Review by Shadowdoom9 (Andi) for Within Temptation - Hydra (2014)
Blending metal with symphonics well since 1996, Within Temptation is one of the first 3 bands that made me up for symphonic metal, together with Kamelot and Nightwish. And unlike those other bands that I discovered via their earlier releases, I was hooked to Within Temptation via this album Hydra, only weeks after its release. The music is pretty good here. Vocalist Sharon den Adel sings nice melodies, though she doesn't have her earlier power that other female singers have. As the metal instrumentation stand their ground, the symphonic keys and orchestra lift it up in cinematic atmosphere. Beautiful, right?
I would've selected one of the band's earlier symphonic metal releases, since this one is beginning to show the band's rock side, but I gotta stay true in what I've really discovered. You just gotta admire how well the band can diversify their sound. Here we have a symphonic metal/rock sound that often dives into their earlier gothic metal and their later pop/alt-rock, all while making sure their fans know that it's the same Within Temptation as before.
The excellent opener "Let Us Burn" is a catchy start, with fantastic riffing and chorus, all in pure epic symphonic metal/rock that would surely please the live crowd. Former vocalist of Killswitch Engage Howard Jones guest appears in "Dangerous" which has an edgier modern heavy metal sound. This might qualify as my first ever metalcore association, even though Jones only performs clean vocals. "And We Run" definitely throws me off. Guitarist Robert Westerholt thought it would be a good idea to invite hip-hop star Xzibit to make an appearance in the song. I certainly don't think so. I'm fine with rapping in a few metal genres, but in symphonic metal?! Nope! I'm outta here!
"Paradise (What About Us?)" is an epic upbeat piece of symphonic gothic metal, featuring the operatic soprano singing of ex-Nightwish vocalist Tarja Turunen. Not only was this one of the first songs I've listened to by Within Temptation, it also made me up for Nightwish! The symphonic metal chain was just beginning for me. Then we switch to a slower pace in "Edge of the World", which has Sharon's beautiful vocals over cinematic symphonics. It's fine, but the slow epic pace I prefer is from DragonForce's epic "Edge of the World". There's some background growling in "Silver Moonlight" by Westerholt, in clear prominence for the first time since the band's gothic doom debut Enter. That song's a faster highlight though. There's some cool vocal melody in "Covered by Roses".
"Dog Days" is a little too poppy, which I find annoying. However, there's still some heavy power to make a bit of the metal still around. The 6-minute epic "Tell Me Why" is a full hodgepodge of different influences to go with their symphonic metal, such as gothic metal, power metal, and even melodic metalcore, the latter covered by the heavier riffing and more of Westerholt's growls. Still it can't beat "Paradise". Dave Pirner, the frontman of the band behind that "Runaway Train" hit Soul Asylum, sings in the alt-/pop rock duet "Whole World is Watching". Intriguing, but not really what I'm looking for. There's a Polish edition with Coma vocalist Piotr Rogucki instead of Pirner.
If we ignore the strange tracks, you might consider Hydra an enjoyable offering. There's solid song construction with strong variety. Some guest singers work nice and well, but others don't. And the atmosphere doesn't greatly catch your attention as it should have. Despite all that, Hydra is an album for new fans and die-hard collectors. Within Temptation could still stand strong and not lose steam, at least until their subsequent albums that would show a highly different era for the band....
Favorites: "Let Us Burn", "Dangerous", "Paradise (What About Us?)", "Silver Moonlight", "Tell Me Why"