Review by Shadowdoom9 (Andi) for Abnegation / Chapter - Abnegation / Chapter (1996)

Ah, here we go! A 1990s metalcore/deathcore release that has greater playing value than that other Abnegation release, along with the Napalm Death/Coalesce split and Downcast album. This oughta add a small bit of goodness to my search...

The 90s was a different time for our world. For one thing, thrash/death metal was withering after their golden age of the 1980s, and in its place was the newly developing metalcore scene on the rise. The two bands here, Abnegation and Chapter, both of whom would have a more deathly sound later, were highly influential back then but faded down into obscurity. This split EP was a very important display of adding metal into hardcore. They didn't need to be known by the whole world, just the right audience!

Abnegation began their transition from hardcore to metal around that time, and what helped out is one of their songs here, "Blanket of Black". This highlight shows more of a speedy deathly metalcore sound. This was considered the most metallic/Slayer-sounding any hardcore band has gone before. It was thanks to this band and that song that every metalcore band would start emphasizing the metal part of their template. "Behind the White Walls", on the other hand, continues the chaos, yet the shorter length kind of decimates its memorability. Still a great song to like!

Chapter is not really interesting enough for me to describe the songs in detail. All I'll say is, they play wild dissonant metalcore that would also take over the late 90s, yet more in the Rorschach style than Slayer. I mean, they sound more metal than Rorschach, but not as powerful when crashing in different angles. I prefer my noise-metalcore from the more popular Converge who would release the amazing Petitioning the Empty Sky. While Chapter is likeable, Abnegation has much better Slayer-inspired metalcore.

All in all, this split EP is an interesting example of metalcore beginning to rise, straight from two nearly-elusive bands. Abnegation's side is a more amazing offering from that band than the ultra-deathly 1998 album. If you're going through metalcore's early age, start with Rorschach then work your way to this split, then you know what matters....

Favorites (only from Abnegation's side): "Blanket of Black", "Behind the White Walls" (despite its short length)