Review by Rexorcist for Anthrax - Among the Living (1987)

Let's be honest, Anthrax is the poster-band for the standard thrash sound, but that doesn't mean they can't make good music, just that they're most likely going to be limited in their prowess as long as they keep things that way.  However, the title track tells you everything you need to know about this album: it's some pretty damn heavy thrashing, serious crossover attitude, and this rebellious nature drives the album for its majority.  A big part of the album is that, lyrically, it tries to capture the essence of its time.  Songs like "Caught in a Mosh": and "One World" make that obvious  Still, does this album really stand out in anyway?  It probably did at the time, considering that this was the most blatantly punkish of thrash metal's output that didn't completely steer into it.  Combined with proto-groove metal elements, this was a farcry from most of the stuff you'd get in thrash, including the fact that these guys weren't afraid of mingling hardcore vocals and shouting with the heavy metal wail you'll find in Sanctuary and King Diamond works.  The problem is that it hasn't really aged well.  It's still a fun album, but can I honestly look at this and say that it's a true piece of musical art?  Maybe only in the one vein.  Otherwise, it's standard.  Anthrax have an obvious tendency to write the same really good song over and over again.  In other words, despite how much fun the album is, creativity is at a minimum.  Among the Living is an album more suitable for playing a couple songs a time, picking favorites to put on a playlist because the energy and attitude are so good that the two get under your skin and into your soul.  But as an album there are things missing.