Review by Rexorcist for maudlin of the Well - Bath (2001)

So Maudlin of the Well have been on a fucking twelve-year hiatus, and don't even consider that MAYBE they're one of the most reputable names in the underground metal scene?  I've mentioned before that I wish there was more metal that would make use of jazz, like Unquestionable Presence by Athiest did, and one of the first things that comes to mind in this vein would be the Maudlin's album Bath, which starts with a chamber and jazz combo that lasts seven minutes before we get to the actual metal, and it's a gorgeous intro that builds up the Hitchcockian pressure of waiting for the metal to strike hard through its cool acoustic jazzy mood.  After the post-metal outro, we get a literal DEATH METAL song, and the group is quite adamant about emphasizing the genre this time.  But the thing is the contrast is a little too strong.

While the songs on this album will usually be between great to brilliant, this consistency thing is a bit of an issue throughout most of the album.  Although, there are some songs that bridge the softer side and the heavier side to help with the consistency, and thankfully the band plays with a lot of spirit and creativity.  I mean, some of these songs have this outlandish ability to turn weird sound effects, like water in a drain, into a thing of beauty and serenity with the right acoustic sand production to play with these effects.  And the fact that the band has such a strong sense of atmosphere means all of these songs have something very moody or serene about them.  Still, the inconcistency thing is an issue, and if it weren't for that this would be a five-star album.