Review by Shadowdoom9 (Andi) for Trail of Tears - Existentia (2007)
Not often does a symphonic gothic melodeath band continue their winning streak building up with every release better than the last, but how else can I describe the music of Trail of Tears? Existentia shows the band going back to some of their earlier gothic roots with more keyboard orchestration and the return of female singing in some songs. And at the time of its release, it was what atmospheric gothic metal fans needed after The Gathering and Green Carnation were softening their respective sounds.
And holy sh*t, the heaviness is still up in Existentia! The crushing guitars and growls continue on from their previous album Free Fall Into Fear. What's different is, there's more of the soft drama from their earlier albums for better flow.
"Deceptive Mirrors" begins the album with killer riffing and Kjetil Nordhus' clean singing, keeping up what the band has in Free Fall Into Fear, before switching into the piano and female singing of the albums before then. The female vocals are done by session member Emmanuelle Zoldan, known as part of the band Sirenia, originally in the Sirenian Choir for 15 years before joining that band full-time. With that kind of contrast in this album, I had a grand feeling about it. "My Comfort" is also great with a catchy midtempo chorus. The song is a little restrained in its 4 and a half minute length. Oh yeah, every song here is within the 4-minute track length. Then we have the killer highlight "Venom Inside My Head", packing some venomous punches, as Ronny Thorsen's growls are in perfect battle with the clean melodies of Nordhus.
"Decadence Becomes Me" is a total rocker though the chorus practically pays homage to Candlemass' "Solitude". Then "She Weaves Shadows" makes a dramatic entrance sounding similar to Green Carnation back when Nordhus was still making that band heavy. "The Closing Walls" has wonderful atmosphere. I wish I could give the album the remaining half-star needed for total perfection, but unfortunately... "Empty Room" is a poor attempt at looking back at the early years of Trail of Tears and Tristania when try to put operatic singing and keyboards up front. But it's never really a stinker, otherwise the rating would be lower.
Next track "Poisonous Tongues" is a better gem. Lots of excellent drama in the bridge there. You can hear killer riffing in "As It Penetrates", with more symphonic synths and piano as Kjetil's vocals fit right in. "Shades of Yesterday" starts with some strange electronics that almost made me think this was gonna lead into something like Dead by April, but nope, we still have the last bit of the epic gothic melodeath for this album, and the last bit of Kjetil's vocals for his time in the band.
Anyone who has followed Trail of Tears and known its history would be aware of their initial fallout. The main members of the band who recorded the album besides Ronny and Kjetil were guitarist Runar Hansen, bassist Kjell Rune Hagen, and drummer Jonathan Perez, all 3 of whom plus Kjetil left shortly before the album was released. But shortly after, Thorsen would assemble a new lineup, including the return of female vocalist Cathrine Paulsen, all ready for a fantastic duo of albums. Existentia is still quite amazing though and it's for anyone who wants to hear Kjetil's work outside his other band Green Carnation. He and the other departed members have done their job well!
Favorites: "Deceptive Mirrors", "Venom Inside My Head", "She Weaves Shadows", "Poisonous Tongues", "Shades of Yesterday"