The Hall of Judgement: Shining (SWE) - V - Halmstad

Sonny requested that this release be submitted into the Hall of Judgement.

Result: With a result of YES 5 NO 0, Sonny's request to have Shining's "V - Halmstad" album added to The Infinite while remaining in The North has been passed.

This change saw the Post-Metal genre added to the release while retaining the Black Metal genre.

Member Comment: "There is very little actual black metal on here, although it is rooted in the genre. I think the album is far more related to post-metal. It focusses on creating an atmosphere rather than on riffs and blastbeats and has far more in common with bands like Cult of Luna and Isis than Darkthrone and Mayhem. As such I believe the post-metal tag should be added and the album also put into The Infinite whilst retaining it's place in The North."

NOTE: Only members of The Infinite and/or The North could vote on this judgement.