to say that Septicflesh were still developing their style, because they made it clear that they were fully aware of what they wanted their image and their music to be.  This album switches around more than a game of musical chairs.  I suppose the band took a massive risk when writing several songs that switched from every point between soft gothica to black death aggression in a whimsical way, but this album's identity keeps this aspect magical, and the album might diversify, but it risks losing the magic in that second act when it was being slow-paced for too long.  This is a bold debut challenging consistency by applying the right emotions and sensations to a plehora of metal genres, finally challenging the listener's dedication to the behavior of the band with a classical piece similarly composed to the most outrageous songs here.  Not quite perfect, but a masterwork in metal.