Reviews list for Roadrunner United - The All-Star Sessions (2005)

Roadrunner Records is one of the most famous and diverse metal/hard rock record labels of all time. Famous and infamous bands signed to the label like Slipknot, Trivium, Fear Factory, and Machine Head have made the label as big as it is. And the then-core members of each of those 4 bands were chosen for ambitious project conceived by ex-vice president of the label Monte Conner...

Mr. Conner wanted to do a special thing for Roadrunner's 25th anniversary. He wanted 4 members of different bands band together to make an album dedicated to the label. But then he decided to upgrade his idea into something more ambitious... The 4 chosen ones, ex-Slipknot drummer Joey Jordison (RIP), Trivium frontman Matt Heafy, Fear Factory guitarist Dino Cazares, and Machine Head frontman Robb Flynn were tasked in each recording 4 songs (though one captain would have a bonus 5th) and choose any member of a Roadrunner-signed band past or present to record with them. The end result is a massive 18-song 77-minute album featuring 57 artists from 45 bands!

The modern thrash/groove/metalcore anthem "The Dagger" opens the album as the first one of Flynn's songs, and it already has a Machine Head gone Killswitch Engage vibe, which makes sense since it features ex-Killswitch Engage vocalist Howard Jones. A godly guitar solo played Canadian thrash master Jeff Waters of Annihilator absolutely tears down the house. An amazing kick-A starter track! The guitar skills of second captain Cazares the guitar/drum chaos of "The Enemy" after an acoustic intro by Sepultura's Andreas Kisser. With Cazares' riffing that is able to bring back that of Demanufacture without any of the industrial aspects, and the sharp vocals of Mark Hunter (Chimaira), you're in for another deathly thrash-metalcore treat. "Annihilation by the Hands of God" is full on death metal that showcases Jordison's stampeding drum blasts and murderous riffing. The song is OK, but a little too deathly for me, and Deicide vocalist Glen Benton's growls aren't that great. The diverse writing of Matt Heafy, back then a 19-year-old aspiring metal star, begins with the song "In the Fire". The sinister and operatic singing of the legendary King Diamond is some of the best vocals I've heard in the album. And we have an awesome guitar solo duel between Matt and Trivium bandmate Corey Beaulieu. An absolutely killer 80s heavy/speed metal standout!

"The End" features Heafy's clean singing in a wonderful hard rock/alt-metal power ballad. An incredible experiment by Cazares and Heafy that has paid off! And I'm glad that one received a single and video, the only one from the entire album to have those. "Tired 'n Lonely" is a much different song written by Jordison, like is this modern bluesy hard rock?!? Likely so, as if it's something Slash and Wednesday 13 would write! Life of Agony's Keith Caputo (now known as Mina Caputo after gender transition) has well-fitting vocals there. Still a highlight, but not beating most of the first 5 tracks. "Independent (Voice of the Voiceless)" has the fast aggression of the thrash/groove metal that can be heard in Sepultura, Soulfly, and a less industrial Nailbomb. And it's no coincidence that Flynn chose the vocalist of those 3 bands, Max Cavalera for that song. It's great hearing this Cavalera-borrowed bridge riff, though the rest of the song is a bit strange. Though not as much as the next one written by Heafy, "Dawn of a Golden Age", pure blasting black metal with the haunting shrieks of Cradle of Filth leader Dani Filth. This is only for those brave enough to explore the Satanic depths of black metal.

The next Flynn-written song is "The Rich Man", with Slipknot vocalist Corey Taylor singing as sinister atmosphere builds up along the way. There's decent bass in the soft verses, and then the chorus has usual heavy riffing of metal. A solid nu/alt-metal song made interesting with the clean verses and rough chorus. "No Way Out" is more of a simple alt-pop rock song. However, unlike Jordison's other rock song, there's way more melody than actual heaviness, and the vocals by Daryl Palumbo of Glassjaw come out so bad. I'm sorry, but NO. Then "Baptized in the Redemption" has more of Cazares' heaviness, and Dez Fafara of Coal Chamber and Devildriver. You can consider this a Latin-inspired groove/nu metal song, especially in the f***ing headbanging riffing at the start, and another guest appearance by Andreas Kisser in a pulverizing solo. One song that doesn't get mentioned much is "Roads", and that's because it wasn't written by any of the 4 team captains, along with being a much different-sounding song from the rest. Beautiful keyboards are performed by Type O Negative keyboardist Josh Silver and the vocals and acoustic guitar are performed by Opeth frontman Mikael Åkerfeldt. That's all the song has, but it's still pretty nice, with a catchy chorus melody. Another incredible song written by Heafy is "Blood and Flames", a sludgy groove metalcore song with powerful vocals by Killswitch Engage current vocalist Jesse Leach. A definite highlight here!

"Constitution Down" has heavier extreme drumming by Jordison. I enjoy it a bit, but that groove/thrash track sung by Kyle Thomas of Exhorder sounds a bit unnecessary in their attempt to tribute to Pantera. Heafy's last song here is "I Don't Wanna Be (A Superhero)", and... What?! I never thought he would write a two-minute Pennywise-esque hardcore punk song featuring ex-Misfits vocalist Michale Graves, let alone make one that's a true anthem to please my ears! Nicely done, Matt! The last one of Flynn's songs "Army of the Sun" is the most different one in that category. That one's more of a melodic heavy/alt-metal power ballad in a similar vein to "The End". The chorus and bridge is so beautiful, sung by Tim Williams from Bloodsimple and Visions of Disorder. Cazares makes one more move in "No Mas Control", which has the most Fear Factory-like vibe in the riffing for a groove/nu metalcore attack, as Ill Nino vocalist Christian Machado rages through. Not bad, though could've been better. Joey got to write a bonus 5th song to end this offering, and that final song "Enemy of the State" starts with the beautiful piano of Josh Silver. Adding more to the calm gothic doom depressiveness of Type O Negative is the deep singing of the late Peter Steele (RIP). The song is OK, but it ends it all in more of a whimper than a bang.

All in all, this impressive Roadrunner United is one of the most ambitious offerings in metal history. Although it is considered alt-metal, you can't deny the metalcore, thrash, groove, and to a lesser extent, death/black metal appearing here. Heafy and Cazares write the best songs here, and how can I say otherwise? They're from two of my favorite bands! No disrespect to Jordison, but he really could've written his songs better. Flynn is somewhere in between. Any musicians from at least one metal band you love and enjoy? They're all in this astonishing offering. Here's to another impressive project like this in the future, hopefully in Roadrunner's 50th year, 2030....

Favorites: "The Dagger", "The Enemy", "In the Fire", "The End", "Tired 'n Lonely", "Baptized in the Redemption", "Blood and Flames", "I Don't Wanna Be (A Superhero)", "Army of the Sun"