Fates Warning - Perfect Symmetry (1989)^{Release ID: 2309}

My favorite Fates Warning album in the John Arch era is The Spectre Within, but my favorite one in the Ray Alder era is the one that fully departed from their earlier heavy metal roots for strictly melodic prog-metal, Perfect Symmetry! While their progressive evolution would be shown further in their next 3 albums, it is this essential masterpiece that would make the band part of the early melodic prog-metal trio alongside Dream Theater and Queensryche. The melody has aged well, probably more than Haken would. The delivery flows greatly to allow the album to stand out well.

Alder's vocal range is in perfect balance, not sounding as screechy as in No Exit and not as tame as their later albums either. His high vocals have an easy tone that would help guide you through these abstract lyrics. The guitar duo Jim Matheos and Frank Aresti can pull off riffing that can range from heavy to ethereal. Kevin Moore, who was Dream Theater's keyboardist at the time, gives some songs his magic touch.

"Part of the Machine" is a towering opener, from the rattling intro onwards. "Through Different Eyes" is one of my favorite tracks here. There's so much melodic beauty here, especially when the chorus soars, adding greatness to a structure too simple by prog-metal's standards. The frantic "Static Acts" has Alder's vocals reaching greater heights.

Then we have the average "A World Apart", but even that song has great power. Alder's vocals continue to make the album the sparkling gem it is. "At Fate's Hands" is quite magnificent with soft beauty riffing while making room for some of the thunderous heaviness and progressiveness. My ears are quite pleased. And of course, there's that magic touch from Kevin Moore. I think the closest the band has gotten to their earlier heavy metal roots is "The Arena". It's short, more classic-sounding, and Alder's vocals sound closer to Arch. Nice though a little unhinged.

"Chasing Time" is another short track, coming out as an elegant ballad. It also has some vibes similar to pre-metal prog. "Nothing Left To Say" is a true ending epic to exemplify early melodic progressive metal. Alder sings his vocals with great passion, covering somber lyrics that often fit the dark mood. I wish I could describe this beautiful epic more, but I have nothing left to say.

Perfect Symmetry is a flawless classic for melodic progressive metal. It's quite deep with nothing too technical, and despite the tracks being shorter than in other albums, nothing's rushed. All is in genuine balance with no missteps. Between the underground No Exit and the commercial Parallels lies this gem. Indeed perfect and symmetrical!

Favorites: "Through Different Eyes", "Static Acts", "At Fate's Hands", "Nothing Left To Say"

Most people consider “Awaken the Guardian” to be Fates Warning’s shining moment, but the album that outshone everything else by miles to me is “Perfect Symmetry.”

Perfect Symmetry is the band’s transition from a fantastical, proggy almost-Power Metal band into a full fledged modern Progressive Metal band, and one of the first albums ever to conceptualize this sound. Gone are the tales of high fantasy and abandoned are the speedy and uplifting metal epics that iconized their earlier sound. Here, they have traded their swords and steeds in acceptance of the reality that the world is a cold, unfriendly place that eats dreamers alive. They have become part of a machine of finely tuned skill and technicality – here the whole band play incredibly complex parts, alone but in unison, creating a cacophony of different melodies and rhythms that never play against each other.

One mistake you could make in reading that is to think they have become technical cogs incapable of producing melodies of beautiful passion. This couldn’t be further from the truth. Vocalist Ray Alder commands his voice like an instrument, but never shies away from simply crying out the sorrows of being smothered in the constraints of modern society. The lyrics across the board sound like those of a man who dreamed of grandeur as a child, but had those dreams quashed by reality. The only options are to hold out a last shred of hope that tomorrow holds something new, or allow oneself to die internally in order to carry on.

The music knows exactly when to dance the lines between progressive technical showcasing, soft passages of pure beauty, or simply catchy melodies. The band does include some strings on a few tracks that harken back to their fantasy sound (interestingly, it’s the least bleak songs with this touch). The titles might also fool you into thinking they’re still a fantasy band – tracks like “At Fate’s Hands” sound entirely medieval in nature. In reality, the song is about being helpless to make your own way in a world where people are smothered to fit roles and voices of the common are not heard. The burden of a modern society is disguised by poetic and timeless words that could apply just about anywhere if not for the context of the album.

It is a jarring shift from their old sound. It’s probably not what fans wanted. It’s also entirely pessimistic, introspective and subtly conscious. To me, it’s the perfect album from Fates Warning.