Review by Rexorcist for Pain of Salvation - One Hour by the Concrete Lake (1998)

I don't feel like doing another track-by-track review today, so I'll just cover the most important stuff. Hearing the actual music kickstart with a beautiful piano metal intro already told me there was a Symphony X similarity that might end up going through the whole album. As a huge fan of Symphony X, I adored the neoclassical piano focus. While I can't say this was "groundbreaking," I was certainly impressed with the healthy upgrade in balance between melody and progression, as well as a totally new sound for the band. On top of which, metallic moments seem to be a bit heavier and more layered, which was an issue for the more metal-oriented songs of the debut. The occasional industrial backdrops also help with that, as well as with more robotic guitar tones and riffs. And of course, there's always a little room for a softer and more contemplative song with some violin attached. But these elements don't often overpower the standard dramatic prog metal aspects, but rather add light influences for the most part. In fact, it's enough to make sure most of these songs feel different enough from each other to almost be different subgenres of prog metal. Handful of Nothing, for example, is quite mechanical in its handling of hardcore punk influence, never really steering into "metalcore," though.

I gotta say, though. Only about half the time the melodies manage to really impress me. For example, a wonderful collective of rhythms takes up the bulk of Home, but in comparison, a track like Water feels a bit empty. Thankfully, the former happens a bit more often. A track like Home is followed by an incredibly proggy yet catchy track like Black Hills, making for an excellent pairing. Hell, I'd say Black Hills even astounded me, managing to be better than the already grand Home. On top of all that, the various sounds and feelings connect well with the emotional focus of the theme, centering around the dystopian devastation and pollution of the world due to man's lack of sympathy for the world around them. The theme isn't very story-based, but it does an excellent job sharing the lead character's feelings of despair. Of course, it goes without saying that it takes a while for that hidden track to really pick up, about four out of six minutes. But once it does, it really does, going into some beautiful avant-garde that perfectly covers what the album went through in a very quick time.

Major improvement over the last. This is considered the weakest of the first four Pain of Salvation albums? I might not agree with people's general consensus on the debut, but the improvement here seems like a very good sign for what's coming next.

93